Mr Ibrahim and similar others facing DV act action.
Seen your papers and it is good case for dismissal before further orders of lower court.
However most of the people do common mistake as you and your advocate has done in giving reply / counter.
In counter or reply never attempt to give any story of your side. It amounts to admission and the task of opponent becomes easy. In fact you admit the case and weaken your case.
In counter or reply you have just contradict the opponents pleading one by one that is all. No need to give any other story or your side of the case.
Please always take advice immediately after receipt of court summons so that proper reply is drafted and further steps given.