HC saysit is husband's duty to protect wife abused by inlaws

so should he respond to my views for the 1st time by name calling and personal remarks?

is this civilized behavior?

or...

Deviation from the basic point in issue is not good for anyone.

This forum has become tolerant to such deviations! Sometimes they are enriching, sometimes irrelevant. sometimes they provide comic relief when issues become too sensitive! 

kushan i m reminded of a recent sms from ur reply above

BECHARA MARD...

Agr orat per hath uthae, to zalim or pit jae to buzdil,

Orat k agy chale to firon, piche chale to joru ka ghulam,

Orat ko kisi k sath dekh k laray to jealous or chup rahe to beghairat,

Gher se bahar rhe tou awara, ghr mai rhe to nakara,

Orat ko job se roke to shakki mizaj, na roke to Orat ki kamai khane wala

,Akhir....

Ye Mard bechara jae to kahan....... ????

Wow! Beautiful Suno ek aur baat;(FROM;https://freeorkutshop.blogspot.com/2010/10/fsc-student-ki-love-story-funny-scraps.html)

f.s.C karne wale ki Love Story:

in most cases MIL harasses DIL...the son is confused whom he should  support...due to emotional attachement with the mother and in the fear of being called a JORU KA GULAM forgets that his wife is also a beloved daughter of someone as his sister is..

Then in such situations a boy shud marry only when he's doubly sure that the daughter inlaw will be accpeted  in family.otherwise he shud remain a bachelor till his parents' feel the need that they need a daughter,not a daughter inlaw.

Good judgement with good observations.

It is good to support and protect the wives by their husbands. Wives too supports husbands