How to marriage with my father's sister's daughter

Legal Evangelist - TRIPAKSHA

Custom should be followed in the community and not place.

 

The marriage would be a void marriage, so beware.

 

 

Regards,

 

Shonee Kapoor

harassed.by.498a@gmail.com

 
Reply   
 

What nonsense goes on here, all the time.
 
Reply   
 


Scientist/Engineer

I think Mr. Sunil Sharma has stopped listening. Let me now take on the Maharashtrian Hindu, Mr. Medhap. I do not want him have the last word. He says that among them cross-cousin marriages are permitted, because they belong to different families. Actually he means different gothras. Even parallel cousins on mother’s side can come from different families (gothras). Do they also marry among Maharashtrian Hindus?  Further South from Maharashtra, maternal uncle marries sister’s daughter. The justification is same as what Mr. Medhap says, that they belong to different families (gothras). Whereas such close blood relations marry, no Hindu anywhere in India can marry even the 10th cousin on the paternal side because they would belong to the same gotra. Often it can happen that boy and girl belong to the same gothra but they would not even know whether they had common ancestors. Still they cannot marry.

The marriage rules originate in the belief that inheritance is transmitted only through the male and not the female. The sperm is considered as the seed and the womb, the soil. Seed determines what plant will come out and not the soil. In Christianity the entire humanity are sinners, because they inherit the original sin from Adam. But Jesus Christ was not a sinner, because his father was God Himself.

Whatever various religions say, modern knowledge says that inheritance is from both sides. In order to maintain the quality of the population, let us not justify customs and become the cause for creating sick individuals.

 
Reply   
 
Banana Master

"Whatever various religions say, modern knowledge says that inheritance is from both sides. In order to maintain the quality of the population, let us not justify customs and become the cause for creating sick individuals.

Absolutely true Ramani sir.

 
Reply   
 
corruptissima re publica plurimae leges

In Avunculate cultures sisters daughters can be married. Sociobilogically too. The framers of these Acts don't know what Recessive genes are. Strangely even the so called educated ones are blisfully unaware of facts. Anyway no point fighting against a wall.

 

PERIOD.

 
Reply   
 
Scientist/Engineer

Avunculate culture and avuncular marriage are two different things. In fact in Avunculate cultures, avuncular marriages are forbidden. The nairs of Keralam can be said to follow avuncular system in matters of joint family and property inheritance. But marriage between a man and his sister’s daughter is a strict no no among them. Just as in patriarchies same gotram marriages are forbidden, among nairs of Keralam same tharavad marriages are not allowed. There tharavad replaces gotram.

In fact avuncular marriages are the rule in the other three Southern states viz. Tamilnad, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh, where patriarchal system is followed.

What is the connection between maternal uncle – niece marriage and recessive genes? Is it that defective genes will remain recessive only, in avuncular marriages?  I am not a stone wall, though poor in understanding things. I shall be happy to be enlightened on this subject.  Let the lawyers also learn some genetics, so that they won’t be stone walls if and when they may have occasion to draft bills.

 
Reply   
 
corruptissima re publica plurimae leges

@Dr.RAMANI: A man invests 3/4th of genes in his sister's daughter through natural selection or rather Socio Biology. Such Genes are not recessive at all. Likewise for cousins as mentioned above. Read SOCIOBIOLOGY by E.O Wilson, Paul A Samuelson, Ivan E Eibeldfeld "HUMAN ETHOLOGY(not ENTHNOLOGY)], Gruyter,1998. Try google scholar to get hold a researches into this rather interesting subject. No usual links will give you the information. I'll see if I have a rough draft of my paper on Genetic Cycles and their Synocronization with Politico-Economic Cycles. South India has an avunculate culture hence we see gorgeous and healthy women like Rekha, Sri Devi, Vidya Balan, and South Indian men are healthier than north Indians. Try nature.com but there you will get confused by the technical jargon. I'll try uploading some of my proven reaerch papers as well as those of the geniuses mentioned above. Hindu Prohibted degrees of Relationships is ANTIQUATED and cannot be taken seriously.

 
Reply   
 
Advocate High Court Chandigarh M:09814110005 email:adv.kamal.grover@gmail.com

As per Hindu Marriage Act, it is not possible.

But there are various other ways out. but for that you need a detailed discussion.

Regards

 
Reply   
 
corruptissima re publica plurimae leges

@Dr.RAMANI, I'm attaching a copy of my proven research paper[One of the numerous]. Its just the roough draft and was published in early 90's. This may not suffice and the one on Receesive genes etc. ,many antiquated Prohibited degrees of relations is on a CD with I'll upload later. This might give you an idea of how Law must evolve in Consonance with Scientific Developments. This paper was published and read in University of Geneva and in A European Journal. For any questions you can PM me.



Attached File : 141100 219518 55 geneticsynchoronicity.pdf downloaded 112 times
 
Reply   
 

If you love her then please go for marriage . IMO if some one is not in your blood relation there should not be any issue.

In many parts of India still Hindu's marriage to their ralatives.

With best wishes.

 
Reply   
 

LEAVE A REPLY


    

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  



 

Search Forum:








×

  LAWyersclubindia Menu