LCI Learning
Master the Art of Contract Drafting & Corporate Legal Work with Adv Navodit Mehra. Register Now!

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More


Reservation policy was made to uplift the weaker and poor section of community upwards and to give the equal status to these people at par to other rich and high society communities. With the passage of time and upon demand of other communities, more castes were added time to time under this policy to give them benefit. But this policy becomes a serious threat to the nation now. Meritorious students/candidates are losing jobs and opportunities due to this policy. Political pundits are the main culprits of this policy. They do not want the welfare of the people but they work only  for their vote bank. In India, majority remains with illiterate and poor people. The Political leaders misguide them on this issue. They offer reservation to them in every sector, whether it is job recruitment or job promotion. They stands upfront from the other meritorious students of general category under this policy. Moreover, a reserved category candidate can enter in the shoe of general category also but not vice versa.

I am not against the reservation policy. But I want some amendments in this policy. It is undoubtedly right that when this policy was frame, the country was really in need of this policy. There was a very big discrimination between the upper and lower castes, which compels to the people for the agitations and which results in to this policy. The main purpose of this policy was to diminish the gap between the upper and lower castes. That was the demand of that time. But now, meritorious candidates are getting affected in a big way now. Some times a general category candidate works for his/her whole life as a class 4/5 employee, but in the same conditions the other candidate of reserved category got promotions and promotions and sit at the top position of the departments. This is not fare. This policy is mentally torturing to the general candidates. But they can not do anything.

Let me tell, if we place a candidate with 33% or 40% marks in medical college instead of 75% of general category candidate, they how can we expect that he will treat the patient in efficient manner.

If we place a reserved category candidate with lower marks like as above instead of meritorious student in a engineering college, then how can we expect a better development in our infrastructure or how can we expect that our Nation will stand at par with other developed nations. More worse than this, our meritorious candidates are not well paid in country. They are compelled to go outside of Indian origin for the higher salaries and they have no other option to leave their homes and their families. Even these candidates are sit at top CEO positions in U.S. or in other countries, and think if they were given proper opportunity in India, they can shine our country. Meritorious candidates are lying vacant in the lines of unemployed youths or compelled to do the job on lower salaries. On the same time, unparalleled candidates with the stamp of reservation stands in upfront positions.

My views:

I strongly support my issue that only one family member should be given the benefit of this policy and this benefit would be given for one time only. I wonder when a candidate is uplift by this policy, then why he/ she needs the benefit of the reservation in future at every step of his/her life. We have made them dependent for the whole life. They have forget to live with out the help of stick of reservation. Once a candidate uplifted, he or she stands on the equal footage of upper category castes. And after that he or she should be promoted only if he/ she deserves. This is not a way to promote the nation. If we want to promote the nation on the right path, We need efficient candidates not reserved candidates. I again tell here that I am not against the policy of reservation, but I advocacy for the amendments in the policy, which is the demand of time. We should build the nation with efficient candidates and proper salaries should be given to them so that, they can earn necessaries and luxuries according to their family living standard and they did not think to leave the country for the better opportunities in abroad.

I am sure this will be the right step towards the improvement of environment of govt. offices also. Because right man will be placed at  If we expect the political leaders will move for this amendment, they will never do this. Because they divide the people on the issue of caste and religion and rule over them. This is the main reason that why they are not real well wishers of the country.

Rest of this, I acknowledge here that these are my personal views seeking the better growth of the nation and my purpose is not to hurt any one feelings. My purpose is also not to degrade any community. I think that each and every people who take birth in this world is a son of God. There should be no discrimination on this chapter. Modi Ji is requesting to every people to leave their subsidy, I suggest them that he and their party workers should  request to the people to leave the benefit of reservation. This will be the right step and this will start from our self only. Do not expect the political help on this chapter.

Advocate Dimple Jindal,

(M.B.A, LL.B, B.COM)

Distt. Courts Barnala

LCI Learning

"Loved reading this piece by DR. DIMPLE JINDAL (ADV.)?
Join LAWyersClubIndia's network for daily News Updates, Judgment Summaries, Articles, Forum Threads, Online Law Courses, and MUCH MORE!!"






Tags :


Category Constitutional Law, Other Articles by - DR. DIMPLE JINDAL (ADV.) 



Comments

9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

problem is the reservationinsts do not realize what is the ploy behind reservations..so long as the reservationsts do not realize till then criminal idea politics can survive..how long one need to wait patiently very reservations would turn against that is the D day for these politicians, results might be even assasination(s) too likely, wait and see what happens..after all patients pay the dividends...


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

fact is reservation idea is to ensure not meritorious is promoted, criminal legislators can do what they want is the great idea behind Dimpleji


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

fact is reservation idea is to ensure not meritorious is promoted, criminal legislators can do what they want is the great idea behind Dimpleji


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

you yourself say one is a crime and how you can exonerate it as a legislator, so the concept of judicial review is to not recognize the statutes made by legislators in which there is even one legislator is with criminal background, for this statute is abinitio is ultra vires of the very constitution. that is constitutional jurisprudence.


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

see criminal background politicians sit as legislators they play on people, see your present Loksabha has 186 /531 MPs ...they cannot run parliament per se the constitution of of india as constitution of india is not under any article conceived parliament with criminal background politicians, law of crimes you yourself created by your own statutes, when so how can you allow those fall under same law of crimes to be your defacto legislators!


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

in fact reservation policy is a great idea of divide the people and rule principle what Mr Ramsay McDonald as British PM applied on Indians then that same is played by politicians....


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

problem is very taxation principle by government,,,it plays divide and rule between direct and indirect tax payers, i said in my comment on CAsclubofindia.


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

yo may read my article ' it matters not what we do, but glory of endeavor lies in how we do it' in rapidanalysts16@wordpress,com.


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

all castes are just distortions, to take out merit based life is just ditched. if merit is a toilet paper you would go backwards moreitua, faster than growing, do u like that situa situation.


9 years ago dr g balakrishnan

there is nothing called as caste; refer Gita, read my article - caste is imagination.


Show All (24) (Login required)


You are not logged in . Please login to post comments.

Click here to Login / Register