Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

sunil (Engineer)     17 June 2012

Is less earningwife eligible to claim maintainance after mcd

Hi,

Both husband and wife are divorced through MCD and lumpsome amount is given to wife and MOU is made.

Husband came to know she is doing job for 10,000rs through facebook, and husband is earning 10times than her.

Now can she come to court in future for claim of maintainance, even though she is earning 10,000rs, she even worked before marriage

She filled 498a and taken back.



Learning

 6 Replies

Sanyam Malhotra (Advocate)     17 June 2012

she can put up a claim for maintenance in court saying she is unable to support herself. it is the courts discretion to increase/decrease/modify the amount. you would have to support your arguement with evidence that she is self sufficient.

1 Like

tarun (lawyer)     17 June 2012

sorry, she cannt claim MAINTINANCE after getting divore by mutual concent and gellint lum sum amnt. maitnce cnnt be demanded after gettng divorce by mutual concent.

 

tarun kalara, adv

tarunkalra12001@gmail.com

1 Like

Sanyam Malhotra (Advocate)     17 June 2012

@ tarun

there are judgements to the effect where maintenance has been allowed by the court even after mutual divorce.

there is no blanket ban on maintenance after mutual divorce even with lump sum paid. the woman has a right to claim maintenance it is part of her fundamental rights. judicial pronouncements have reserved their discretion in this matter to come to the aid of the weak and needy. 

1 Like

MRRpersonality (Knows very little about Indian laws)     17 June 2012

@tarun:  can you kindly post such judgements, as they will be useful for all of us here.  we all somehow believe that once MCD is settled and lumpsum is paid there is no future contests about the marriage anymore. then what is the use of a lumpsum settlement ?

sunil (Engineer)     18 June 2012

@sanyam

I too heard that she is eligible after maintainance.

In my case we got MCD, lumpsome amount is paid, at that time she is not working and agredd as per MOU no future claims.

Then in future, if she says i cant maintain myself, then y could she have not asked for maintainance before????

sunil (Engineer)     18 June 2012

sorry

I too heard that she is eligible for maintainance after.

In my case we got MCD, lumpsome amount is paid, at that time she is not working and agredd as per MOU no future claims.

Then in future, if she says i cant maintain myself, then y could she have not asked for maintainance before????

In one of the Shonee sir thread i have seen "if wife is previously employed or working she is not eligible for maintainance..".

My only question is "if wife is working with very less income compared to husband and during MCD no maintainance claim is made, then how come she come to court and say i am not able to maintain my self."


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register