Introduction
In a prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, where the accused intends to dispute the complainant’s financial capacity to advance the alleged loan, the accused should specifically raise that defence in the reply to the statutory demand notice. The Supreme Court has explained that the initial burden of raising such a defence rests upon the accused. In the absence of such a plea, the complainant cannot ordinarily be expected to anticipate the objection and lead evidence about financial capacity at the outset.
In Kuntegowda v. Thurubaiah, the Supreme Court also reiterated the effect of the statutory presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act and the limited scope of the High Court’s revisional jurisdiction when two courts below have concurrently recorded a finding of conviction.
Background of the Case
The complainant had advanced a hand loan of ₹4,50,000 to the accused in December 2010 for the purchase of a house site. The accused issued a cheque dated 20 March 2013 for repayment. The cheque was returned unpaid for insufficiency of funds. After issuing the statutory demand notice and receiving no payment within the prescribed period, the complainant initiated proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act.
The Trial Court convicted the accused. The Sessions Court affirmed the conviction, while modifying the fine. The Karnataka High Court, exercising revisional jurisdiction, set aside the conviction and acquitted the accused, principally questioning the complainant’s financial capacity to advance the loan.
Supreme Court on the Statutory Presumptions
The accused had admitted his signature on the cheque. The Supreme Court held that, once execution of the cheque is admitted or proved, the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act are attracted. The presumption that the cheque was issued towards discharge of a debt or liability is rebuttable, but the accused must bring forward material capable of making the non-existence of the alleged debt or liability reasonably probable.
A bare denial of the transaction or the debt is not, by itself, sufficient to rebut these statutory presumptions. The accused may rely on direct or circumstantial evidence, but the defence must be supported by material on record.
Financial Capacity: Defence Should Be Raised in the Reply Notice
In paragraph 6.7, the Supreme Court observed that the initial burden of raising a defence that the complainant lacked the financial capacity to advance the loan rests upon the accused and ought to be specifically pleaded in the reply to the demand notice. If that plea is not raised, the complainant cannot ordinarily be expected to lead evidence establishing financial capacity while presenting the complainant’s case.
The Court clarified that the accused may seek to establish the alleged lack of financial means through independent witnesses or documentary evidence. The accused may also rely on the materials produced by the complainant or attempt to establish the defence through effective cross-examination of the complainant and the complainant’s witnesses.
In the case before it, the Court found that the complainant’s evidence regarding investments and the financial assistance received from two witnesses supported the complainant’s capacity to advance the loan. The accused had not produced convincing contrary material to substantiate the plea of financial incapacity.
Important clarification
The judgment does not make a reply to the demand notice an additional statutory ingredient of Section 138, nor does it declare that an accused is automatically barred from raising a financial-capacity defence if no reply was sent. Its point is that the accused bears the initial burden of specifically raising that defence; the defence must then be assessed on the evidence and materials available in the case.
Limits of Revisional Jurisdiction
The Supreme Court further held that the High Court had exceeded the limits of its revisional jurisdiction by reappreciating the evidence and reversing the concurrent findings of the Trial Court and the Sessions Court without identifying perversity, a glaring error, or a legally sustainable ground warranting interference.
Revisional jurisdiction is supervisory. It is not equivalent to a second appeal and does not ordinarily permit the revisional court to substitute its own appreciation of evidence merely because another view may be possible.
Decision of the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court allowed the complainant’s appeal, set aside the High Court’s order and restored the judgments and orders of the Trial Court and the Sessions Court. The conviction under Section 138 of the NI Act was consequently restored.
Practical Significance
- An accused who disputes the complainant’s financial capacity should specifically raise that defence in the reply to the statutory demand notice.
- The accused should support the plea with credible material, such as documents, independent testimony, the complainant’s own records, or effective cross-examination.
- Failure to reply to the demand notice may be a circumstance which the court considers; it does not, by itself, replace the statutory requirements or make the presumptions irrebuttable.
- Once the cheque’s execution or signature is admitted or proved, the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 operate, subject to rebuttal by the accused.
- A revisional court should not ordinarily overturn concurrent findings by conducting a fresh appellate-style appreciation of evidence in the absence of a recognised ground for interference.
Case Details
- Case: Kuntegowda v. Thurubaiah
- Court: Supreme Court of India
- Citation: 2026 INSC 790
- Case number: Criminal Appeal No. 3654 of 2026, arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 2247 of 2024
- Date of judgment: 4 August 2026
- Bench: Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Relevant provisions: Sections 118, 138 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881; Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (corresponding provision discussed in the judgment: Section 438 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023).
Join LAWyersClubIndia's network for daily News Updates, Judgment Summaries, Articles, Forum Threads, Online Law Courses, and MUCH MORE!!"
