LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

durgaprasad   05 July 2017

Can ias and ips make the rules? to suffer the public?

HELLO EXPERTS!

I AM DURGA PRASAD!

HERE I HAVE SOME DOUBTS, NOW THESE DAYS I COME ACROSS SOME INTRESTING TOPICS, LIKE I.A.S AND I.PS ARE MAKING RULES TO INCONVENCE THE PUBLIC IF THEY CAN MAKE THE LAWS ADN RULES WHY DO WE NEED CONSTITUTION AND LAW?

AN I.A.S OR I.P.S CAN MAKE ANY RULE TO SATISFY THEIRE EGO?

I A.S OR I.PS CAN SUFFER THE THE PUBLIC BY MAKING A ORDER? WHO ADN WHICH GAVE THEM SUCH POWER, WHETHER INDIAN CONSTITUTION LET THEM ANY POWER? IF YES LET ME KNOW ARTICLE NO?

 

RECENTLY ONE D.S.P MADE AN ORDER IN OUR CITY THAT ORDER SAYS THAT NO MALE PERSON SHOULD NOT WALK ON THE ROAD AT 8 AM TO 10.30 AM. AND 4 P.M TO 7 P.M OFCOURSE THAT TWO KILOMETER ROAD IS GOING THROUGH THE COLLEGES. IS IT HAS CONSTITUTIONAL VALIDITY FOR HER ORDER?

BECAUSE OF THAT ORDER SO MANY MALES OF AGED ABOUT 60 ARE ALSO SUFFERED. BCAUSE POLICE HAS EXCUTED THAT ORDER. PEOPLE ARE ARRESTED BY POLICE AFTER TAKING SOME MONEY THEY RELEASED THEM. POLICE EARNED A LOT!

 

TWO DAYS BACK UIDAI(ADHAAR DEPARTMENT )

DEPUTY DIRECTOR UIDAI.

HAS ANNOCED THAT 25000/- ENROLLMENT AGENCIES ARE KEPT INACTIVE. INDEED ALL THE ENROLLMENT AGENCIES ARE RUN BY UNEMPLOYED YOUTH, AFTER PASSED THE EXAM BY UIDAI, THESE UNEMPLOYED ARE EARNING TO MEET THEIR BOTH ENDS!

CERTAINLY THIS ORDER IMPACTS 100000/- UNEMPLOYED YOUTH. WHETHER THIS ORDER HAS ANY VALIDITY?

SOME MIDDLE CLASS PEOPLE LIKE ME INVESTED MORE THAN TWO LAKH RUPEES. NOW THAT ORDER SAYS EVERY ENROLLMENT AGENCY SHOULD BE SHIFTED TO GOVT. PREMISES?

UIDAI DEPARTMENT HAS ENGAGED WITH FOUR BANKS, THOSE FOUR BANKS ARE REFERED AS RIGISTAR THESE REGISTARS MADE MOU WITH SOME PRIVATE AGENCIES AGAIN THESE PRIVATE AGENCIES ENGAGED WITH GROUNDLEVEL ENTERPRETNEURS!

FINALLY TOTAL IMPLEMENTATION COST FALL ON THESE ENROLLLMENT AGENCIES. THEY MAKE ME TO BUY TENFINGURE BIOMETRIC, IRISH AND GPS DEVICE AND LAPTOP WEB CAMERA. SOME OTHER EQUIPMENT. NOW THE ABOVE SAID ORDER WILL SMASH OUR LIVES?

FOR THE MISTAKE DONE BY SOME ONE, INSTEAD TAKING ACTION AGAIST THEM THEY TRY TO SUFFER THE INNOCENT. GOVT CAN NOT GIVE THE JOBS. WHEN WE EMPLOYED OURSELF THESE PEOPLE ARE TRYING TO DRAG OUR FOOD AWAY!

DOES THAT OFFER HAS THE RIGHT TO SUFFER 25000 PEOPLE WITH ONE ORDER TO SATISFY HIS SELF EGO?

CAN COURT TAKE ANY ACTION AGAINST THEM? LEAVE THEM IT WAS DONE UNDER THE DUTIES?

 

DO WE HAVE ANY SOLUTION FOR THIS?

 



Learning

 5 Replies

Kumar Doab (FIN)     05 July 2017

The authrotities above said officer,  Minister, Ministry, PM, President, Courts................can provide relief.

 

Build irrefutable evidence of bribery.

 

Chief Justice of Supreme Court of India  Mr. Justice Jagdish Singh Khehar has recently provided relief to persons that sufferred due to demonetisation.............that could not exchange currency notes.

 

Unfortunately even such judges have been mocked, ridiculed by so called  members/experts at LCI.

 

 

 

rajeev sharma (Advocate Ex senior manager law )     05 July 2017

An IAS or IPS officers may make rules concerning the department they are heading for smooth functioning of department but each rule has to be within the limits of constitution of India. If you feel that any rule is unjust unfair and is causing inconvenience to public that may be challenged before High Court

Kumar Doab (FIN)     06 July 2017

The person that is subjected to undue hardship, loss or whose rights are infringed upon can agitate.

{Balu manikantan} SUBRAMANYAM (Practising Advocate)     08 July 2017

IAS AND IPS OFFICERS HEADING A PUBLIC AUTHORITY ARE EMPOWERED TO MAKE RULES UNDER 144 CRPC AND WHO EVER VIOLATES THOSE RULES ARE PUNISHABLE UNDER 188 IPC BUT THE RULES MADE BY THEM SHOULD NOT BE VIOLATIVE OF ARTICLE 21 OF THE INDIAN CONSTITUTION AND IF ANY ONE IS AGGRIEVED BY THOSE RULES THEY CAN CHALLENGE THOSE RULES BEFORE THE HIGH COURT BY A FORM OF A WRIT.

 

jyotirmaya behera (advocate)     09 July 2017

IAS or IPS are only administrative officer. They created the bill not law but that does not valid till approval of Precedent or Governor. Before the approval the bills most pass through the lok shava and raj shava. After the signature of president or governor that become law.

Now-a-days what they does that can be challenge before the court. if any rules violate the fundamental right of any individual, he can file the writ direct before High Court.

 

Jyotirmaya Prasad Behera

9132319262

Advocate, Orissa High Court


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Recent Topics


View More

Related Threads


Loading