Strategy Implementation & Evaluation Notes

1. Formulation vs. Implementation

It's one thing to have a great plan, it's another to make it happen.

  • Formulation is the 'thinking' part. It's an entrepreneurial and intellectual process. It's about effectiveness (doing the right things).
  • Implementation is the 'doing' part. It's an administrative and operational task. It's about efficiency (doing things right).

A brilliant strategy with poor execution will fail. Success is a combination of a sound strategy and excellent implementation.

2. Strategic Change

Implementing a new strategy always involves change. A useful model for managing this is Kurt Lewin's:

Three Phases of Change:

  • Unfreeze: Prepare for change. Make people aware of the need and break down old habits.
  • Change: Implement the new strategy. This is the action phase where new behaviors and processes are introduced.
  • Refreeze: Make the change permanent. Reinforce the new ways of working until they become the norm.

3. Digital Transformation

This is a fundamental strategic change using digital tech to create new business processes or products.

Example: A bookstore chain closes physical stores and launches a successful e-commerce platform with an e-reader app. This requires a massive change in operations, marketing, and culture.

Effective change management is crucial for this to succeed.

4. Structure & Culture

The "hard" and "soft" sides of an organization must support the strategy.

Organization Structure (Hard):

The formal hierarchy. The rule is: "Structure follows strategy." You must design your organization to facilitate your strategy.

Organization Culture (Soft):

The shared values, beliefs, and behaviors. "The way we do things around here." A culture can be a powerful ally or a major obstacle to executing strategy.

5. Types of Org. Structure

Different strategies require different structures.

  • Simple: For small businesses (owner makes all decisions).
  • Functional: Grouped by function (Marketing, Finance, etc.).
  • Divisional: Grouped by product, geography, or customer. Good for large, diversified companies.
  • SBU (Strategic Business Unit): Similar divisions are grouped into larger SBUs.

6. Modern Structures

Newer structures are more flexible and adaptive.

  • Matrix: Employees report to both a functional manager and a project manager. Complex but good for cross-functional projects.
  • Network: A central hub outsources many functions. (e.g., A clothing brand designs in-house but outsources all manufacturing).
  • Hourglass: A lean middle management layer, with technology connecting the top and bottom levels directly.

7. Strategic Leadership

Leaders are crucial for driving implementation.

Two Key Styles:

  • Transactional: Focuses on control, systems, rewards, and punishments. Good for maintaining efficiency and stability.
  • Transformational: Uses charisma and vision to inspire people and drive major change. They motivate followers to go beyond expectations.

8. Strategic Control

This is the evaluation part: checking if the strategy is working and being implemented as planned.

Four Types of Control:

  • Premise Control: Are our underlying assumptions still true?
  • Implementation Control: Are we hitting our milestones?
  • Strategic Surveillance: General scanning for unexpected threats/opportunities.
  • Special Alert Control: A rapid review in response to a sudden crisis.

9. Performance Measures

How do you know if you're succeeding? You need to measure performance.

Key Categories:

  • Financial: Revenue, profit, ROI.
  • Customer: Satisfaction, retention, market share.
  • Employee: Satisfaction, turnover.
  • Innovation: New product launches, R&D spending.

Modern approaches like the Triple Bottom Line also consider People (social) and Planet (environmental) performance, not just Profit.