LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More


Quick Summary
The Allahabad High Court has upheld a four-year jail sentence for a rape case, clarifying that complete penetration is not necessary to establish the offence of rape under Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code. The court found that even partial penetration, along with other evidence like the victim's testimony and medical reports, is sufficient for conviction. This landmark judgment reinforces a zero-tolerance approach towards rape and attempted rape.

It is a matter of paramount significance to note that while delivering its judgment in a learned, laudable, landmark, logical and latest judgment titled Ram Raj @ Lala v. State of UP in Criminal Appeal No. 116 of 1984 that was reserved on 30.10.2026 and then finally pronounced on 16.11.2026, the Allahabad High Court which is one of the oldest High Courts and so also the biggest High Court in the entire world has upheld the conviction of Ram Raj alias Lala who had been sentenced to four years of rigorous imprisonment by the Trial Court under Section 376 of IPC. We thus see that the Allahabad High Court has made it indubitably clear that complete penetration is not necessary to establish the offence of rape under Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). We need to note that the Allahabad High Court while dismissing a criminal appeal arising from a 1982 rape incident held so while making it crystal clear that even partial penetration can satisfy the legal requirement.  

It has to be borne in mind that the Single Judge Bench comprising of Hon’ble Mr Justice Abdul Shahid thus most commendably has upheld the conviction of Ram Raj alias Lala, who had been sentenced to four years of rigorous imprisonment by the Trial Court under Section 376 IPC. To put it differently, we see here that the Allahabad High Court found no pragmatic reason to interfere with the sentence of conviction after examining the victim’s testimony, medical evidence and other circumstances on record. No denying or disputing it!

At the very outset, this brief, brilliant, bold and balanced judgment authored by the Single Judge Bench comprising of Hon’ble Mr Justice Abdul Shahid of the Allahabad High Court sets the ball in motion by first and foremost putting forth in para 2 that, “The present criminal appeal has been filed against the judgment and order dated 07.01.1984 passed by the learned III Additional Sessions Judge, Fatehpur, in Criminal Sessions Trial No. 39 of 1983 (State v. Ram Raj alias Lala), whereby the appellant has been convicted under Section 376 IPC and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of four years. Since the appellant has been convicted under Section 376 IPC, he has not been separately convicted under the alternative charge under Section 376 read with Section 511 IPC.”

To put things in perspective, the Bench envisages in para 3 while elaborating on the facts of the case stating that, “The complainant, Vasdev, lodged a written report at Police Station Hathgaon, District Fatehpur, stating that on 10.07.1982, his daughter had gone to the forest to graze cattle, where the accused, Ram Raj alias Lala, was also grazing his cattle. At about 4:00 p.m., the accused allegedly pushed the victim to the ground by using force and attempted to insert his penis into her urethra. Upon failing to do so, he repeatedly inserted his finger into her urethra, causing bleeding. The victim raised an alarm, whereupon Shivpyare, son of Jairam, Ramesur, son of Mahavir, and Buddhan, all residents of the same village, rushed to the spot and challenged the accused. On being challenged, the accused fled from the spot.”

As it turned out, the Bench then enunciates in para 4 disclosing that, “The complainant further stated that he could not approach the police station on the previous evening and, therefore, went to the police station on 11.07.1982 along with his daughter. He also handed over her bloodstained underwear to the police and requested that appropriate legal action be taken against the accused.”

Do note, the Bench notes in para 5 that, “In her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. on 11.07.1982, the victim confirmed and reiterated the prosecution version set out in the F.I.R. She stated that on the previous day, as usual, she had taken her cattle for grazing. Ram Raj alias Lala and Prem, both residents of her village, were also grazing their cattle there. In the afternoon, they left their cattle in the shade of an orchard belonging to Shivviyara. While grazing the cattle, she sat beneath a mango tree belonging to Sukruva Pasi. Ram Raj alias Lala was also lying beneath the same tree, with his dhoti spread out and a thuha beside him.”

Do also note, the Bench then notes in para 6 that, “She further stated that after pushing Prem away, Ram Raj alias Lala forcibly made her lie down and attempted to insert his penis into her buttock at the place of her urethra and consistently inserted but he failed to insert. Thereafter, the accused inserted his finger into her urethra, causing profuse bleeding. He also tore her underwear and forcibly stripped her naked. When blood started oozing, she raised an alarm and cried loudly. Upon hearing her cries, Shivdhiyare, Rameshwar and Buddha, residents of Baihanan Ka Purwa in her village, rushed to the spot and challenged the accused. On being challenged, Ram Raj alias Lala fled from the spot. She further stated that she had narrated the entire incident to her father.”

Do further note, the Bench then notes in para 49 that, “The victim has specifically stated that the accused lifted her and laid her down on the tahmat spread there. Thereafter, the accused attempted to remove her undergarment (knicker), but when he could not do so, he broke its drawstring. Thereafter, the accused attempted to insert his penis into her private part. When he failed to do so, he inserted two fingers into her private part. Blood started oozing from her private part. She further stated that she raised a loud alarm.”

Simply put, the Bench points out in para 50 that, “The commission of an offence generally involves three stages, namely, intention, preparation and execution. In the present case, according to the statement of the victim, the accused had proceeded through all three stages in furtherance of his intention to commit rape.”

Be it noted, the Bench notes in para 51 that, “In the circumstances narrated by the victim, the accused repeatedly attempted to insert his private part into her private part. When he failed to do so, he inserted two fingers into her private part, resulting in bleeding. During the entire process, the possibility of some degree of penetration cannot be ruled out, although complete penetration may not have taken place. Thus, even if the act did not culminate in the commission of completed penetration, the conduct of the accused clearly demonstrates that he had proceeded beyond the stages of intention and preparation and had entered the stage of execution of the intended act.”

Needless to say, the Bench states in para 53 that, “It is well settled that rupturing of hymen is not necessary for constitution of crime and chances of false implications are too remote as nobody would like to do it by placing family reputation at stake. Rape leaves a permanent scar and has a serious psychological impact on the victim and also her family member’s. Reliance is placed on Rajendra Datta Jarekar v. State, 2008 CrLJ 710 (SC).”

It is worth noting that the Bench notes in para 67 that, “The testimonies of PW-1 to PW-3 with regard to the actual occurrence and the specific roles attributed to the accused person are consistent, natural and probable, and stand duly corroborated by the medical evidence. Accordingly, upon an overall appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence available on record, this Court is of the considered opinion that the prosecution has successfully established its case against the accused person beyond reasonable doubt. Thus, the conviction of the accused person recorded by the learned trial court does not warrant any interference.”

It is definitely also material to note that the Bench then notes in para 68 that, “The testimony of the victim (P.W.-2) is material and inspires confidence. She has categorically described the manner in which the appellant forcibly took her to the ground and committed the alleged act upon her. Her testimony finds substantial corroboration from the medical evidence furnished by P.W.-7, Dr. V.L. Raijada, who found the hymen of the victim ruptured, slight bleeding at the 7 o’clock position and tenderness on internal examination. The doctor also opined that the victim had been subjected to rape and that the injuries could have been sustained within 12 to 24 hours prior to her medical examination, which is consistent with the prosecution version regarding the time of occurrence.”

Broadly speaking, the Bench observes in para 73 that, “The submission of learned counsel for the appellant that there are contradictions in the statements of the victim does not find favour with this Court. Some variations regarding the precise manner of the occurrence and the part of the victim’s body involved are discernible in the statements recorded during investigation and trial. However, such variations, when considered in the context of the overall testimony, do not demolish the substratum of the prosecution case. The victim has consistently maintained that the appellant forcibly subjected her to a sexual assault, resulting in bleeding.”

Most rationally, the Bench propounds in para 74 holding that, “The argument that the medical injuries could have been caused by a fall on a hard object or a pigeon pea stalk also does not advance the case of the appellant. Merely because the doctor admitted a possible alternative explanation for the injury does not render the entire prosecution version unreliable, particularly when the medical findings are considered alongside the testimony of the victim and the surrounding circumstances. It is well settled that medical evidence is generally corroborative in nature and cannot, by itself, displace otherwise reliable ocular testimony.”

It would be worthwhile to note that the Bench notes in para 75 that, “The absence of external injuries on the body of the victim is also not sufficient to discredit her testimony. The nature of the assault, as described by her, and the internal findings recorded by the doctor cannot be ignored merely because no external injury was noticed.”

It would be instructive to note that the Bench hastens to add in para 78 noting that, “It is true that the prosecution is required to establish its case beyond reasonable doubt; however, this does not mean that the degree of proof must be beyond a shadow of doubt, as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Iqbal Moosa Patel v. State of Gujarat, 2011 (2) ACR 1897 (SC).”

As a corollary, the Bench then directs and holds in para 79 that, “Having considered the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel for the parties and upon careful examination of the evidence available on record, this Court finds that the prosecution has successfully established the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt.”

Resultantly, the Bench then also directs and holds in para 81 that, “In view of the aforesaid submissions, the learned trial court has rightly appreciated the evidence on record and convicted the appellant. Therefore, no interference with the impugned judgment and order is warranted, and the appeal is liable to be dismissed.”

Further, the Bench also directs and holds in para 82 that, “Consequently, this Court finds no merit in the present criminal appeal. The conviction and sentence awarded to the appellant under Section 376 IPC by the learned trial court are hereby affirmed.”

As a result, the Bench then directs and holds in para 83 that, “The present criminal appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.”

In addition, the Bench then stipulates in para 84 holding that, “As the appellant, Ram Raj @ Lala is on bail, he is directed to surrender before the learned trial court within fifteen days from today. His bail bonds will be cancelled, and the sureties will be discharged as soon as he surrenders before the learned trial court.”

Furthermore, the Bench then also directs in para 85 stipulating that, “Learned trial court shall complete the necessary formalities. The appellant shall undergo the remaining sentence awarded by the learned trial court, and the period of incarceration already undergone by him, if any, shall be adjusted against the sentence in accordance with law.”

What’s more, the Bench then also further directs in para 86 stipulating that, “In case the appellant fails to surrender within the aforesaid period of fifteen days, learned trial court shall be at liberty to take all necessary steps to secure his presence and ensure compliance of this order.”

Still more, the Bench then also further directs and holds in para 87 that, “Let a copy of this order along with the original trial court record be transmitted immediately to the Court concerned for compliance and necessary action.”

Finally, the Bench then concludes by directing and holding in para 88 that, “A copy of this judgment shall be immediately sent by e-mail to the learned District and Sessions Judge, Fatehpur, by the Registrar (Compliance), for forthwith compliance.”

In a nutshell, we thus see that the Allahabad High Court has made it explicitly clear that even a slight penetration can constitute rape. The Allahabad High Court has undoubtedly taken the most commendable stand that there has to be zero tolerance not only for rape but also for attempted rape and complete penetration is not necessary to establish conviction under Section 375 of the IPC. There can definitely be just no denying or disputing it!


"Loved reading this piece by Adv. Sanjeev Sirohi?
Join LAWyersClubIndia's network for daily News Updates, Judgment Summaries, Articles, Forum Threads, Online Law Courses, and MUCH MORE!!"







Category Others, Other Articles by - Adv. Sanjeev Sirohi 



Comments