Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Dharmesh Manjeshwar (Advocate/Lawyer)     12 November 2009

criminal case to be filed on state bank of india

My company had business transactions with one M/s. Mals Cargo Pvt Ltd based in Bhadohi, Uttar Pradesh ..... Mals Cargo issued us 5 cheques against clearing liability ... All 5 cheques were drawn on SBI, Bhadohi Branch, Uttar Pradesh. My Company based in Mumbai deposited the 5 cheques with IndusInd Bank, Mumbai .... All the 5 cheques came back dishonoured ....and there were material alterations/overwritings on the dates of all 5 cheques and reason for dishonour was given as ' full signature of drawer required on cutting ' ..... We inquired with IndusInd Bank .... IndusInd had removed xerox copies of all 5 cheques before sending them to SBI, Bhadohi Branch .... and they found that there were no material alterations/overwritings when the cheques were presented .... so they gave us a certificate stating that the 5 cheques did not have any alterations/overwritings on their dates .....

This means that some staff/official of SBI, Bhadohi Branch in connivance with Directors of Mals Cargo played this fraud on us .... numerous notices/complaints were made to higher SBI officials/Banking Ombudsman ..... but nothing has evolved .... We want to file criminal case against SBI & Mals Cargo Pvt Ltd ... But how to go about it .... Who should be made party considering SBI ....

Central Board of Directors based in Mumbai .......... or SBI, Bhadohi Branch only .... or Administrative office at Lucknow

further on jurisdiction .... Can I file case at Mumbai or should it be filed in Bhadohi since cheques have been tampered at Bhadohi .........



Learning

 11 Replies

Anil Agrawal (Retired)     12 November 2009

 SBI, Bhadohi and the company which issued the cheques.

jayaveladvocate (Lawyer)     26 December 2009

Please lodge a complaint with District crime branch cell or if refused send the complaint to the SP of concerned District by registered post stating the refusal by the police, the next course would be to lodge a complaint under Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. and get suitable driection from the Magistrate Court or High Court

Anil Agrawal (Retired)     26 December 2009

 Please write to Economic Offences Wing, Mumbai Police, Azad Maidan, Mumbai-400001 giving full details and enclosing a copy of the cheques as received and as presented.

MOHANA SUNDARAM (Advocate High court Madras. M-9840908555)     27 December 2009

file a private case under IPC offences against the bank manager of the concerned branch and dissiminate the fraud commited by bank officials in all local medias. It will yield fruitful result.

Anil Agrawal (Retired)     27 December 2009

 Media is nothing but a shrewd trader. it won't buy or touch your story with a barge pole. Forget media.

 


(Guest)
Dharemsh ji, 1)First lodge a criminal complaint with police in Mumbai. 2)Send notice to the SBI Branch Manager, Bhadhohi branch 3)Send your complaint to the Ombudsman. 4)Send your complaint to the intelligence wing of Banking. 5)Send complaint to the Chief General Manager, SBI 6) send notice to the Mals Cargo Pvt.Ltd. 7)After send the above, file a criminal suit making parities as the above.

Dharmesh Manjeshwar (Advocate/Lawyer)     28 December 2009

Sathya Prakash Ji, (1)  I lodged written complaint with the concerned police station in mumbai .... we were called but they evaded the matter saying it was civil issue ... they refused to see our reasons ... (2) Notices were sent to Branch Manager, SBI, Bhadohi Branch ... there was no reply (3) Notices/Complaints were sent to Chairman/Managing Director/Dy General Manager, SBI, Mumbai ... they assured that they would look into the matter ..... Notices/Complaints were sent to SBI, Administrative Office at Lucknow .... there was no reply .... (4) Lodged complaint with Banking Ombudsman at Kanpur .... in October our complaint came to be dismissed on grounds that the complaint requires consideration of elaborate documentary and oral evidence and therefore proceedings before the BO are not appropriate for adjudication of the complaint .... (5) Now I have filed criminal proceedings in Mumbai.

Can I file complaint in Consumer Court also .... But we have deposited cheque with IndusInd Bank, Mumbai and fraud committed by SBI, Bhadohi Branch ... Do I become a Consumer of SBI, Bhadohi Branch .... Because I will have to make IndusInd Bank a witness .. since they have given me Certificate that when the cheques were presented before them they did not have alterations on the dates ... Please help


(Guest)
Dharmesh ji, Before filling a suit to make complaints or sending notices are essential. Whether they reply or not that is up to them. You can file a criminal suit for alterations and forgery. A civil case can be filed for damages of mental agony.Yes.You can file in consumer forum for damages.You can file in Mumbai.Make all as respondents.Don't step back.In your petition you request for forensic report also.Now a days banks are doing such cheating in several places.Definatly you get damages and action may be taken on bank officials.

(Guest)

If you follow P. Sathya Prakash ji  steps you will win with out any problem but you must keep a fully trusted lawyer and please never trust any police officer in this regard.

They may harrase you. Even Bank officials also try to manipulate. Where ever you go try to take there names and disignations tomorrow you can make them to stand in the court.

 

Dharmesh Manjeshwar (Advocate/Lawyer)     05 January 2010

The questionthat comes to my mind before filing complaint with Consumer is ---

My Company had A/c in IndusInd Bank, Mumbai .... all cheques were presented before IndusInd Bank ...... cheques were drawn on SBI, Bhadohi Branch .... IndusInd Bank sent cheques for processing before SBI, Bhadohi Branch .... there the forgery seems to have been committed and sent back to IndusInd Bank .....

To file complaint before Consumer Court .... I have to be a Consumer ..... Now do I become a consumer of SBI, Bhadohi Branch and can we file for deficiency in services and for unfair trade practices ????? Remember we are having A/c with IndusInd Bank ........

Anil Agrawal (Retired)     05 January 2010

 How will you prove that the cheque was not already overwritten before deposit? It is a clever way of getting away from 138 because the drawer is in collusion with Bhadohi branch of which he is a prominent customer.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register