Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Prave (Engineer)     30 September 2014

Divorce with mutual consent

Hello Folks,

I am an NRI engineer living in the UAE. I got married in the Consulate General of India in 2012 as per the foreign marriage act of 1969. Few months later we got married in India as well as per the Hindu marriage act. We actually have two marriage certificates, one issued by the Consulate and another issued by the municipality. Now our differences have grown out of proportion that proceeding further would run both of our lives. We are planning to get a divorce with mutual consent.

Since there exist more than one marriage contract, how do we go about it? Can someone please guide?



Learning

 2 Replies

Hardeep (Business)     01 October 2014

AFAIK, technically the second marriage is void since both of you were already married at the time, albeit to each other  ( luckily ! )

 

So, the foreign Marriage act should hold.

Tajobsindia (Senior Partner )     02 October 2014

@ Author,

 

1. If the parties first got their marriage registered under FMA and got their marriage registered under FMA then marriage registration certificate issued in accordance with Rules of FMA will govern their divorce too, be it under Mutual Consent route. 


2. Hence, under S. 18(1) of the FMA, the matrimonial reliefs would be granted to the parties under the SMA and not under HMA even though parties got their earlier registered marriage under FMA re-registered again under HMA.

 

3. Hence, the parties Mutual Consent Divorce will be done under S. 28(1) and S. 28(2) of the SMA only.



Note:
Except Muslim Marriages,  Registration Certificate issued under FMA or under HMA or be it under SMA is not a contract. 


Reasoning:


A. Under S. 14(2) of the FMA, the Registration Certificate is deemed to be conclusive evidence of the fact that the marriage is solemnised under the FMA, no evidence with regard to the fact that the marriage was further registered under HMA can, therefore, be allowed under S. 4 of the Evidence Act because such fact stands proved by virtue of the deeming provision.

 
FMA = Foreign Marriage Act, 1969 (As amended)
HMA = Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (As amended)
SMA = Special Marriage Act,1954 (As amended)

 

[Last reply]


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register