CAN CANDIDATE OWN MD THEORY PAPER ANSWER SHEET BE DENIED -An INI institution cited Sections 8(1)(e), 8(1)(g), and 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, 2005. They stated that releasing these records would reveal the identities of individual examiners, breach fiduciary capacity, and disclose third-party personal information
No, an institution cannot legally deny a candidate a copy of their own evaluated MD theory answer sheet under the RTI Act, 2005. In the landmark judgment CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay, the Supreme Court of India ruled that evaluated answer sheets constitute "information" under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act and must be disclosed to the candidate.
Why the Cited Exemptions Do Not Apply
• Section 8(1)(e) (Fiduciary Relationship). The Supreme Court explicitly rejected the argument that an examining body holds evaluated answer sheets in a fiduciary capacity. The evaluator acts as an agent of the examining body, and the candidate is the owner of the answers written.
• Section 8(1)(g) (Examiner Identity and Safety). While the Supreme Court acknowledged that revealing an examiner's identity could endanger their physical safety or invite harassment, it held that this is not grounds to withhold the entire answer sheet. Instead, the institution must apply Section 10 (Severability) by masking or blacking out the examiner’s name, signature, and code before releasing the copy.
• Section 8(1)(j) (Third-Party Personal Information). A candidate requesting their own answer scriptt is not seeking third-party personal information. Once the examiner’s personal identifiers are severed under Section 10, the remaining marks and evaluation remarks pertain strictly to the candidate.
Exceptions and Limitations to Keep in Mind
• Record Retention Period. The right to access answer sheets is subject to the institution's official record-retention schedule. If the answer sheets have already been weeded out or destroyed per standard university rules prior to the RTI filing, the institution cannot be compelled to produce them.
• No Right to Revaluation. Obtaining a certified copy or inspecting the answer sheet under the RTI Act does not grant an automatic right to revaluation unless the university’s specific academic ordinances permit it
