The chargesheet is a report that the police make following the conclusion of the final inquiry, in accordance with Section 174 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The report relates to the offence that the accuser is using to build a case against the plaintiff. This report details every step from the moment a crime is reported to the scene of the crime. To begin a criminal investigation against the accused, this report must be filed in court.
The First Information Report, or FIR, is an oral report that must be recorded in writing by the police station's supervisor in accordance with Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. An original copy of the report must be delivered to the informant, who must also sign it. When a cognizable offence occurs, a FIR is filed.
How do charge sheets work?
When an investigation has been completed and the police are confident that the accused is guilty, they submit a charge sheet to the magistrate. According to Section 170 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, an arrest may be made and a report sent to the Magistrate if the officer in charge of the police station where the first First Information Report was filed believes there is sufficient evidence or reasonable grounds to do so after an investigation. Additionally, this part requests that the accused be sent to the Magistrate for additional procedures.
Section 173(2)(i) mandates that the report be submitted as soon as the investigation is finished, in a format specified by the state government, and must contain the information listed below:
- the parties' names
- the type of information
- names of the people who seem to be familiar with the case's details
- whether an apparent crime was committed, who did it, and whether the accused has been detained
whether or not he has been taken into custody pursuant to Section 170
Following the filing of the F.I.R., the investigation phase of the criminal justice system ends with the submission of a charge sheet.
Currently, it is standard procedure for police to file a charge sheet once the suspect has been taken into custody. In a recent case called Siddharth v. the State of Uttar Pradesh (2021), the Magistrate declined to accept a charge sheet from the police since the accused had not yet been apprehended.
How do a chargesheet factor into any inquiry and judgement?
Both a First Information Report (F.I.R.) and a charge sheet are crucial components of the Indian legal system for opening an investigation into the accused party and gathering the information necessary to present the entire investigative process in court.
The following are reasons why filing an F.I.R. is important:
- An F.I.R. is a crucial document that lays the groundwork for any criminal offence because it is only on that basis that an investigation may be opened.
- Because the informant who gives a statement regarding a cognizable offence in the police station is presumed to have a recent memory of the incident, it is known as the First Information Report when it occurs.
- It is less likely that the information will be made up.
- The police launch their investigation as soon as an F.I.R. is submitted.
- A victim, a witness, or a third party who was not involved in the incident can all submit a FIR.
- The officer-in-charge questions the accused in cross-examination based on the prosecutor's statement.
Nonetheless, the following points highlight the value of a charge sheet:
- A charge sheet is a crucial document from which a criminal case against the defendant or accused can be started in court.
- It includes a narrative of the incident, the statements of the informant and the accused, and any accusations brought against him in accordance with the IPC or another law.
- The accuser learns about the charges brought against him via the charge sheet.
- Whom the charges are against must be present for the court hearing, even if he is not guilty.
- There can be no criminal proceedings without a charge sheet.
How may a charge sheet be submitted to the court?
After looking into the offence that is related to the cognizable offence, the investigating office will write out a charge sheet, and the officer-in-charge will then submit the report to the court. The court will issue a summons or a warrant after taking note of the entire situation. A summons is a formal notice of the requirement to appear in court.
Can chargesheet be quashed?
Yes. According to Section 483 of the Code of Criminal Procedures, 1973, a charge sheet may be annulled by the High Court. This section gives the court the inherent authority to establish any court as may be required to prevent the misuse of authority and to uphold the interests of justice[iv]. The grounds for reversing a charge sheet are as follows:
When the court cannot find that a FIR filed by the plaintiff against the accused has merit.
When the F.I.R. is full of false accusations and the court is satisfied with the results of the case, it means that the motivation for filing the false information was to exact retribution, disrupt the accused's life, or defame him.
When, in accordance with section 155 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, an F.I.R. is submitted without the magistrate's consent and does not relate to a cognizable offence.
The charge sheet for which the summons was issued by the court later revealed that the section for which the accused was charged did not apply to them.
As a result, the High Court has quashed the charge sheet in a few cases. As stated by the court in Joseph Salvaraj A. vs. State of Gujarat & Ors. v. 2011case[v], "we are of the considered judgement that the prosecution of the Appellant for the commission of the claimed offences would be an obvious abuse of the process of law. The FIR should be dismissed at the threshold given the circumstances.
How to issue chargesheet against government officials
The persons who carry out/implement various government plans and programmes are known as government officials. Yet, it is possible that an official will be found guilty of wrongdoing in specific circumstances. There must be a system in place to look into allegations of wrongdoing against public servants.
In accordance with the idea of natural justice, it is also fair to offer procedures in which allegations of wrongdoing against any authority are investigated in a fair and impartial manner.
The required protections are provided under Article 311 of the Indian Constitution, namely two protections for government employees with regard to their terms of service.
1) No authority below the official's hiring authority has the authority to fire the official.
2) A government official cannot be fired or demoted without first conducting an investigation that gives him a fair chance to present his case.
An officer of the government who is accused of misbehaviour is subject to disciplinary proceedings.
The Service Regulations and Standing Orders of the Government outline the disciplinary procedure to be followed.
A charge sheet is a crucial document for pursuing a criminal complaint against the offender. However, the law also defends people who are the target of false accusations
Join LAWyersClubIndia's network for daily News Updates, Judgment Summaries, Articles, Forum Threads, Online Law Courses, and MUCH MORE!!"