Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Mrs . Shanta Rani (Housewife)     07 April 2012

Succession - due process of law

We are 2 Sisters.

Our father, vide an “Unregistered WILL”, gave Property A (Self acquired) to my sister and Property B (inherited by him - Originally owned by my Grandfather i.e father’s father) to me.

Based on a NOC given by me, my sister got the mutation of Property A done in her name.

Since my sister lives in USA, she also gave me her NOC, after getting the same attested by the officials at the Indian Embassy in Washington DC before sending it to me for transfer of Property B in my name. This NOC was then certified by the Collector of stamps for payment of specific Stamp Duty in Delhi. As one of the points,the NOC states, “That the deceased had left behind the following heir including myself under Hindu Succession Act, and their names….. etc.”

Accordingly, the land holding authority (L&DO in this case) has substituted/transferred the lease in my favour. And MCD has also done the mutation in my name.

Suddenly, my sister, after 2 years, is now asking me to give her a Relinquishing Deed and have the same registered.

I am personally not very comfortable with her demand and smell some malafide intentions. Therefore, may I please request for advise as follows:

 1)   Is the above stated process followed by me to get the Property B transferred/Substituted as per law or can it be challenged in the court of law?

2)   Can my getting a NOC from her be considered as a possible case of obtaining it by coercion /duress /forgery or as such can the NOC be withdrawn?

3)    Can the actions taken by L&DO and MCD be challenged?

4)    Should I still go in for a Family settlement or a Relinquishing deed so as to safe guard myself from any future complications?

 

5)    Finally, what is the best way to safe guard me and my legal heirs’ interest for the future?



Learning

 12 Replies

V. VASUDEVAN (LEGAL COUNSEL)     07 April 2012

Is your sister asking for relinquishment deed in respect of property B ? Have you registered the property B in your name and started paying revenue, electricity bill etc.

Is the current market value of property B greater than A?, answer to these queries would help provide a suitable answer.

vasudevan

1 Like

Mrs . Shanta Rani (Housewife)     08 April 2012

Thank you for your response my Vasudeva !

As required...

No,my sister is not asking for relinquishing deed in respect to Property B. She wants it for Property A

Yes, the Property B stands in my name in the books of land holding authority (L&DO) and MCD to whom I am paying Lease and Property Tax. Additionally, the electricity meter is also transferred in my name and I pay the charges.

Yes, the current market value of Property B is more than that of Property A..

Having said that, my basic question is..

Is the above stated process(i.e. attestation by the officials of the Indian Embassy and Stamping by the collector of Stamps and transfer based on an NOC etc.) followed by me to get the Property B transferred/Substituted as per law or can it be challenged in the court of law?

regards

Shanta

V. VASUDEVAN (LEGAL COUNSEL)     08 April 2012

For property A, you can give the deed of relinquishment to complete the process. No issues and cool!
vasudevan

1 Like

J.M.P.Lobo (Practising Advocate)     08 April 2012

I  agree  with  the  opinions  expressed by  Shri.  Ashish  Davessar  and  Shri.  V. Vasudevan,  Advocates

1 Like

Mrs . Shanta Rani (Housewife)     08 April 2012

Thank you all !

But I still feel unclear.

Therefore, may I now request you to please reply to my 5 questions, point by point, as stated in my 1st message.

Regards

Shanta 

Ps. How  do I establish that the WILL was made voluntarily and is not vitiated due to lack of a free consentcept ? Is the NOC not an acceptance to the WILL?

I.S.Roy,Advocate (Advocate)     10 April 2012

Dear Mam

what is this term of lease in between your problem

Accordingly, the land holding authority (L&DO in this case) has substituted/transferred the lease in my favour. And MCD has also done the mutation in my name. So, give clear pricture abouta your problem please . Then I will agive correct suggestion

1 Like

Mrs . Shanta Rani (Housewife)     13 April 2012

Dear Mr Roy?

All that I wanna know is, whether my sister can impeach Property B which is now in my name under the Hindu succession Act as it was inherited by my father before giving it to me vide an unregistered WILL? Though, before the same being transferred to me, my sister did give an NOC to this effect

Regards

Shanta

kapil (NA)     14 April 2012

 1)   Is the above stated process followed by me to get the Property B transferred/Substituted as per law or can it be challenged in the court of law?...No. not unless there is a proof of malafide acts.

 

2)   Can my getting a NOC from her be considered as a possible case of obtaining it by coercion /duress /forgery or as such can the NOC be withdrawn?... NO coz the NOC was signed in a far away country in your absence and in presence of suitable authorities

3)    Can the actions taken by L&DO and MCD be challenged? YES. land revenue records are NOT proofs of title

4)    Should I still go in for a Family settlement or a Relinquishing deed so as to safe guard myself from any future complications? best is family settlement. mutual relinquishment deeds will have the smae effect

 

5)    Finally, what is the best way to safe guard me and my legal heirs’ interest for the future? as per 4 above

1 Like

Mrs . Shanta Rani (Housewife)     16 April 2012

Thanks to All !

I really appreciate your inputs !!

Now, just a clarification for Mr Kapil.

Sir,

Regading my Qs "

3)    Can the actions taken by L&DO and MCD be challenged? YES. land revenue records are NOT proofs of title "

My understanding is that L&DO ( Land and Development Office) which is part of Urban development Ministry is Land Holding agency. In other words, L&DO owns the land. We have a 99 year lease with them which was originally entered between them and my grand father.

Secondly, the substitution has been done by them.

Do you still believe that it is not a Proof of tittle? If so, then what would amount to be a Proof of Tittle?

kapil (NA)     25 April 2012

Mefe substitution is NOT proof of title at all... as held by various courts umpteen times.

There are millions of cases where 3rd party substitution is done with malafide intents.. would the property belong to such person(s)?

 

it is definitely challangeable at any point of time

 

 

It is best to have an unchallangeable line of succession// inheritance and ensure a certified copy of it  becomes a part of the substitution proceedings


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register