Should there be reservation in higher judiciary? |
|
| Yes | 20 % |
 |
|
| No | 79 % |
|
|
|
| Can't Say | 1 % |
|
|
|
| Total Votes Cast : 275 | |
| Submitted By - Prakash Yedhula | Read Comments |
| Posted by narsinha |
01/07/2010 18:00:01 |
| no there should not be reservation | |
| Posted by Legal Eagle |
13/11/2008 16:03:58 |
| Should women counsels be appointed as Senior Counsels? | |
| Posted by s.sundara moorthy |
12/11/2008 20:05:31 |
| If reservation policy in higher judiciary means spreading red carpet to politics which is not a healthy condition currently. | |
| Posted by SRINIVASA MURTHY L. K. |
11/11/2008 18:59:32 |
| NOT EVEN IN LOWER JUDICIARY | |
| Posted by kap |
10/11/2008 12:25:26 |
| weird that 1 percent actually cant say !!! and I thought reservation was a topic of extremes | |
| Posted by padmanabhan |
07/11/2008 14:04:48 |
| Reservation on the communal basis is untenable in higher judiciary. it would also lead to destandardise the judicial functions. any appointment on the basis of standing in the bar and practise | |
| Posted by Adv. Rishab |
07/11/2008 13:47:56 |
| there must not be any reservation in judiciary as it will lower down the prestige and level of the judges....the adjudication is a very complex and hard to deal matter.. it must be in the hands of competant persons who can impart justice on the basis of true principles of natural justice, equity and good conscience... it will be against the interest of the justice and the judicial system if there will be reservation in the judiciary.. reservation must be discarded/ must not be allowed in any system whether in judiciary either higher or lower , education , or in goverenmental jobs... | |
| Posted by A. A. JOSE |
06/11/2008 10:55:50 |
| HOW MANY DAYS SAME POLL TOPIC WILL BE SHOWN PLEASE ? DAILY NEW POLL FELT DESIRABLE IF POSSIBLE. | |
| Posted by SantoshKumarSrivastava |
06/11/2008 06:57:52 |
| Certainly not. There should be no reservation,not only in judiciary but any where else also.Every opprtunity to the economically weaker's should be provided to improve every person of the socity without any reservation. | |
| Posted by SantoshKumarSrivastava |
06/11/2008 06:42:56 |
| In my opinion there should be no reservation in higher judiciary or any where in Judiciary because justice need's ability. | |
| Posted by Md Amjad Ali |
05/11/2008 14:34:47 |
| I hate the words reservation, | |
| Posted by smilingadvocate |
04/11/2008 18:17:28 |
| The method of selection to the higher judiciary ie. to the High Courts is only through recommendations from the respective highcourts collegium where in there is only chance to a set of people may be by way of caste and money but, in my opinion if theindian judicial service is brought then there is scope that only the merit who have legal stuff will be adorning the chair of the higher judiciary. | |
| Posted by veenzar |
04/11/2008 13:25:10 |
| On observation we could find candid reservation in the higher judiciary.Though it is not subject to reservation. | |
| Posted by pranjali |
03/11/2008 13:04:20 |
| there is no need to allow reservation in higher judiciary but preferably with intellectual | |
| Posted by A. A. JOSE |
03/11/2008 12:04:50 |
| MERIT ALONE MUST BE THE CRITERIA FOR JUDICIAL APPOINTMENTS. WHY SHOULD WE GO BACK TO STONE AGE FROM 21ST CENTURY ? | |
| Posted by C Nadarajan |
02/11/2008 21:05:50 |
| No. It is not required. When there is no hurdle to elevate the meritorious to judiciary without any difficulty where is the question of reseravation and when political parties are playing their part in recommending their paty persons for judiciary and is being allowed without murmur then the reservation willadd fuelto the fire and no meritorious person will like tocome judiciary. Nadarajan | |
| Posted by Rajeev Kumar Dubey |
02/11/2008 20:52:48 |
| for the interest of cients and society there should not be resevation in higher judiciary | |
| Posted by vijayakumar |
02/11/2008 20:50:19 |
| Always merrit should be given priority, wisdom , knowledge should be first - no caste, no religion should be given importance | |
| Posted by saharaaj |
02/11/2008 20:34:03 |
| reservation has already severely damage to india's competitiveness. At this rate india will have to outsource middle level business work which is done by 50 -70 % range hurting those very for whom reservation is being thurst | |
| Posted by J.L.Naagar |
02/11/2008 18:15:55 |
| These are Constitutional Posts and should be on highly competitive basis. The doyans in the field should only decorate such high posts. | |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
02/11/2008 12:32:36 |
| JUDICIARY IS EXPERT JUDICIAL OPENION WHICH DECIDES THE FATE OF ACCUSED IN CRIMINAL CASES AND ALSO THE JUST AND PROPER DECISION.THE PERSON DECIDING THE COURT MUST BE EXPERT AND HENCE NO NEED FOR RESERVATION .THERE SHOULD NOT BE ANY COMPROMISE REGARDING QUALITY. NANDKUMAR B.SAWANT, M.COM.LL.B.(MUMBAI), ADVOCATE MOBILE-9325226691, e.mail.adv.nbsawant@yahoo.co.in. | |
| Posted by G. ARAVINTHAN |
01/11/2008 13:16:50 |
| The promotion is to be based on the merits and qualification as the post is for the welfare of all the people in the country | |
| Posted by KamalNayanSaxena |
31/10/2008 20:30:43 |
| Not only judiciary, but should be abolished in each service. | |
| Posted by mohammad aarif khan silawat |
31/10/2008 17:06:24 |
| reservation is a illness of mind | |
| Posted by sridharan |
31/10/2008 15:31:20 |
| why should be reservations in this everything is on merit basis | |
| Posted by sunil aware |
30/10/2008 18:37:40 |
| cancel all reservation, for any post give preference to merit & who deserve the post | |
| Posted by mahendra kumar mishra |
30/10/2008 16:53:30 |
| we are not aganist of reservation but in judicail service when it want to higly qulified and inteligent person fot this post and this judicail post is a trust post and its depand lot of person felling and juje simler as god if in this post site unqulifed and unskilled person on based of regervation till that what will being. he will give roung jujement and all the person who trust in this time on judicile they will also leve his trust of that | |
| Posted by Rama chary Rachakonda |
30/10/2008 13:25:15 |
| upto a common level only reservations r required. The judiciary is beyong common level. | |
| Posted by ESTHERPRIYA |
29/10/2008 21:48:01 |
| No need of reservation. The survival of the best and fittest has to be chosen on merit. As we are in the stages to reach the domain of developed nation category, the entire system of reservation is not required. | |
| Posted by t.m.kumar |
29/10/2008 19:52:30 |
| Reservation was ideally introduced in the constitution to balance the caste diffrences in the country,instead the faulty political system has allowed reservation to creep all walks of life. even "GODS". Please spare judiciary out of this disease "RESERVATION". | |
| Posted by Sanjeev Dudhat |
29/10/2008 17:04:15 |
| talk of reservation strengthens the caste system once again! Its back to square one. there is no chance for pure merits.Yet another thousand years of reservation by birth now! | |
| Posted by Ajay kumar singh |
28/10/2008 19:51:29 |
| No. | |
| Posted by Member (Account Deleted) |
28/10/2008 00:32:07 |
| The topic that "should there be reservation in higher judiciary" itself assumes that judges in higher judiciary are partisan. Why should there be a representation in higher judiciary to people from every caste, creed and religion? What makes us feel that judges are biased as per their own caste or religion and therefore there should be equitable representation? If they are really so biased, we have to discard the entire system of justice dispensation prevailing in India. By making reservations, we will only be enforcing the belief that Indian Judiciary is divided on castes and religions. Justice dispensation is a divine work. Please do not meddle with it. | |
| Posted by Apurva Kumar |
27/10/2008 20:27:01 |
| happy Deepawali 2 all d members of the society!!!!!!!!!! | |
| Posted by Apurva Kumar |
27/10/2008 20:26:00 |
| do not control the supremacy of the post thru any reservation! | |
| Posted by sanjeev murthy desai |
27/10/2008 18:43:29 |
| I wish everyone associated with Lawyersclubindia a happy and prosperous Diwali. | |
| Posted by Aniruddha.P.Pawse |
27/10/2008 17:31:08 |
| The work of judiciary is of utmost importance. A wrong judgement if treated as a precedent can badly effect the community/society. The Judges should only be selected on qualifications, experience, Knowledge and expertise. | |
| Posted by rajareddym |
27/10/2008 09:33:00 |
| Reservations should limit to providing better education for back ward classes who are financialy not sound; not for free feeding | |
| Posted by GOPAL SINGH SAINI |
26/10/2008 19:23:11 |
| Reservation should not be given any fild . | |
| Posted by sanjay kumar patibandla |
26/10/2008 09:31:45 |
| Higher judiciary has it's own value. For this post only the worth and honesty are only the qualifications not the cast or anything | |
| Posted by sanjay kumar patibandla |
26/10/2008 09:30:34 |
| Higher judiciary has it's own value. For this post only the worth and honesty are only the qualifications not the cast or anything | |
| Posted by Prahant Bhatt |
25/10/2008 19:21:53 |
| When we choose something, we compromise with other. When one side efforts are going on for fairness and improvement of our system, a policy which is based on racism (here that is cast base), definitely not fair ethically. | |
| Posted by ca.bhupendrashah |
25/10/2008 08:33:27 |
| merit vs no merit? | |
| Posted by ca.bhupendrashah |
25/10/2008 08:33:27 |
| merit vs no merit? | |
| Posted by Sanjay Agarwal |
25/10/2008 05:41:05 |
| No handcuffs for MERIT | |
| Posted by Vinodkumar Kotabagi |
25/10/2008 00:40:03 |
| Higher judiciary should represent the highest quality. So, only the judges deserving the post in highest judiciary should be appointed. | |
| Posted by P.Elamaran |
24/10/2008 22:20:31 |
| A very strong YES.Because, unless and until the chauvenistic mindset of the upper caste people changes, there cannot be a question of throwing away the reservation policy.Who will uplift the marginalised sections of the society? Only Government can uplift them. There is not even a single day in India, which passes without any attrocities against Dalits.Why the rate of conviction under the SC/ST Act is very abysmal? Why still there are double tumbler systems in the tea stalls of rural India? Why still Dalits are prevented from entering the Temples? Will an upper caste boy marry a lower caste girl? Even if a Dalit boy/girl gets selected in Open Competition Category in some Govt and PSU Jobs, he/she is still being stigmatized and dubbed as inefficient or deadwood. Why there is such a sweep against reservation policy? The people who are conducting opinion polls in the Print&Electronic Medias should reach out to the rural areas of India, then they will understand the necessacity of reservation policy. It is easy speak from the tip of the iceberg but hard to digest the realities. I STRONGLY AND VEHEMENTLY SAY YES TO RESERVATION POLICY AS IT IS THE ONLY SAFEGAURD AVAILABLE TO THE DOWNTRODDEN PEOPLE AND THROUGH THIS SAFETYVALVE ONLY DALITS CAN COME OUT OF THE SHACKLES OF SLAVERY UPPER CASTE CHAUVENISM. | |
| Posted by Dr. Harrit Jani |
24/10/2008 20:31:39 |
| There must not be reservation in any field at any level, As the society and the industry needs quality services. By reservation appointing people of lower quality on the basis of cast, cread and community can't solve any matter rather will decrease the level of quality output. | |
| Posted by Adv.Shine Thomas |
24/10/2008 19:22:53 |
| Reservation diminishes the quality of judiciary. | |
| Posted by N.K.Assumi |
24/10/2008 14:00:30 |
| We need the best brain for the job not a post of bounty. | |
| Posted by keshav |
23/10/2008 23:11:13 |
| reservation is no longer required in our society. once it was a boon 2 up lift back ward ness in our society but now itz the main obstacle in making our society weaker. | |
| Posted by keshav |
23/10/2008 23:10:37 |
| reservation is no longer required in our society. once it was a boon 2 up lift back ward ness in our society but now itz the main obstacle in making our society weaker. | |
| Posted by Barun Ghosh |
23/10/2008 22:41:57 |
| Reservation only further weaken the judicial system qualitatively. | |
| Posted by prabodh kumar patel |
23/10/2008 20:07:09 |
| I think the system of reservation should not be there, in lieu of it the govt. should make the education upto any level, totaly free for the reserved catagory and financial assistance during studentship (stipend) be allowed. | |
| Posted by Tribhuwan Pandey |
23/10/2008 19:34:36 |
| No because person sitting in the higher post has high responsibility. He should possess good knowledge and experience through his own labour. He should come to the position through merits not through reservation/approach. | |
| Posted by Shree. |
23/10/2008 18:49:53 |
| Certainly No, Let the best of the lawyers become judges irrespective of caste religion. By the way the same applies to other sectors also. THROW AWAY THE RESERVATION ON THE BASIS OF CASTE FROM EVERY WALK OF THE SOCIETY. Instead give free education upto college level to all the poor and downtrodden people | |
| Posted by D.ANANDHAGIRI |
23/10/2008 13:39:43 |
| yes | |
Member Strength 9,51,631 and growing..
© 2024 LAWyersclubindia.com. Let us grow stronger by mutual exchange of knowledge.
