Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Abhinav Gupta (xyz)     22 June 2013

Working without pay

Hello,

I am in very big trouble. I am a mechanical engineering student with some backlogs. I have placed in one IT company from campus on december 25,2012 and on 6th january 2013 we got our offer letters having designation as ERP Consultant. We are 26 studends which are placed and got offer letters. Company HR told us to provide online training so as to make us compatible with job. We are working from 10th january 2013 online from a trainer and out 26 now remains only 8. Some people dont want to join and some others are removed by company. The work we are doing as training is simply for publicity of company's blog and to make(article writing) company's blog. We are not getting anything like language learning etc which are required as erp consultant.

 Now in offer letter they have given 23 july as our joining date in offer letter but they till now not give us our call letter. Is offer letter is different from call letter? They are saying that they do this as our performace of some candidates is not satisfactory. Please note that there is nothing written on offer letter regarding this 6 month so called training.

Now my questions are:

Is this leagal to pursue any such training?

As we are placed through campus does irragularity in performance or not satisfactory performance during this training period are suitable excuses to dismiss us or anyone from group from this job?

As I have backlogs is this possible to dismiss me due to this reason. Though they have not make any backlog criteria during placement. And I personally asked HR and he told me that I am allowed?

If somehow we got fired is it possible to take any legal action against company for job or compensation?

Please reply me as soon as possible...we all are in great tension.



Learning

 3 Replies

Kumar Doab (FIN)     22 June 2013

 

 

All affected employees may show the offer letter, attendance record etc to a labor consultant/service lawyer to evaluate the merits.

 

 

You are not alone. There are many threads to suggest that students are being exploited by such unscrupulous employers.

 

The student union, college authorities, Dean/VC in concerned University, should be informed on this malpractice as none of the students recruited in campus is being paid.

This company should be blacklisted.

 

No one can be asked t work without payment of wages.

You may show the offer letter to

 

During training employment can be terminated. However wages shall have to be paid.

 

If a candidate is not able to clear the final exam, company may terminate the employment.

 

Collect proof of your attendance and work done.

 

Offer letter issued by company, attendance record shall help.

The company must have registered under (Name of state) Shops and Establishments Act, and as per this enactment of many states it is mandatory to issue and supply appointment letter.

 

Al affected employees may join hands, be witness to each other and approach Inspector under Shops and Establishments Act, Inspector under Payment of Wages Act, Labor Inspector. The contact details can be obtained from o/o Labor Commissioner.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sandy (Journalist)     07 August 2013

This is happenieng way to often.

 

I have come across such a case even if the person in question is not a student on first job. He is one with experience and is running his own consulting firm..

 

I have posted the case here on this forum

 

You may read the complete thread here

 

https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/details.asp?mod_id=84142&offset=1#.UgFt4ZIwfuw

 

 

Or the full details of the case is as follows:

 

The case in short and concise format is as follows:

Employee is made to spend on his travel for interview. They promise to pay later.

Employee is asked to joing 'soon' under promises of good positions and plum postings. Later they turn out to be false promises.

Employee travels for joining at his own cost. They promise to pay later.

Employee is made to join without appointment letter. They promise to give soon. But they make him sign a Non Disclosure Agreement about the employer's business.

He is then made to do some things which is unethical /immoral. He hesitates. They fire him. Then they issue an apointment letter after firing. They coerce him to sign or else his salary and travel dues will be held back. They want him to sign a 'back dated' appointment letter. While signing they want him to put the date of joining as the date on which the letter was signed. Now since they have fired him they change the clause of the appointment which says notice pay must be paid. So technically now the letter would say "No Notice" is required in the initial period.

They also want him to sign the resignation letter. They want to do this or else his money will not be paid.

He doesn't sign and seeks legal advice.

They keep convincing him to get to the office and sign.

Meanwhile they had given him cheques for his dues. They deliberately do stop payment on the cheques since he did not sign on anything as they wanted.

The employers also threaten to inform the "labour office" as though the employee has done a misconduct. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black. They say "it will go to labour office as a case of termination" . The termination threat is the ultimate weapon used by employers to get employees to toe the line. Many employees succumb to such threat and resign on their own. Now these employers have taken things to the next leve. "informing the labour office".

A lone single innocent employee would be trembling with terror at sudden mention of such phrases. All he can think of is to secure his future. If such an ugly label of "being terminated" is applied against his name he  is scared if his future employment will be a problem. The employers can find any reason later. They may find inconsistency in anything at office. If all is perfect then they may go digging into his past and find problems with past work and employers. The story never ends.

__________________________________________________________

 

A coincidence: The employee is living in the company guest house when a credit card fraud happens. The guest house of course is in a city in India. The card has been skimmed. The transaction has happened in a city outside of India. Incidentally, this is the same city where the company is headquartered. Now this is a coincidence, right?

________________________________________________________

Somebody mentioned why did he not take action.

He is without a job. He is in depressed state. His money has not been cleared. Some other couple of issues have happened with him ( a different related matter). A  He wound up his work, his clients and other things. He had to give sufficient notice to them but he did not. He gave shorter notice. He got enticed by false promises. The clients and their goodwill was lost . Difficult to win them back. He left family for another strange city. He faces all this trouble. Then he goes back and has other responsibilities. He approached press. He approached lawyers. He has ailing parents to take care of. A sibling to be treated medically.

All this while he has to hunt for some gainful employment. He already is afraid that if the matter blows out of proportion, one doesn't know how a corrupt employer will react. What they may do. His entire career could be ruined. Even a lawyer warns "Think of it as if you have done some mistake and gave off your money to charity. Forget it and move on. For a few rupees, why do you want to keep fighting a legal case? Those people may ruin career if they are hell bent on it."

Maybe he made a mistake by not taking all this too seriously on a legal level at that time

But the question is : IS IT TOO LATE ?

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

What are the legal options available?

What's the next step? Cheque can be resubmitted right?

Can't the employers be made to answer on what grounds they did all this?

_____________________________________________________________

Kumar Doab (FIN)     07 August 2013

Employee may escalate the matter ‘Finally’ to good offices of appointing authority, MD, Chairman, Company Secretary……………………..narrate all representation made so far mentioning dates, names of company personnel……………………………..with brief minutes of discussion and explain………………..raise clear demand for………………..the documents and payments (provide detail) by bank DD only and that these should be supplied by redg. post only……………………………….so as to reach in next say………………………………..7 days along with PF account slips of all years of service. 

Employee may add that a postage prepaid self addressed envelope (as purchased from PO) is attached herewith……………………………..



If despite the best and sincere efforts good office does not resolve and provide relief,

the employee can approach:

-Lawyer/Law Firm: A legal notice by lawyer can drill sense into the heads.

Employee should retain access to a competent and experienced labor consultant/service lawyer and proceed under expert advice of his lawyer.

Almost all employer are crafting contracts with T&C inserted into these which are beneficial for the employer but restraining and damaging for the employee………………….

- trade union leaders

Majority of the employees refrain from becoming member of trade unions which is their loss.
Trade unions can negotiate service conditions for the benefit and advantage of employee.

Employers should have ‘Works Committee’ in which representative(s) of the employee are made member and even Chairman……………….
There should be Grievance Redressal Committee in company………………..

Be a member and educate others to form IC, trade union in company and trade……………

 

Some of the unions formed by IT sector and other trade unions which seriously want to unite them are:

 

https://www.rediff.com/money/2007/feb/01ites.htm

 

 

https://www.itecentre.co.in/

Contact Us

Please contact us on
mail id : contact@itecentre.co.in.
ph : 9620907912

Please Join ITEC group for discussion among IT-BPO employees. To join the group, please send a blank mail to itec_bangalore-subscribe@yahoogroups.com

 

https://ithiworld.wikispaces.com/News+Update

ITHI, a forum
of women employees in IT and ITeS

 

 

IT/BPO Voice of India | Facebook


UNITES Professionals

 

'IT Professionals Forum.'

https://www.itpfindia.org/

UNITES Pro (Union for Information Technology & Enabled Services Professionals):

www.unitespro.org

West Bengal Information Technology Services Association (WBITSA):

https://www.wbitsa.org/

Centre for BPO Professionals (CBPOP): 

 

https://labour.kar.nic.in/labour/trade-unions-list.htm

 

CITU, in collaboration with other Left-unions -- like the All India Trade Union Congress, want the Union government to enact a law separately to deal with the labour issues of the IT industry.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


-Inspector under Shops and Establishments Act: one of the duties of Inspector is to ensure settlement of dues etc………………

e.g. Delhi Shops and Establishments Act : 37. Powers and duties of the Inspector: (b) Duties of the Inspector

(i) that in dispensing with the services of an employee the provision of the Act and Rules
have been complied with and no dues payable under the Act or Rules have been
withheld

- Inspector under Payment of Wages Act (applicable to all employees drawing wages as per def. of wages in the Act up to Rs.18000/pm),

2. Definitions.
3*[(vi) "wages" means all remuneration………………………..

(d) any sum which by reason of the termination of employment of the person employed is payable under any law, contract or instrument which provides for the payment of such sum, whether with or without deductions, but does not provide for the time within which the payment is to be made;


-O/o Labor Commissioner:


Time for Payment of FNF dues is max. usual pay day………………

SCHEDULE I
[1][MODEL STANDING ORDERS IN RESPECT OF INDUSTRIAL ESTABLISHMENTS NOT BEING
INDUSTRIAL ESTABLISHMENTS IN COAL MINES]


13. Termination of employment:

(3) Where the employment of any workmen is terminated, the wages earned by him and other dues, if any, shall be paid before the expiry of the second working day from the day on which his employment is terminated.

16. Certificate on termination of service.--Every permanent workman shall be entitled to a service certificate at the time of his dismissal, discharge or retirement from service.

NOTE. - There is a provision under this Act for issuing a service certificate at the time of dismissal, discharge or retirement and every person is entitled to take such certificate.


-Civil Court


-For matters related to Form 16: I/C –TDS at location where employee files ITR and jurisdictional CIT-TDS where company files ITR……………………………………..There are provisions for penalty for defaults by deductor (employer) if return is not files and Form 16 is not supplied………….

- For matters related to PF:Thru RPFC at location of employee: Non submission of PF dues is cognizable offence…………..

Pursue the complaint thru RTI and make the authorities act………………………and act sternly…………

 

-For matters related to Gratuity: Controlling Authority of Gratuity : Dy. Labor Commissioner-Gratuity

 

There are threads to suggest that employee can approach police and lodge criminal complaint under sec 406, 420……………………………….

And to treat the unpaid wages as debt on employer and approach the employer as creditor …………..
e.g;
https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/details.asp?mod_id=72011&offset=1#.UgHWIdKAqWO

 


Attached File : 97712168 trade unions in karnataka.doc, 97712168 challenges for organising bpo workers in india.doc, 97712168 union does it industry need a trade union.doc downloaded: 114 times

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register