LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Bhavesh (RnD head)     26 October 2026

Legal recourse to seek parental maintenance from estranged nri son

I live with my parents in Ahmedabad. My elder brother is in US since 2007. He has totally reneged on his duty as elder son. He also forced us to go to court in 2012 to stop him from selling our father's flat that was bought in his name in good faith. The case is still pending.

My question is can we sue him, even if it requires involving an international firm, using the contingency fee arrangement legal/allowed where he lives but not here?

Please ask for any more details required to help answer my question.



Quick Summary
This discussion explores the possibility of seeking parental maintenance from an estranged son living abroad. The family has an ongoing legal battle regarding a property purchased in the son's name, and they are keen to initiate maintenance proceedings. They are specifically interested in pursuing a contingency fee arrangement with an international law firm, despite it not being permitted in their home country.

 8 Replies

kavksatyanarayana (subregistrar/supdt.(retired))     27 October 2026

You have to prove that the flat was bought in his name with your father's/parents' money but not with his own money.  Consult a prudent advocate in your area for guidance and to proceed with court proceedings.

Bhavesh (RnD head)     27 October 2026

Thank you.

We already have a case ongoing for ownership of the flat since 2012.

Our lawyer had said to wait for this case to be over before filing maintenance case.

My parents could've lived a much better life thse last 14 years had my brother done his part.

I don't think we should wait any longer given they're both above 70.

We want to sue under contingency fee arrangement. But since it's not allowed here I wanted to know if I can hire a lawyer or firm in US on contingency fee arrangement.

T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate (Advocate)     30 October 2026

You may note that filing a suit in a US court under a contingency fee arrangement will not work for this specific dispute. While contingency fees are legally permitted in the US, US courts lack jurisdiction over property located in Ahmedabad, and moral non-fulfillment of duty ("reneging on duty as an elder son") is not a legally actionable claim in any jurisdiction.

Under fundamental civil law principles globally, real estate/immovable property disputes are strictly governed by the courts located where the property is situated. A US court will dismiss any lawsuit concerning title, ownership, or sale of a flat located in India for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.

Ensure that your temporary injunction restraining your brother from selling, creating third-party rights, or mortgaging the flat remains active.

If your father transferred property or registered it in your brother's name with an implicit condition that he would look after them, and he has failed or refused to do so, the tribunal has the legal power to declare such property transfer void.

Your brother living in the US does not protect him from Indian court orders. India and the US are signatories to the Hague Service Convention. Summons, notices, and execution decrees passed by Indian courts can be formally served on him at his US residence.

Obtain a status update on your 2012 civil suit from your advocate in Ahmedabad to ensure an interim stay/injunction order is currently binding on the title.

1 Like

Bhavesh (RnD head)     31 October 2026

Thank you!

That makes the course forward much clearer.

The only question I have now is whether we can sue him for maintenance in local court. Somebody, not a lawyer, has said my parents are legally entitled to 10% of his earnings.

P. Venu (Advocate)     06 November 2026

Therfe is no such blanket rule. The facts posted suggest that query arises from pique than any real legal issue.

1 Like

Bhavesh (RnD head)     06 November 2026

Thanks.

As I'm not a lawyer myself, I know only that law is supposed to serve justice. Since all laws put the responsibility of raising children on parents it doesn't sound unnatural for same law to ask children to take care of parents when roles reverse in few decades. After all we're supposed to be better than animals who only take care of their children.

If law disagrees then fine. I was already living in a country that doesn't allow contingency fee arrangement which is entered into by lawyers and clients, probably adults, in countries like US.

P. Venu (Advocate)     07 November 2026

The question of legal obligation from the children arise only if the parent is unable meet bare necessities of life. The posting reveals no such situation.

Bhavesh (RnD head)     08 November 2026

I'm living with them(because the house is theirs).

They'd say they're living with me because I've been paying for their bare necessities and more since, at least, last 15 years.

Like I said my brother is in US & making at least 10x more than me and worth probably 100x more.

If law thinks nothing should be done because at least one kid is meeting their bare necessacities then fine.

Given this, and what I've learned here, I'm not even sure if they should sue him or I.

I think he owes them at least what I've spent over the years + late fee / interest + fine for loss of quality of life over the said period.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register