Almost every week someone comes to the chamber with a dishonoured cheque and the same worry: "Sir, the person who gave me this cheque lives in Jaipur. Will I have to go to Jaipur for every date?" In most cases, the answer is no. But the reason is worth knowing, because filing in the wrong court can quietly eat up months.
How we got here
Many lawyers still remember 2014. In Dashrath Rupsingh Rathod v. State of Maharashtra, the Supreme Court held that a Section 138 complaint had to be filed where the drawer's bank branch was located. Overnight, a large number of pending complaints were returned to be filed again in other cities. For a small trader in Gurugram holding a cheque drawn on a bank in Kolkata, it meant travelling to Kolkata just to recover his own money.
Parliament stepped in the next year. The Negotiable Instruments (Amendment) Act, 2015 added sub-section (2) to Section 142, and it tilted things back in favour of the person holding the cheque.
What Section 142(2) says, in plain words
If you deposited the cheque in your own bank account, which is what most people do, the case goes to the court where your bank branch is, meaning the branch where you maintain that account. Only when a cheque is presented over the counter at the drawer's own bank does the drawer's branch decide the court.
So a trader in Gurugram who deposits a Jaipur party's cheque into his account at a Gurugram branch files his complaint before the Magistrate at Gurugram, not Jaipur. The Supreme Court later made it clear in Bridgestone India Pvt. Ltd. v. Inderpal Singh (2016) that it is this amended provision that governs jurisdiction now.
The "home branch" point people miss
One thing I always ask clients to check is which branch actually maintains their account. You may have deposited the cheque at some other branch or through the bank's app. What matters is the branch where your account is kept, which is usually the one where you opened it. Your passbook or account statement will show this. It is a small detail, but it is exactly the kind of thing the other side picks on at the summoning stage.
More than one cheque from the same person
If the same person has given you several cheques and more than one has bounced, do not scatter cases across cities. The Explanation to Section 142(2), read with Section 142A, keeps them together: once a complaint is filed in one court, later complaints about other cheques given by the same drawer to the same payee go to that same court.
What I would tell anyone before filing
Keep the deposit slip and the bank's return memo safely along with the cheque itself. In the complaint, put one clear paragraph stating where your account is maintained and that the cheque was presented through it. And do not delay. The complaint has to be filed within one month after the 15 days given in the demand notice run out. Courts can condone delay for good reason, but I would never advise anyone to depend on that.
If you are on the other side and genuinely believe the case has been filed in the wrong court, raise the objection at the very first stage, with the bank documents to support it. Raised late, after evidence has started, it rarely helps.
Every cheque matter turns on its own papers, so do take advice on your specific documents. What the 2015 amendment did, simply put, is make sure that the person who was not paid does not also have to travel across the country to chase his money.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice.
The author is an advocate enrolled with the Bar Council of Delhi, practising in criminal and civil matters before the courts at Gurugram and Delhi.
Join LAWyersClubIndia's network for daily News Updates, Judgment Summaries, Articles, Forum Threads, Online Law Courses, and MUCH MORE!!"
