Hindu marriage act v/s special marriege act

Adv Vinay Mathur + 8447131770 (Advocate) 07 December 2019

it is given in the first schedule of Special Marriage Act see section 2 (b) "Degrees of prohibited relationship"

Adv Vinay Mathur + 8447131770 (Advocate) 07 December 2019

sorry ipc section do not apply to you

Suraj123456789 (Other) 08 December 2019

Yes it explains prohibited degrees of relationship but it doesn't include sapinda relationship there. Sorry if I am not correct.

Originally posted by : Adv Vinay Mathur + 8447131770
	it is given in the first schedule of Special Marriage Act see section 2 (b) "Degrees of prohibited relationship"

Adv Vinay Mathur + 8447131770 (Advocate) 09 December 2019

you are saying Sapinda so you tell me how the girl and boy are related

Suraj123456789 (Other) 09 December 2019

Girl is Boy's Father's Sister's Son's Doughter. Thank you Mr.Mathur for being till now.

Originally posted by : Adv Vinay Mathur + 8447131770
	you are saying Sapinda so you tell me how the girl and boy are related

Suraj123456789 (Other) 10 December 2019

Mr. Mathur please suggest.

Originally posted by : Suraj123456789
	Girl is Boy's Father's Sister's Son's Doughter. Thank you Mr.Mathur for being till now. Originally posted by : Adv Vinay Mathur + 8447131770 you are saying Sapinda so you tell me how the girl and boy are related

SHANTANU MISHRA 11 December 2019

According to Hindu Law , when two persons offer Pinda to the same ancestor , they are Sapindas to each other.  Two persons would be Sapindas when they have common ancestor.  Section 3 (f) of HMA ,1955 defines Sapinda relationship.

SHANTANU MISHRA 11 December 2019

THE SPECIAL MARRIAGE ACT, 1954 THE FIRST SCHEDULE [See section 2(b) “Degrees of prohibited relationship”] PART I 1. Mother. 2. Father’s widow (step-mother). 3. Mother’s mother. 4. Mother’s father’s widow (step grand-mother). 5. Mother’s mother’s mother. 6. Mother’s mother’s father’s widow (step great grand-mother). 7. Mother’s father’s mother. 8. Mother’s father’s father’s widow (step great grand-mother). 9. Father’s mother. 10. Father’s father’s widow (step-grand mother). 11. Father’s mother’s mother. 12. Father’s mother’s father’s widow (step great grand-mother). 13. Father’s father’s mother. 14. Father’s father’s father’s widow (step great grand-mother). 15. Daughter. 16. Son’s widow. 17. Daughter’s daughter. 18. Daughter’s son’s widow. 19. Son’s daughter. 20. Son’s son’s widow. 21. Daughter’s daughter’s daughter. 22. Daughter’s daughter’s son’s widow. 23. Daughter’s son’s daughter. 24. Daughter’s son’s son’s widow. 25. Son’s daughter’s daughter. 26. Son’s daughter’s son’s widow. 27. Son’s son’s daughter. 28. Son’s son’s son’s widow. 29. Sister. 30. Sister’s daughter. 31. Brother’s daughter. 32. Mother’s sister. 33. Father’s sister. 34. Father’s brother’s daughter. 35. Father’s sister’s daughter. 36. Mother’s sister’s daughter. 37. Mother’s brother’s daughter. Explanation.—For the purposes of this Part, the expression “widow” includes a divorced wife.

SHANTANU MISHRA 11 December 2019

PART II 1. Father. 2. Mother’s husband (step-father). 3. Father’s father. 4. Father’s mother’s husband (step grand-father). 5. Father’s father’s father. 6. Father’s father’s mother’s husband (step great grand-father). 7. Father’s mother’s father. 8. Father’s mother’s mother’s husband (step great grand-father). 9. Mother’s father. 10. Mother’s mother’s husband (step grand-father). 11. Mother’s father’s father. 12. Mother’s father’s mother’s husband (step great grand-father). 13. Mother’s mother’s father. 14. Mother’s mother’s mother’s husband (step great grand-father). 15. Son. 16. Daughter’s husband. 17. Son’s son. 18. Son’s daughter’s husband. 19. Daughter’s son. 20. Daughter’s daughter’s husband. 21. Son’s son’s son. 22. Son’s son’s daughter’s husband. 23. Son’s daughter’s son. 24. Son’s daughter’s daughter’s husband. 25. Daughter’s son’s son. 26. Daughter’s son’s daughter’s husband. 27. Daughter’s daughter’s son. 28. Daughter’s daughter’s daughter’s husband. 29. Brother. 30. Brother’s son. 31. Sister’s son. 32. Mother’s brother. 33. Father’s brother. 34. Father’s brother’s son. 35. Father’s sister’s son. 36. Mother’s sister’s son. 37. Mother’s brother’s son. Explanation.—For the purposes of this part, the expression “husband” includes a divorced husband.

Suraj123456789 (Other) 11 December 2019

Means they can marry under special marriage act. Can't it?

Originally posted by : SHANTANU MISHRA
	PART II 1. Father. 2. Mother’s husband (step-father). 3. Father’s father. 4. Father’s mother’s husband (step grand-father). 5. Father’s father’s father. 6. Father’s father’s mother’s husband (step great grand-father). 7. Father’s mother’s father. 8. Father’s mother’s mother’s husband (step great grand-father). 9. Mother’s father. 10. Mother’s mother’s husband (step grand-father). 11. Mother’s father’s father. 12. Mother’s father’s mother’s husband (step great grand-father). 13. Mother’s mother’s father. 14. Mother’s mother’s mother’s husband (step great grand-father). 15. Son. 16. Daughter’s husband. 17. Son’s son. 18. Son’s daughter’s husband. 19. Daughter’s son. 20. Daughter’s daughter’s husband. 21. Son’s son’s son. 22. Son’s son’s daughter’s husband. 23. Son’s daughter’s son. 24. Son’s daughter’s daughter’s husband. 25. Daughter’s son’s son. 26. Daughter’s son’s daughter’s husband. 27. Daughter’s daughter’s son. 28. Daughter’s daughter’s daughter’s husband. 29. Brother. 30. Brother’s son. 31. Sister’s son. 32. Mother’s brother. 33. Father’s brother. 34. Father’s brother’s son. 35. Father’s sister’s son. 36. Mother’s sister’s son. 37. Mother’s brother’s son. Explanation.—For the purposes of this part, the expression “husband” includes a divorced husband.