Supreme court on freedom of expression for nudity

You are equating Self Realization With Nudity .

Every person can do it in his own way not affecting others way or his vision of what self realization is

Bliss can be nude , fully clothed , vaccum, Swarg, Nark , Omnipresent, Omnipotent, Self Developing, Self  destructing etc etc

IT MAY NOT BE JUST NUDITY

A CHILD JUST BORN IS SEEN AS A CUTE BABY RATHER THAN A NUDE CUTE BABY

Breast feeding cannot be looked as a symbol of Nudity

Its your own View to EQUATE THEM BOTH

BUT HAVE BELIEF THAT THERE MAY BE OTHER VIEWS WHICH MAY BE MORE SUBLIME THAN YOURS

Mr. godbole

you said that

You may dance being Nude in your Bedroom and ask  counterpart to join you

But  that cannot be done in Public Street in London , Paris, New York, Sweeden or in New Delhi , being transgressing the others Right to remain in Cultured Dress .

in your previous reply to siddhartharoyi

do you know that there are NUDE beach in europe where you can be NUDE in PUBLIC and nobody will oppose you? moreover the way western women dress themselves (  bikini, microskirt)  which part of their body remains hidden? if you have ever seen the coastal cities of america you will see young women move on public road wearing different types of bikini exposing most of ( 99% , if possible to quantify) their bodies. nobody sue them.

actually in india women are still subdued by men. in india a man can move on the road wearing  just a barmuda and can move on beach with just a chaddi but women are forbidden to show up in public. this shows the unequal treatment between men and women. and this unequal treatment is shown as indian culture. actually indian culture is an unequal culture.

and people like you are the holder, promoter, keeper of this unequal culture. you boast of your unequal indian culture in front of foreigners which really diminish india's image internationally. i know i can't change you. nobody can. you are just a rock with your own stubbornness. there is no hope for equality in  india so long people like you are there.

Mr. Godbole,

At first it very nice that you have some interest in nudity , you know it is a natural god gifted position , when we come and go to and from the Earth we all creatures are equal , we man has differentiate it from god , who made us divine. By cloths we all differentiate each others.And by difference we are getting indulge with (Pap Karmas-Kam,Krodh,Moha etc.)some wrong ways to live .

Through nudity all those (Pap Karmas-Kam,Krodh,Moh etc.)wrong ways may be a little bit more controlled .

Nudity is an Indian culture of many-many centuries ago , it was actually born in India , now we are not accepting it , we use to keep nude statutes , even we worship nude statutes in hindu religion . 

Before we going nude some bad thinking we think that it is not good , that thought is bad , bad for all.

When everyone will live Nude , go to office Nude , Go to schools Nude , Teach children nude , ride a bicycle, eat in a restaurant , walk on a street (ALL of them ) in Nude , Child , brother sister , mother , father , grandfather , daughter , friends and all the 120 Cr people in India will start living nude  FROM BIRTH TILL DEATH , AT THAT TME THE TERM OR THE FEELINGS  OF VULGARITY ATTACHED TO THE WORD NUDITY MAY VANISH

AT THAT POI*NT OF TIME WAERING CLOTHES BY SOME MAY BE TERMED AS  COMING UNDER PRIVATE SPACE AND THEN CLOTHED HUMAN BEINGS MAY BE SAID TO BE LIVING IN DIFFERENT AGE .

YOUR REFERENCE TO THE NUDE  BEACH  IS POINTING TO THAT DAY

BUT MIND YOU EVEN AFTER 120 CRORES GO NUDE ANOTHER QUESTION OF BEING CLOTHED WHILE GOING IN SOCIETY WILL BE TERMED AS CULTURED  AT THAT POINT OF TIME AND PEOPLE LIKE YOU WILL RAISE A QUESTION WHY THEY CANNOT WEAR CLOTHES AND SUPREME COURT OF US OR INDIA WILL HAVE TO ADJUDGE THAT QUESTION

 SO SOME LINE HAS TO BE DRAWN BETWEEN BEING DISCIPLINED AND NOT DISCIPLINED , BEING A MURDER AND NOT A MURDER , BEING AN ADULT OR NOT AN ADULT  AND BEING CORRUPT AND NOT CORRUPT , BEING GOOD AND BAD , BEING CULTURED AND NOT CULTURED ETC  ETC .

                              YOU MAY DECIDE FOR YOURSELF

                             AS OF NOW THE DEMARCATION BETWEEN NUDITY  AND NOT NUDE , BETWEEN PRIVATE SPACE AND PUBLIC SPACE , STLL EXIST  BEING CERTIFIED AS ADULT CONTENT BY FILM CERTIFICATION  AND TO ALL ADULT WEB SITES ETC .

The Earth is moving and time is going on and on now at the present situation what the time actually need that is NUDITY the time is very near about that , just look every where in TV,Computer,Mobiles,Dresses ,more which increasing all of the Devils inside us  , So the time has come to control them ,  more we hide (our devils) more they attack , In Bhagwat Gita Lord Shree Krishna also said that NATURE WILL DO BY YOU, IF YOU DON'T DO THAT.

So go with nature for we all live with LOVE and PEACE  if you like it.

Thank you Mr. Arnab for your support.

You HAVE NOT HIT THE BULLS EYE

BUT SIDESTEPPEDTHE ISSUE

MY POINT WAS

EVEN IF THE EARTH IS MOVING

IN EVERY AGE THE DEMARCATION LINE WILL ALWAYS REMAIN

THAT IS A FACT LIKE RISING OF SUN IN THE EAST

YOU SEEM TO SUGGEST THE SUN MAY RISE FROM ALL ANGLES

AND SET IN ALL DIRECTIONS

WELL ON THAT DAY THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A GIRL AND BOY , BROTHER SISTER , MOTHER AND FATHER , A WHITE AND BLACK , LORD KRISHNA , AND LORD PAIGHAMBER WILL VANISH

IF THAT HAPPENS THEN YOUR DREAMS WILL COME TRUE

AM AFRAID NOT BEFORE

OR WE WILL EXIST IN KALIYIYUG AS STATED IN RAMAYANA AND MAHABHARATA

At the present time we are living with TV,Mobile,Computers,Films, Dresses all the things doing such a thing that like to giving a sweet to a child and again hide it ,this creasing the bad happenings with us .

We have  to do something that we should not have to hide from any body any works any things (except which are cruel like operation to a patient ).

It will help us to make our country  a PEACE FULL country as we want it. 

the point Mr suresh godbole is that i am advocating about freedom of people. in my world people can live either nude or clothed as per their DESIRE. now living NUDE is forbidden by cynical people like you. people cannot be nude even if they desire.

in america and west PEOPLE CAN LIVE EITHER NUDE OR CLOTHED BASED ON THEIR VERY OWN DESIRE. NO CYNICAL, RETARDED PEOPLE FORBED THEM THERE. THIS IS TRUE FREEDOM.

IT IS POINTLESS TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT FREEDOM SINCE YOU ARE A FREEDOM-BLIND MAN  I ONLY WISH INDIA COULD HAVE THAT FREEDOM WHICH THE WEST IS ENJOYING NOW.

THANK YOU MR. SURESH " FREEDOM-BLIND" GODBOLE.

Actually most people in this country do not know the real meaning of freedom and liberty. They are still reeling under the slave mindest. Similar people are also unfortunately sometimes sitting in courts and giving absurd and nonsense judgments. Such judgments only lower the dignity/respect of courts and make mockery of themselves not only in this country but all over the world.

The basic test of freedom is perhaps less in what we are free to do than in what we are free not to do. - Eric Hoffer

There is another US Supreme Court judgment in Brandenburg v. Ohio - 395 U.S. 444 (1969) that held the government cannot punish free speech even if it is inflamatory unless it is directed to inciting, and likely to incite, "imminent lawless action."  Even advocacy of violence is protected under free speech. It gave rise to Brandenburg test -- of intent, imminence, and likelihood. The judgment and the test still holds sway today. Can we expect such a bold judgments from our Supreme Court? The judgment can be read at https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/395/444/case.html

only if a miracle takes place in india.

Dear sir,

Nudity should stay in public because of maximum weastern country do so.

If we all are freedom, we should have the liberity at all.

Please reply sir.

Thank you

The TRUTH is NAKED

in OUR COUNTRY we say STYAMEVA JAYATE...............................

Thank you...............................

The TRUTH is NAKED

in OUR COUNTRY we say SATYAMEVA JAYATE...............................

Thank you...............................