Remember | Register | Forgot Password?
Bookmark This Page   RSS Feeds  Follow On Twitter

 

Search for Lawyers          
    



Please Wait ..


Discussion > Civil Law > Difference between Registered Society and Co-Operative socie   Unanswered Threads Post New Topic

Pages : 1


There are 7 Replies to this message


N.K.Assumi


Advocate
[ Scorecard : 21791]
Posted On 03 June 2009 at 22:15 Report Abuse

What are the basic differences between Registered Society under the Societies Registration Act and Co-operative Society under the Co-Operative Society Act?



A V Vishal


Advocate
[ Scorecard : 19894]
Posted On 03 June 2009 at 22:37 Report Abuse

  Dear Assumi, 

Cooperative Societies Act is a Central Act. However, ‘Cooperative Societies’ is a State Subject (Entry 32 of List II of Seventh Schedule to Constitution, i.e. State List). Though the Act is still in force, it has been specifically repealed in almost all the States and those States have their own Cooperative Societies Act. Thus, practically, the Central Act is mainly of academic interest. - - – As per preamble to the Act, the Act is to facilitate formation of cooperative societies for the promotion of thrift and self-help among agriculturists, artisans and persons of limited means.
The Statement of Objects and reasons states as follows – (a) Cooperative Society can be established for purpose of credit, production or distribution. (b) Agricultural credit societies must be with unlimited liability. (c) Unlimited society is not best form of cooperation for agricultural commodities. However, the provision is continued as in several provinces (now States) such societies do exist and are working.  It is not intended to give them undue encouragement, but to legalise their existence. (d) Unlimited society can distribute profits with permission of State Government.
Registration of Society - State Government will appoint Registrar of Cooperative Societies. State Government can appoint persons to assist Registrar and confer on such persons all or any of powers of Registrar. [section 3]. Function of Registrar starts with registration of a society. He has powers of general supervision over society. Returns of Society are to be filed with Registrar. He can order inquiry or inspection against society. He can order dissolution of society.
Societies which may be registered – A society which has as its object the promotion of economic interests of its members in accordance with cooperative principles can be registered as a Society. Similarly, a society established with the object of facilitating operation of such a society can also be registered under the Act. The society can be registered with limited or unlimited liability. However, unless State Government otherwise directs, (1) Liability of a society of which a member is a registered society shall be limited. (2) Liability of a society of which object is to creation of funds to be lent to members, and of which majority of members are agriculturists and of which no member is a registered society shall be unlimited [section 4]. Thus, a registered society can be member of another society, but liability of such other society must be limited, unless State Government otherwise directs.
Who can form a society – A society can be formed with at least 10 members of age above 18 years. If object of society is creation of funds to be lent to its members, all the members must be residing in same town, village or group of villages or all members should be of same tribe, class, caste or occupation, unless Registrar otherwise directs.  - - The provision of minimum 10 members or residing in same town/village etc. is not applicable if a registered society is member of another society. - - The last word in name of society should be ‘Limited’. If the Society is registered with limited liability. [section 6]. Registrar is empowered to decide whether a person is agriculturist or non-agriculturist or whether he is resident of same town/village or whether the members belong to same caste/tribe etc. and his decision will be final. [section 7].
Restrictions on society with limited liability – If a society has limited liability, any individual member of such society cannot have share capital more than one-fifth of total capital. An individual member cannot have interest in shares exceeding Rs 1,000. - - This restriction of 20% shares or Rs 1,000 shares value is not applicable to a registered society which is member of another society. [section 5]. - - Thus, if a registered society is member of another society, it can hold shares exceeding 20% or exceeding Rs 1,000 in value.
Amendment of bye-laws – Any Amendment to bye-laws shall be registered with Registrar. If Registrar is satisfied that the amendment is not contrary to Act or rules, he will register the amendment. He will issue a certificate of registration along with copy of amendment certified by him, which is conclusive evidence that the amendment has been duly registered. [section 11].
Rights and liabilities of members – If liability of members is not limited by shares, each member shall have one vote irrespective of amount of his interest in the capital. [section 13(1)]. If liability of members of a registered society is limited by shares, each member will have as many votes as may be prescribed in bye-laws. [section 13(2)]. If a registered society has invested in shares of other registered society, it can vote by appointing a proxy. [section 13(3)].  - - A member of registered society shall not exercise his rights as member, unless he has made payment to society in respect of membership or has acquired interest in society, as may be prescribed by rules or bye-laws. [section 12]. Thus, if there is any default in payment to society, the member cannot exercise his rights. 
Management of society -  Each society will be managed by Committee. - - Committee means the governing body of a registered society to whom the management of its affairs is entrusted. [section 2(b)]. Officer of society includes a Chairman, Secretary, treasurer, member of Committee or other person empowered under rules or bye-laws to give directions in regard to business of society. [section 2(e)].
Registered Society is body corporate – A registered cooperative society is a body corporate with perpetual succession and common sea. (just like a company). It can hold property, enter into contracts, institute and defend suit and other legal proceedings and to do all things necessary for the purposes of its constitution. [section 18].
Priority claim of society dues from member  – A registered society is entitled to priority to other creditors and enforce outstanding demand due to society from any member. However, the priority is subject to prior claims of (a) Government dues in respect of land revenue or (b) Dues of landlord in respect of rent receivable by the landlord. The priority of society is in respect of following – (a) Supply of seed or manure or loan for purchase of seed or manure. The priority is upon the crops or other agricultural produce upto 18 months from date of supply of seed/manure or loan. (b) Supply of cattle or fodder of cattle, agricultural implements or machinery or raw materials or loan for these. The priority is upon the cattle/fodder/ machinery / raw materials supplied or any articles manufactured from raw materials supplied or purchased form loan given by society. [section 19].
Liability of past member – Liability of past members towards society as on the date he ceased to be member will continue for two years. [section 23].
Restrictions on loans – A registered society can give loans only to its members. However, it can give loan to another registered society with permission of Registrar. [section 29(1)]. A society with unlimited liability cannot lend money on security of movable property without sanction of registrar. [section 29(2)]. State Government, by issuing a general or special order, can prohibit or restrict lending of money on mortgage of immovable property by any registered society or class of registered society. 
Inspection of affairs of society – Registrar can hold an enquiry or direct some person authorised by him to hold enquiry in following circumstances – (a) Of his own motion (b) Request of Collector (c) Application by majority of committee members of society or (d) At least one-third of members of society. [section 35(1)]. All officers and members of society shall furnish necessary information to registrar or person authorised by him. [section 35(2)].
Dissolution of society – Registrar, after inspection or inquiry, or on application received from 75% of members of society, may cancel the registration of society, if in his opinion, the Society should be dissolved. Any member can appeal against the order of Registrar within two months to State Government or other Revenue Authority authorised by State Government. If no appeal is filed within two months, the order of dissolution shall become effective. If appeal is filed, the order will become effective only after it is confirmed by appellate authority. [section 39].
Companies Act not applicable – Provisions of Companies Act are not applicable to registered cooperative society. [section 48].

 

Purpose of the Act is to provide for registration of literary, scientific and charitable societies.

Societies Registration Act is a Central Act. However, ‘unincorporated literary, scientific, religious and other societies and associations’ is a State Subject (Entry 32 of List II of Seventh Schedule to Constitution, i.e. State List). Thus, normally, there should have been only State Laws on this subject. However, Societies Registration Act was passed in 1860, i.e. much before bifurcation of power between State and Centre was specified. Though the Act is still in force, it has been specifically repealed in many States and those States have their own Acts. Thus, practically, the Central Act is mainly of academic interest.

Societies to which the Act applies – Following societies can be registered under the Act - * Charitable societies * Military orphan funds or societies * Societies established for promotion of science, literature, or for fine arts * Societies established for instruction and diffusion of useful knowledge, diffusion of political education * Societies established for maintenance of libraries or reading rooms for general public * Societies established for Public museums and galleries for paintings or other works of art, collections of natural history, mechanical and philosophical inventions, instruments or designs [section 20]

Registration – Any seven or more persons associated for literary, scientific or charitable purpose can register a trust by subscribing their names to  memorandum of association. [section 1]. [The Act envisages filing the memorandum with Registrar of Joint Stock Companies. Practically, the memorandum will have to be filed with Registrar appointed under corresponding State Act]. - - The memorandum of association shall contain name and objects of society and names and addresses of governors/council/ directors or other governing body.  - - Copy of rules and regulations of society will also have to be filed along with memorandum. [section 2].

Annual list of managing body to be filed – Annual list of managing body should be filed within 14 days after AGM. [section4]. If there is no provision of AGM, then list should be filed in January every year. [section 4]. - - The governing body may be termed as governors, council, directors, committee, trustees or other body to whom by rules and regulations of society, the management of the affairs of society is entrusted. [section 16].

Society is not a body corporate – Society is not a body corporate. This is evident from following – (a) Entry 32 in List II of Schedule to Constitution itself uses the words ‘unincorporated’ (b) As per section 4, property of society vests in governing body, if not vested in trustees. Thus, property does not vest in society as such. (c) Section 6 states that suit by or against society can be only in name of President, Chairman, Principal Secretary or Trustees, as determined by rules of society. Thus, suit cannot be in name of society as such.

Office bearers not personally liable – Section 8 makes it clear that though suit against society is instituted in name of some person, he is not personally liable, but property of society will be liable.

Members of society – A member is a person who is admitted according to rules and regulations of society and who pays subscription, or signed the roll or list of members, and who has not resigned from membership. [section 15]. A member can be sued as stranger for arrear in subscription or if he injures or destroys property of society. [section 10]. Member guilty of offence of stealing, embezzlement or wilful destruction of society property can be punished as stranger, i.e. not a member. [section 11].

Alteration, extension of purposes, amlagamation  or dissolution – Society can alter, extend or abridge is purposes, or amalgamate with other society after approval of general meeting of members. [section 12]. Society can be dissolved if three-fifths of members determine to do so. [section 13]. Upon dissolution, balance amount should be given to other society and not to any member. [section 14].

 


N.K.Assumi


Advocate
[ Scorecard : 21791]
Posted On 04 June 2009 at 07:53 Report Abuse

Thanks Vishal for the response:


V.S.R.Deekshitulu


B.Sc, B.L
[ Scorecard : 155]
Posted On 05 June 2009 at 08:08 Report Abuse

Mr Vishal

Clongratulations,  you have taken lot of pains in giving the reply. Keep it up


mir mohamed ismail ali


service
[ Scorecard : 53]
Posted On 11 June 2009 at 14:56 Report Abuse

sir please let me know the person who is default in the repayment of laon in the co-operative society, wehter  this banks has got right of secising  i mean recovering the households items like fridge, music system etc etc.  please confirm

 

thank you

ismail ali ,            email id     mirali_smile@yahoo.com


V.S.R.Deekshitulu


B.Sc, B.L
[ Scorecard : 155]
Posted On 12 June 2009 at 07:49 Report Abuse

Mr Ali

Any creditor can realise his dues by bringing not only the immovable property but also the movable property to sale. There is no distinction in this regard between a Bank, or a co-operative society or any ordinary creditor. The item mentionedby you are not at all exempt from attachment or sale in a court of law. In this regard I direct you to refer Sec. 60 and Order 21 of C.P.C as regards the said subject.

I hope your problem is solved


V.S.R.Deekshitulu


B.Sc, B.L
[ Scorecard : 155]
Posted On 12 June 2009 at 07:55 Report Abuse

Mr. Ali

Your question is little confusing. You are mentioning Cooperative society and also Bank. Any how a creditor cannot the seize the movables of a debtor by himself, when he has no charge or hypothecation of the property in his favour. The only course is to proceed in a court of law. A Bank or a creditor who has a charge over the items mentioned in you querry, can seize the same.

One has to approch a court of law for such seizure through process of court only but not by himself. No body can take law into his hands. In this regard you may kindly refer to law of contracts regarding hypothecation, pledge etc. then you will understand the real picture. Right.


pankaj kumar agrawal


partner
[ Scorecard : 22]
Posted On 03 May 2012 at 18:37 Report Abuse

vishal ji

one more thing i wanted to know whether a society under societies registration act, 1860 can be formed for making housing society in delhi, in which members will be alloted shares of Rs. 100 each and then they can purchase land on cost contribution basis and then they can contribute for construction of houses on that land on cost basis.

thanks and waiting for your response

pankaj kumar agrawal



Related Files



Previous Thread
Previous
Next Thread
Next

Related Threads


Post your reply for Difference between Registered Society and Co-Operative socie



Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to login


Not a member yet ?? Click here to signup

Message







    

  • This is a public forum. Avoid posting content which you do not wish to disclose in public.
  • Use thank button to convey your appreciation.
  • Maintain professionalism while posting and replying to topics.
  • Try to add value with your each post.





Subscribe to the latest topics :


Forum Home | Forum Portal | Control Center | Who is Where | Popular Threads | Today's Topic | Recent Posts | Today's Posts | Post New Topic | Thread With Files | Top Threads - Month | Unreplied Topics | Forum Stats


web analytics