Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Anonymous   01 February 2021

Mahindra aura (gurgaon) illegally held hostage

Hi, I'm an American living in India and recently faced illegal harassment from the property management at my apartment as I was moving out. It's a gated high-rise apartment community in Gurgaon called Mahindra Aura, and as we were leaving, the property management illegally detained the movers and packers and refused to let them leave the property. They claimed they needed an email from the apartment owner, which is surprising as I had informed him that I was leaving. Either way, they refused to let the mover guys leave and illegally detained them inside the property for 7 hours. I'm pretty sure that only a police officer can legally detain someone, so the property management office at that place committed a felony. What would you advise me to do in this situation?

As Nandini had written in the other thread, this is a violation of the Indian Constitution:

If a private person has illegally detained people for a considerable amount of time, it will be considered as deprivation of their liberty, and it is a violation of Article 21 of the Indian constitution, which talks about the fundamental right to life and personal liberty. The remedy for such a violation can be found under Article 226 of the Indian constitution, which talks about issuance of writs (all types of writs, such as habeas corpus, prohibition, mandamus, more).  Under Section 43 of Criminal Procedure Code, any private person has the authority to arrest an individual without a warrant ONLY under circumstances where the person has been subsequently declared to be an offender under Section 82 CrPC or when a person is said to commit a non-bailable or cognizable offence in their presence. 
 



Learning

 1 Replies

G.L.N. Prasad (Retired employee.)     02 February 2021

Contact a local advocate as the facts suggested stoppage of movement of goods and not the persons.  No one can restrict the movement of persons and if there is an agreement with the owner is most important and if there is a condition that both have to abide for vacating the property.  Just imagine if you are in America and let out the property to someone in India, and when the tenant without paying rents for many months vacates the property, what course of action you can as an owner take when the entire belongings are being moved out where the possibility of contact and recovery is complicated.  Please understand that this is not passing on judgment, as that can only be made by an expert who is aware of entire facts.  Now that the entire situation is over, just forget it is a bad experience as retaliation further complicates such issues..


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register