Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Damayanti (Unemployed)     04 May 2013

When to adduce rebuttal evidence against frivolous wife!!

when and How to adduce rebuttal evidence against  a frivolous wife ! who is a petitioner in divorce trial and husband has not made any counter claim .......... so as to catch red-haned in her cross exam????

 

 

 

Currently, Wife has given her Exam-in-chief affidavit 

 

 

And her cross exam is awaited.

 

 

Husband wants to disprove her averments/allegations as utter falsity  ..................... and thus wants to rebut her ORAL EVIDENCE of those false allegations by producing concrete/original documents and many other statements such as Income tax returns/sale deeds and her bank account statements and also photos videos taken by him ................ during her CROS EXAM.

 

 

The husband's question is that  ...

 

 

DOES the law /CPC  REQUIRE/MANDATE the RESPONDENT-husband TO GIVE GIVE A PRIOR NOTICE of HIS REBUTTAL EVIDENCE  TO PLAINTIFF-wife??? 

 

 

Husband is afraid that .......................if  husband gives any prior info to wife, it is likely that wife may try to wipe out all that evidence or even may find some excure and evasive answer to the same!!!!!

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

My view was that Order 13 of CPC differentiates between parties to suit (i.e. those who obviously know facts indisputes and aren't unaware of fact of the disputed matter themselves) andother witnesses of those parties

 

 

And rules as to 'suprise to witness' and failure to give notice of Evidence apply only to Other witnesses and not parties themselves.

 

 

 

So....................... Can the husband give a surprise to wife and catch her red handed in WITNESS BOS by tendering those material documents just during CROSS of her without giving any inkling to her prior to that?


 

 

Please advise.

 

Thanks


 

 

 

Would 

 



Learning

 2 Replies

Damayanti (Unemployed)     04 May 2013

Isn't it true that 

 

And rules as to 'suprise to witness' and failure to give advance notice of Evidence apply only to Other witnesses and ...................  NOT  to parties to suit themselves.

Shantanu Wavhal (Worker)     04 May 2013

no party is allowed to travel beyond the pleadings.

i.e.

the petitioner wont be allowed to travel beyond the pleadings in the petition.

the respondent wont be allowed to travel beyond the pleadings in the WS.


in cross, only those questions will be allowed which cover the ISSUES already framed + averments in the Petition + averments in the WS

 

otherwise it may amount to starting a NEW case.

 

for any additional points the hon. court may grant permission if the party introducing the additional points succeeds to convince the court that those points were not deliberately skipped in petition / WS.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register