LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Rajesh Kumar (Advocate)     20 March 2008

Privatisation of Taxation Machinary

Indian tax administration machinary is probably the most corrupt in the world. Such corruption leads to harassment of the tax payers and leakage of revenue. To curb this menace certain functions needs to be identified which can be privatised.

It has been experienced in the Income Tax that privatisation of PAN application procedure has led to lesser harassment to the assessee, which has resulted into greater tax compliance. The endeavour should be to locate more and more area which can be privatised.

I suggest that routine procedure like- application of registration and issuance of registration certificate and receipt of periodical return and othet communications received from the assessee can easily be privatised. It will reduce harassemnt of honest tax payers and improve the voluntary compliance of tax.



 7 Replies

Rajendran Nallusamy (Advocate)     26 March 2008

Your suggestions sounds good. This will reduce red tapism and corruption. But who is going to bell the cat?

Rajesh Kumar (Advocate)     26 March 2008

Your approval of the suggestion my friend- when we will start approving things which sounds good, things has to change.

ACS.LLB. Gourav Khatri (Company Secretary)     28 March 2008

I sincerely appreciate the views of Shri Rajesh. As we are aware of Budget 2008 witness various new areas where quoting PAN has become expedient. Tax has been recognised as the cost of civilisation and where any person evading tax is an intruder and not a citizen.

Rajesh Kumar (Advocate)     04 April 2008

Governemnt is a necessary evil- and taxes is required to maintain that evil. The issue is "how to collect taxes". Government Machinary has established its corruptability, inefficiency and lack of foresightedeness in implementating the tax work- a new thinking is required. That is why i suggest that part of taxation machinary should be privatised.


I do fully agree with the proposition that ,tax administration shold be handled through private machinery.

Vineet (Director)     04 January 2010

I do agree with Mr Rajesh that overhaul is required in the taxation machinery. But is privatisation is only solution. Just ask somebody who has been harassed by private banks, telecom operators or any other such service provider.


There are certain non core functions which are neither sensitive nor legal which can easily be handled by non government operators on contract basis. Success of PAN management is one example (though it comes with a fee which was not the case when IT Department was handeling the applications). These non core functions lead to much of the harassment and as I understand Government has already taken steps in this direction by online filing, refund banker schemes etc.

Vineet (Director)     04 January 2010

But what about Judiciary and Police which have been rated as most corrupt in all studies and surveys. How do you privatise them.

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register