Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Sushil (student)     21 June 2012

Rights of husband after wife dies w/o changing nominee

 

Hi Experts,

I need your opinion on the rights of legal heir in the following case –

A (husband) and B (wife) marry. Two years after the marriage, B expires interstate (without leaving a will). A and B have no children. Is A (husband) her sole legal heir?

1)     1) Life Insurance - B (wife) has life insurance from office and two more life insurance policies. B has nominated her mother in all of them and does not change the nomination post marriage. Insurance company says that they will pay the insurance sum to B’s mother. Isn’t A (husband), being the legal heir, should claim the insurance sum?

2)      2) PF and Gratuity – B’s mother is again the nominee. She would receive the money.

3)      3) B’s salary account - B’s mother is again the nominee. She would receive the money after the final settlement from office.

 

As far as my understanding, a nominee is only there to ‘receive’ the money and should distribute the money to legal heirs (Husband in this case)?

 

Thanks



Learning

 11 Replies

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     21 June 2012

Nominee is only a custodian of the property, and has no title over the same, and succession to the property would be diatributed as per the personal law of the parties.


(Guest)
I think if husband is made compulsary to give 50% to wife in all then it should be same if wife is there.

Sushil (student)     21 June 2012

Thanks Mr. N.K.Assumi for replying. 

What do you mean by "the personal law of the parties"?

Thanks.

Adv Archana Deshmukh (Practicing Advocate)     21 June 2012

Indian law on matters pertaining to marriage, divorce and succession are governed by personal laws. In case of succession here, hindus, muslims, christians etc are governed by different rules of succession as per the law applicable to them, eg. hindus are governed by hindu succession act, 1956, christians by indian succession act etc 

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     21 June 2012

Thanks Adv Archana for saving my time. Mr.Sushil, are you still ignorant of your personal law?

Sushil (student)     21 June 2012

Thanks Adv Archana. I looked into the act but the language is a bit difficult to understand. Please help me here -

Can you please let me know who should receive the various sums in case of a married hindu female, who dies interstate, leaving behind the husband and no children?

Her mother is the nominee and would receive the sums. What options are left with the widower to claim the amount that is rightfully his. Can some preventive action be taken to stop payments?

Thanks

Adv Archana Deshmukh (Practicing Advocate)     22 June 2012

In my opinion the husband should be entitled to the property.

Rakesh (Advocate)     05 July 2012

As per my opinion A (husband) should file a Succession Application before District & Session Court alongwith Temperory Injunction Application. Once court grant TI in your favour nominee can not take amount from anywhere. Thereafter let the sucession application decide.

Sushil (student)     02 September 2012

Thanks Rakesh. 

How much time TI takes? Shouldn't applications be moved to various authorities (PF, Insurance etc.) to not disburse the amount to the nominee till the time TI is granted?

Also, can someone post the format of such an application.


(Guest)

My Dear Colleagues Archana & Assumi,

Let me remind you that "the question asked by Sushil is purely falls under Hindu Succession Law".

Please read the question again it says " B has nominated her mother in all of the policies,salary and PF etc. does not change the nomination post marriage."

As per HSL (Hindu Succession Law) if a women owned anything before marriage does not belongs to husband ...

it belongs to her father's legal heir if there is no childeren of her.

So in this case the mother is lawfully the heir of the said property and luckily she is the nominee too else that money hunger husband will take all.


(Guest)
My Dear Colleagues Archana & Assumi, Let me remind you that "the question asked by Sushil is purely falls under Hindu Succession Law". Please read the question again it says " B has nominated her mother in all of the policies,salary and PF etc. does not change the nomination post marriage." As per HSL (Hindu Succession Law) if a women owned anything before marriage does not belongs to husband ... it belongs to her father's legal heir if there is no childeren of her. So in this case the mother is lawfully the heir of the said property and luckily she is the nominee too else that money hunger husband will take all.

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register