LCI Learning
Master NDPS 2.0: Latest Legal Developments, Best Practices & Landmark Case Studies

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Rahul (Engineer)     15 October 2024

125 crpc, false income affidavit filed by wife, countered by respondent husband with 91 crpc

Case Stage :

Pleadings Completed (Petition, WS , Income Affidavits, Rejoinder Filing is Strucked Off), Issues Framed, Ad-Interim is Continuoulsy bieng Paid by Respondent for child.

Fixed for Decision of Pending Applications : 91 CrPC , 340 CrPC applications Filed by Respondent Husband , Interim Maintenance application of Complainant. 

Brief : 

  1. 125 CrPC petition by wife Filed in October 2021 along with Rajnish-Neha Format Income Affidavit with Zero documents. Wife also Tempered the fixed format for her convenince for misleading, concealing and non disclosure of her financial immovable assets , bank accounts & other financials etc.
  2. Countered by Respondent husband as filed 91 CrPC and 340 CrPC in May 2022 along with clear and conclusive evidences for her concealments of bank accounts, immovable property doc , her business details, her past employment salary slip and records.
  3. Two family court counselings Mediations failed and 1 judge chamber mediation failed due to non agreement of alimony amount.
  4. After two final opportunities given by court to complainant wife (1st in november 2022 and 2nd in April 2024), neither wife is filing reply on Respondent's filed 91 CrPC and 340 CrPC, nor filing her needful documents as per compliance of Rajnish - Neha like financial documents i.e., Bank accounts statements, financial investments , ITR, IM Property details etc... 
  5. After huge efforts by respondent husband and blessings of GOD, Family Court judge mentioned in last date order that if complainant wife dont file reply on respondent's 91 CrPC , 340 CrPC on or before next date of hearing then adverse inference would be drawn against complainant.

 

Queries :

  1. what adverse inference will be taken by family judge against wife and upto what extent ?
  2. what is the law point to ensure that either judge direct complainant wife or bank authorities to bring the Right Tenure  bank statements i.e., from her income affidavit filing date to past 3 years (November 2018 to October 2021) ?  OR from 91 CrPC application date to 3 years in past i.e., (June 2019 to May 2022) and not of tenure from today's date to past 3 years.
  3. Apprehension of Respondent: Wife is perjurer here and acting smart as spent 3 years with non filing of needful documents by circulating, did withdrwal her money to unknown destinations and now the bank accounts are closed or having meagre amounts..  Target of husband is to get courts order of wife's bank account statements of tenure as mentioned in query 2 above.
  4. Can court decide Interim Maintenance without calling her bank statements etc. ? If yes then whats the remedy available to husband to ensure the bringing of needful documents on record with help of high court and under what provisions to challange in High court ?
  5. Annexed Allahabad high court and bombay high courts citations where it is mentioned that before deciding Interim Maintenance court must decide 340 CrPC application ?  Will non delhi High courts citation be bindings to delhi Family court ? If not then whats the remedy available to husband & under what provisions ?

Please guide....

dharmo rakshati raksh*tah



Quick Summary
This discussion details a legal battle where a wife filed a 125 CrPC petition with a false income affidavit, allegedly concealing assets. The husband responded with 91 and 340 CrPC applications, providing evidence of her financial misrepresentations. The court is considering drawing adverse inferences against the wife due to her failure to respond to these applications and provide necessary financial documents. The husband seeks guidance on the extent of adverse inferences, compelling the production of specific bank statement tenures, and challenging interim maintenance decisions if documents remain undisclosed.

 5 Replies

P. Venu (Advocate)     15 October 2024

Please wait for the Court's decision. It is too hasty to pr-judge the Judge!

T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate (Advocate)     15 October 2024

As rightly observed by the expert advocate Mr. P Venu, it is suggested that you wait for the court to take suitable action on the next date of hearing. 

Rahul (Engineer)     15 October 2024

Thanks to P. Venu & T. Kalaiselan Sir for your perusal of posted query.

Would like to know your expert law point basis experience on Specific bullet Query item 2 and 5. So that righful submission can be given to hon'ble court.

Please enlighten here..

Dr.Manoj Gupta   02 April 2025

Any respected Advocate can guide me, if a wife who does not disclose her property ( 2 Plots),bank statements, ITR, brand new car Varna, Royal an field bike, FDRs etc attracts 340 crpc or not?

mk_gupta_2000@rediffmail.com

Rahul (Engineer)     11 November 2026

This is Rahul (who initiated this thrread)

Development after my thread i.e. from September 2024 is:- 

In December 2024 Wife to save herself from adverse inference had filed twisted 91, 340 combined reply along with Partial documents (not complete, with admissions of her perjury and blame of non filing of documents initially in 2021 on her own previous advocate). in this reply she remained silent on her investments and bank accounts as well where she have had huge financials.

Husband on April 2025, had filed detailed counter as combined Rejoinder to her 91, 340 reply with clear cut pointed financial items (GAP CHART as 91 compliance for Rajnesh Neha affidavit) where she filed incomplete details and remained silent (i.e., willful silence is tantamount to an act of perjury) and she made contradictions to her income affidavit as well as to per averments to her own pleadings. Leading to conclusive admissions to perjury. Husband also filed apex court citation stating that she bieng MBA lady cannot blame her own advocate and she must be vigilant and responsible on her own pleadings, also as per vakalatname she indersigned that in any scenario she wont blame her advocate.

Post that multiple dates/ rounds of mediations happened but failed. 

New Judge arrived, but he on all occassions (3 ddates) pushed respondent/husband to withdraw his 340. husband did not do that. Matter was listed for arguments on 91,340 , Interim maintenance on multiple dates. But went in vain due to excuses by petitioner wife.

In Oct 2026 matter was listed for arguments on 91, 340 , IM. Wife came with new advocate, adjournment sought, husband again revealed her perjury by showing one of bank account deposit slip. Judge did not record same on ordersheet even the attendance of petitioner wife was not recorded.    

                      But judge in open court said to respondent husband that I wont decide your applications and on ordersheet became absolutely silent on disposal of 91,340, IM applications.  Judge had directed to DLSA to appoint LC/Comissioner to schedule and finish the Evidence to be completed before March 2027 and parties to come for final arguments, basis evidence report of comissioner. (Note: Suo moto LC given by judge despite of provate cousel appointed by petitioner wife. Also no consent of petitioner or respondent was taken before granting court comissioner for recording evidence.)

                     As pushed the matter to Evidence stage that too with Court Comissioner instead of following 126(2) evidence method. As what i learnt is in 125 crpc matter LC can't record evidence and it can only be done by judge as Family court act cannot overrride statutory 126(2) provisions by importing CPC procedures of Order 18 rule 4. {multiple citations researched on same of andhra paradesh high court etc.}

Now husband is thinking to file an appropriate misclaneous application to same family court judge to address and decide 91 , 340 applications first with speaking order basis the reasoning of with compliance of Rajnesh Neha and its dispute disposal in form of 91 , 340 CrPC Evidence is premature and cannot be started that too by Court comissioner and must be done as per statute of 126(2) crpc.

 

Various Apex court citations were already listed in Respondent WS that without full and frank disclosure by litigant who did fraud with court , that litigant is not permitted to be heard on merits and his/her case can be dismissed at any stage and she cannot be given any relief at interim or final stage.

So to make it matured evidence as for Petitioner no.2 (minor child), first petitioner no. 1 must comply with Rajnesh Neha true disclosures as per GAP chart given by Respondent in 91, 340 rejoinder table (including missing bank statments, mutual funds etc).   

AND court must first dispose the 91 , 340(established perjury supported with multiple citations that 340 must be decided first where glaring or conclusive evidences are on record), before entering into premature evidence stage as premature evidence will prejudice the defense of respondant during blind cross examination i.e., without Rajnesh Neha compliance documents of wife or without the disposal of dispute raised by husband.

Please suggest your valuable inputs here in support of husband/respondent.

  1. Husband respondent will file the Misclaneous urgent applications basis her non compliance and precedents of apex court including rajnesh neha to first decide his 91, 340 applications with speaking order before entering into premature evidence stage.
  2. In case Family court judge dont decide point 1 application or keep it abeyance then     husband will file Writ in Delhi high court under article 227 (supervisory) for issuing directions to Family court  
    1. Call Trial court record.
    2. to first address and decide 91, 340 applications for ensuing compliance for completing discovery stage of case 
    3. post 91, 340 decision start evidence not in Court comissioner mode as , there is no consent given by respondent husband for evidence by LC and must follow 126(2) crpc for evidence as per statue.
    4. Also make/add additional issues in main case as below:
      1. wether petitioner/wife had complied the Rajnesh Neha Disclosures? OPR (onus to prove by respondent)
      2. wether petitioner/wife had comitted perjury? OPR (onus to prove by respondent)

Please suggest accordingly.

Dharmo Raksh*ta , Raksh*ta Dharmo... om


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register