Identical statements and legal notice

Anand purandare (Querist) 15 January 2017 This query is : Resolved
Respected Experts, request your guidance in the below two queries
1) can two witnesses have identical statements. (looks like police did a copy paste job editing only the name part)
2) Can legal notice be used a an evidence. I am having a legal notice in which many things contradict with the FIR.

Follow Query

Report Abuse

R.K Nanda (Expert) 15 January 2017
state real facts.

Rajendra K Goyal (Expert) 15 January 2017
1. Does the statement before court is also identical? Has the same been crossed by the defense?

2. Accused can submit documents in his defense.

Anand purandare (Querist) 15 January 2017
Respected Experts,
Below is the brief case history.
I was recently accused in a frivolous 498a case coupled with 504, 506(2), 114 and DP act 3 and 7. Joyfully was able to secure bail for Myself and family. Upon inspection of documents, it was identified that statements of witnesses was exactly identical. I understand that no two people can reproduce the event exactly the same. It looks that the police had ready format and done only a copy paste job.

My wife deserted me and refused to come back. At such I sent a legal notice as I also had a daughter. All the attempts for amicable settlement were in vain. In return she replied to my legal notice refusing to join back and filed the fake case. There are many details in the notice which contradict the details in FIR.

Guest (Expert) 15 January 2017
Better Consult/Appoint A Very Good Senior Experienced Advocate of your Place since the sections filed like 506/2 etc could turn against you any time.Better Be safe with the Help of a Senior of your Place.

Rajendra K Goyal (Expert) 16 January 2017
The statement by the witness when deposed before court need to be crossed effectively to extract the truth.

Kumar Doab (Expert) 16 January 2017
Agreed with experts.

Engage a very able and senior counsel to defend you.

Dr J C Vashista (Expert) 19 January 2017
Despite the clarifications given by you, still there are missing links to your statement/query, hence cannot make out proper case and opinion.

What is the opinion and advise of your lawyer who has processed your bail "joyfully"?

Why do you seek second advise of experts on this platform except the fact it is FREE OF COST.

However, if you have lost faith in your advocate, change him/her immediately and engage/discuss/consult the question with some other prudent/senior local lawyer.