Formation of professional firm
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 06 May 2015
This query is : Resolved
Is it possible to form LLP by CA,CS,CMA,MBA Lawyers and other professionals? To my knowledge Bar council has not permitted Lawyers to enter into partnership with CAs.
Please suggest one to one profession.
What will be the procedure to form it, if possible?
Anirudh
(Expert) 06 May 2015
You are right, that Bar council has not permitted Lawyers to enter into partnership with other professionals like CAs and CSs etc.
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 06 May 2015
But pls tell me about other than laywer i.e. whether other professionals can form LLP?
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 06 May 2015
But pls tell me about other than laywer i.e. whether other professionals can form LLP?
Anirudh
(Expert) 06 May 2015
Dear Mr. Vivek,
After all you might have gone through the LLP Act.
What is your understanding and what according to you is the answer to your query?
Guest
(Expert) 06 May 2015
Academic query.
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 07 May 2015
This is not an academic query. It is not just the LLP Act, to my understanding. We are the group of CA, CMA, CS, IT professionals and Layers, we thought of One point solution to client. So the question is covering the Council guideline and Act relevant therto, of various professional Institute.
Guest
(Expert) 07 May 2015
Dear Vivek Laddha,
If it is not an academic query, it is definitely a commercial query. Being a CA, CS as well as LLB, I think you should be fully competent to solve your own problem. More so, when you are "the group of CA, CMA, CS, MBA, IT professionals and Lawyers," you could have solved your problem by collective wisdom of all of the group members.
However, if all of you are still in doubt and feel any difficulty in solving the riddle, yours being a commercial/ business problem, better hire services of some expert on the issue, pay his consultancy fee and get the matter resolved. Seeking free services are quite unwarranted on the part of the group of business/ professional people.
In fact your query gives negative impression about your own qualifications and also of your other associates, being a group of group of CA, CMA, CS, MBA, IT professionals and Lawyers.
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 07 May 2015
Thanks for your valuable guide..if it is the commercial query, then what is other than that being asked over here !!
As far as the negative impression is concerned I am not bothered, rather you are taking. No body is God, and expert even can not find the absolute solution always. Merely by qualifying does not make you the the final solution point.
We are striving to solve it and I do take your point with full of respect.But if you do not know the solution or do not wish to provide it, pls do not guide us in this manner, better is to be silent!!
Guest
(Expert) 07 May 2015
Mr. Vivek Laddha,
Great expectations for free help to develop a profitable building!
Anyway, can you please clarify on the following points:
1) Did I mention anywhere that I don't know the solution?
2) Do you or your associates finance the cost for maintenance of offices and infrastructure of the experts to expect that your commercial/ business problems be solved free of cost?
3) Are you or your asociates so poor that you cannot afford consultancy fee of experts to solve your problem?
4) Has anywhere at the LCI written that commercial business needs are fulfilled by the experts at the LCI free of cost?
OK. if you want solution from me, I charge my consultation fee for providing guidance to solve business problems. If willing to get my consultancy with consultancy fee, you are welcome to send details of your problem through email to me.
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 08 May 2015
I have not asked directly to you. Pls do not take this platform personally. Expert is not the person who is arrogant. So you do not qualify:)
Guest
(Expert) 08 May 2015
Mr. Vivek Laddha,
Thanks for you verdict about the experts and advice for me.
However, about your statement, "I have not asked directly to you," can you please clarify to whom you asked your query directly to expect his answer to your query?
Also, when Shri Anirudh replied your query, he asked you one question also, "After all you might have gone through the LLP Act. What is your understanding and what according to you is the answer to your query?"
But, you have not replied to his query so far. So, naturally, you can say that you cannot be asked any question by Shri Anirudh, when you have not asked directly from him. Is not it?
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 08 May 2015
I suppose you must have read it my previous post again,you are not qualified.
Wow is your assumption that you are alone expert to this discussion other than Shri Aniruddh Ji!!
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 08 May 2015
I suppose you must have read it my previous post again,you are not qualified.
Wow is your assumption that you are alone expert to this discussion other than Shri Aniruddh Ji!!
Guest
(Expert) 08 May 2015
Wow! So, you are the judge of your own cause!
If you are so qualified why you failed to solve your own problem? If qualified as CA, CMA, CS, MBA, may be your qualification as CA, CMA, and MBA not be able to solve your problem, but as a qualified Company Secretary, you were supposed to know the legal aspects of your problem and solution to that.
So, your own qualifications seem to be under cloud.
You have also not quoted any reason to reply the query of Shri Anirudh. That also put a big question mark on your qualifications.
Guest
(Expert) 08 May 2015
The biggest question arises, when you people can very well afford consultancy fee for setting up a profitable business, why you hanker after a charity by asking for a free advice?
T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate
(Expert) 09 May 2015
Mr. Vivek Ladha, you cannot be so arrogant while asking or seeking clarification/opinion from experts. You knew that this section is galaxy of experts hence you have approached here that finding this portal is doing a very good job in helping the distressed and needy people with excellent solutions and advises at free of cost. Though your intention was to avail this free of cost service, there are certain manners to be observed, never ever think that you can demand the opinions from experts, that way no expert will answer your query, you keep knocking the doors of this portal through any disguised way, you will not get any reply.
I dont find anything wrong in the observation made by expert Mr. Dhingra. Infact he has rightly asked you that for setting up a commercial establishment, why dont you utilise the paid consultancy from an expert consultant, in what way you found him to be wrong ? or how do you assess him and with what parameter that he is not qualified?
I dont think you deserve any opinion from any expert here.
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 09 May 2015
One does not have any right to question on competence of other. He very initially mentioned that you should be competent and it is negative impression that you are asking such problem.
I am not interested in his paid solution due to his arrogance. Why can not we pay, should not be the question from other.
If one wishes to put proposal, he should be straight forward, rather to talk useless that you are enough capable and all !!
Guest
(Expert) 09 May 2015
Mr. Vivek Laddha,
With reference to your latest advice, "One does not have any right to question on competence of other," does that apply only on others, not you when you declared, "you are not qualified?"
Don't worry, if you are not interested in paid solution, I am also not interested to have such an extraordinarily arrogant client.
Shri Kalaiselvan has rightly observed, "I dont think you deserve any opinion from any expert here," rather I can say that you don't deserve even any paid help from any one, what to say of free help, as you forget that charity or help seekers don't have the right to dictate their terms to the charity/ help givers.
In fact, if you really have four degrees of CA, CMA, CS, MBA, you should have known, humility is the first and foremost requirement of the help seeker.
By the way, what is your age presently?
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 09 May 2015
You are not qualified to me. If you are not interested, then why you are asking anything.
I am not here to give interview so why should I tell you the age.
Guest
(Expert) 09 May 2015
Mr. Vivek Laddha,
If you have posted question open for one and all in the open forum of LCI, you should have expected yourself to be interviewed on your unsatisfactory description by the members before arriving at some suitable opinion.
Here, you want to be a sole judge of your own cause, a sole authority to declare any one to be qualified or disqualified, and even a sole dictator of your own terms to the experts from whom you have sought help, when you fail yourself to satisfy the members who wish to solve your problem (which in no case is a problem for extensively qualified person, like you and your associate lawyers).
Is not it amazing that on failing yourself to satisfy even Shri Anirudh and Shari Kalaiselvan, you have declared me as, "you are not qualified to me"? In fact, you had the need to prove yourself qualified in accordance with the qualifications shown in your profile before posting your illogic query.
Leave aside me or Shri Kalaiselvan, you have not replied even the simplest question of Shri Anirudh, "After all you might have gone through the LLP Act. What is your understanding and what according to you is the answer to your query?" DOES not YOUR NON-REPLY CONTINUOUSLY FOR 2 DAYS PUT A BIGGEST QUESTION MARK ON YOUR OWN QUALIFICATIONS?
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 09 May 2015
Expert is spending time !!! Not here for responding the personal questions.
Guest
(Expert) 09 May 2015
First deserve and then expect the experts to respond your query that too, only in genuine problem.
Vivek Laddha
(Querist) 10 May 2015
Switched from paid solution to expert response !!
