if two reports had been registered in different police station with regard to an offence, and contradictory reports have been presented in the Court by respective investigating officer, what proceedings should be adopted by the magistrate.
Don't just waste your valuable time, if it's true and the court has taken cognizance on both the reports and issued criminal proceedings against the accused, then file revision before the concerned H.C. under section 482 Cr PC.
respected Vashisht sir it's a real problem came before judicial magistrate Allahabad, actually two reports had been registered in respect of the same offence in different police station and two different investigation report came from different police station in respect of the same offence, one of which the final report has been presented by investigating officer and the other investigating officer presented charge sheet,
Even if, with the new story that 'A' police station submitting FR, means that no evidence was found against the accused. So the accused was absolved by the 'A' police, then probably the court may have not taken cognizance of the alleged crime. But 'B' police submitting charge sheet meant that evidence was found against the same very accused. However the querist is silent whether both the reports were submitted to the same court or in two different courts. Whether the other court has taken cognizance or not on the charge sheet of 'B' police. So, Dr. Vashisht is correct, that it is hypothetical statement.
Vivek Chauhan may be half true, as, such foolish things are norm in my state U.P., but the empathy is that he is selective in query and not only that in such a foolish case maybe he himself not involved. So, my suggestion is to not to answer him any more instead carry on with helping others.