Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Ulhas   16 May 2016

Govt. servant exonerated from dowry death claims full pay al

This is regarding one of the empoyees working in our department (Lets name him Mr. X). Mr. X has been arrested under dowry death of his wife. He was sentenced life imprisonment and was sent to Jail. Due to this, the official wasn dismissed from Service as per departmental rules. Later Mr. X appealed in HC and was exonerated from all the charges (approx.after  7 years) and now claming for full pay and allowances.

Facts:-

  1. Mr. X has been arrested by police and was convicted for the officence, the facts were not known to the department till few months. This was his internal (or say family isue) with no concern with departmental proceedings.
  2. Mr. X went to jail and served imprisonment and gave no productivity to the department during this period. And now since he has been exonerated, he is claiming for full pay and allownaces as well as leave balance, which is drastic and big loss to department (considering  4 to 5 lacs his annual  income total comes around 35 Lacs apporx. Plus  leave for 7 years)

Now the question is-

  1. Though he has been exonerated from all charges, and department had nothing to do with the said matter, why should department pay Mr. X for the personal absence form duty he has made giving no productivity to department??
  2. Is there any refernce case similar to this??
  3. Guidance in the above case..


Learning

 4 Replies

Ulhas   01 June 2016

Ain't anybody to guide in this regards????

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     02 June 2016

you said

"

  1. Mr. X has been arrested by police and was convicted for the officence, the facts were not known to the department till few months. This was his internal (or say family isue) with no concern with departmental proceedings."

If deptt was not aware of his arrest then irrespective of his exhoneation by high court, it is a misconduct on his part. Even if reinstated he can beon continued suspension and disciplinary action can be taken which can result in dismissal.

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     02 June 2016

"and department had nothing to do with the said matter,:

 

You can say so s you have not fully read the Rule 3 of CCS(Coindut) rules.

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     02 June 2016

please see judgement of exhoneration and do not rush to any decision.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register