More views here;
https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/Legal-quiz-Religious-base-of-SC-ST-30289.asp?1=1&offset=2
*****
Originally posted by :Arup
|
"
|
a person converted to another religion can not claim scheduled caste status
- soosai vs UOI, AIR 1986,SCC 733.
|
"
|
It can be easily presumed that this judgment is passed by Manuwadi persons by misusing their position as Judge. As in every section of society judiciary is also captured by Manuwadis. The UP HC Lucknow Bench's decision on Babri Masjid is an example as how the Hindu judges have passed a baseless order (Everyone knows that it is an order and not a judgment)
Anyways, Arup ji, please provide full text of this order (it is also not a judgment) of - soosai vs UOI, AIR 1986,SCC 733 or net link. I will surely challenge it and will prove that this order is not passed "in good faith".
*****
Originally posted by :Ram Samudre-DRF
|
"
|
It is a fake logic that if a person who is notified as SC or ST if changes his/her religion so his/her rights to get their property back from the exploiters, who grabbed under pretext of caste/religion based discrimination, will be withdrawn. THEIR CLAIM STANDS GOOD TO GET BACK/RECOVER THEIR PROPERTY AND WILL BE STAND GOOD TILL WHEN THE SAME IS NOT RECOVERED.
|
"
|
*****
Originally posted by :Arup
|
"
|
" Is there any such criteria for scheduled tribe also?"
the straight answer is - no.
where the base of sc is religion ( caste available in hindu society only) ; st based on triabal area. hindu and christian both are available in st.
i have heared some mohamedan castes declared as sc at rajasthan. can anybody light on it?
actually as per constitution scheduling a perticular caste or tribe is the subject of state goverbnment.
|
"
|
Contradiction in this matter :
Whereas the caste atrocity is a non bailable severe crime against civil society, WHY NOT Hinduism is treated as the most severe crime against civil society which is the ROOT CAUSE OF CASTISM???
Someone please clarify this contradiction.
*****
Originally posted by :Ram Samudre-DRF
|
"
|
In view of the facts as brought out above, the Government should encourage conversion of religion from Hindu to other religion by the persons who comes under scheduled caste by giving them more other facilities besides reservation. Residential and agriculture land with cash prize of 5 lacs rupees should be given to them. By such social and national development programmes the India will become free from caste discrimination.
|
"
|