Rohidas Kamath 21 June 2026

Pio providing false information

I had received a document from a state govt in response to my RTI Application. Now on the basis of said document, I have sought information under RTI Act. The PIO denied of having such document mehtioned in my RTI Application which is provided by the same state govt. Iam prefering an appeal under Section 19 of the RTI Act.

Besides filing appeal under Section 19 of RTI Act, can I take legal action under the various provisions of BNS like Section 61, Sections 198 and Section 199 of BNS act. Request valuable opinion from experts in the field.

Reply Follow

Quick Summary

A user received a document from a state government via an RTI application, then requested further information based on it. The PIO denied possessing the document. The user is considering filing an appeal under Section 19 of the RTI Act and also exploring legal action under the BNS, specifically Sections 61, 198, and 199. Experts suggest that while the RTI Act itself doesn't provide for action against the PIO, criminal action might be possible if a cognizable offence has occurred, recommending consultation with a local lawyer. However, one expert advises against hasty legal steps and suggests focusing on the RTI appeal first.

5 Replies

Dr. J C Vashista (Advocate ) 23 June 2026

Aim and object of Right to Information Act, 2005 do not provide for any action to be initiated against PIO /FAA and/or any authority.

However, you may initiate criminal action against wrong-doer on the basis of information / document(s) provided in response to your application /appeal under the provisions of Right to Information Act, 2005 when there is some cognizable offence has been committed.

It would be appropriate to consult and /or engage a local prudent lawyer for proper analyses of facts/documents, professional advise and necessary proceeding.

1 Like

Rohidas Kamath 23 June 2026

Respected Dr JC Vashista sir,

thanks a lot for your valuable input and advice.