Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

498_final stage (Professional)     26 March 2014

Can i file 120b besides defamation and perjury??

Tell me if 120B is applicable in my case based on the following evidences

 

After hardly one week of the marriage the girl started threatening me of 498a case. I left my parent's house and took her away to Gurgaon where she also got a job. Even there she used to abuse and ill treat me. She used to hit/abuse me like a dog.

 

Finally I decided to record her statements, there it is recorded that she would set my sister and mother to fire. She will ask for 50 Lakh to 1 crore rupees and file false cases. She also said that she will make a scene in front my parental house

 

1) Before 1 week of filing 498a - Wife wrote me an email and said that I want a divorce from you and I have told this to my mother and my family. The legal proceedings will take place now. 

 

2) During the week of filing 498a - Her mother come to my Gurgaon house from Kanpur and they called my parents and they (her mother and daughter) abused my mother

 

3) The day 8th October2012 - Wife started fighting with me, I somehow took her back to home. She continued her Animal behaviour and called her mother, her sister called 100 number in Gurgaon. Police came in took her statement. By the time her mother came in and she wrote a complaint to Gurgaon police that we are harassing her for dowry. The girl went with her mother and sister and an unknown man who came with them

 

4) 9th October 2012 - Entire family went to the Police station. She (her mother and the girl) wrote there that they would take action further from Ghaziabad. File Closed at Gurgaon Police Station

 

5) 10th October 2012 - I started getting threat calls from an unknown man who claimed to be her brother. This brother we never saw anywhere in the marriage though. They attacked my Ghaziabad house at 11pm. The girl started shouting at the doors and made a scene (as she said 4 months ago in the audio recordings). Neighbours came in and her mother said that she would not let me come out of Jail for 6 months at least. The girl went inside the bedroom opened the almira and took her jewellery which my mother gave her.

 

6) Death of my father (18th Dec 2012) - My father died of a heart attack after this incident. 

 

7) They filed another case DV from Kanpur in December 2012

 

8) Girl's Mother started threatening me (Phone call recorded), that if I come to Kanpur then she would see me. In the mediation, girl said that she want to come back but I should send my mother somewhere else.

 

9) Mediation failed. cases are going on

 

10) She never had a father but now we see there is a man who claim to be her father and defending her and want to solve the case through mediation.

So I want to ask

 

For 120 B I read that there should be 2 person and they should plan something which may lead to physical and mental damage to the person.

 

In this case, the girl was definitely manouvered by her mother (who also left her husband in her days), does the EMAIL and the AUDIO RECORDING AND WHAT THEIR CLAIM IN THE COURT SAYS,,, amounts to 120 B

 

I am going to file Perjury as well since the girl and her mother recently in her Domestic Violence case mentioned that she is not earning any more because of mental torture and harassement done to her.

However, the fact says a different picture... she has been working rather I have lost my job because I can not travel outside India and in my job travel is mandatory.

 

Kindly suggest, besides Defamation, Can I file 120B?



Learning

 7 Replies

Hareshkumar Shrimali (Branch Executive)     27 March 2014

Dear Victim,            Plz read the following Judgment of Gujarat High Court :

 

Mayaben Arjunsinh Vasadia vs Arjunsinh Dhirajsinh Vasadia And ... on 18 June, 1996. Search it in indiakanoon.com

See also : Chandubhai Jethabhai Desai vs The State And Anr. on 29 September, 1961  Gujarat High Court

BEST OF LUCK.

 

HARESHKUMAR SHRIMALI

08530155400

T. Kalaiselvan, Advocate (Advocate)     28 March 2014

In my opinion, you first challenge the 498a case against you appropriately, come out of it successfully, then go for perjury or defamation case according to the circumstance then.

Biswanath Roy (Advocate)     06 April 2014

Perjury case and defamation case is not clashing with the proceeding u/s.498A IPC hence, you can proceed with the same simultaneously and can tag your mother-in-law along with u/s/120B.

1 Like

498_final stage (Professional)     07 April 2014

Dear Biswanath G,

Thanks a lot for your advice sir. She is Mother OUT OF LAW not IN LAW> ... For her Law is something which is just seen on paper not in reality.

You would be surprized to know that she herself call her a Lawyer, she left her husband without taking any divorce, her first husband married a woman, without divorcing his first woman.

And that man claims now that he was present in the marriage. So I am dealing with some piece of sh*ts from KANPUR.

One more thing, I have heard that there is NO LAW AND ORDER IN KANPUR, THE JUDGE IS EASILY SOLD AND LAWYERS RULES THERE.

Is that a fact??

Biswanath Roy (Advocate)     07 April 2014

Don't be afraid . BE BOLD AND CHALLENGING otherwise scrupulous people will bend you down.  Always remember the common English proverb " SURVIVAL FOR THE FITTEST "  Bear it in mind that the Kanpur Court is not the last forum to adjudicate your just grievances.  In law there is an word BIAS.  If any Judge is found bias the law provides to shift the case before some other court" upon an application of the agrieved litigant.

Adv k . mahesh (advocate)     07 April 2014

why you have waited all this years I don't understand just in a weeks of your marriage if she has treatinend your of 498a means what gone in between you both is the main question we cannot blame only your wife alone because she has her reservations from her end of life .

now after filing all the cases you came to light and want to file this prejury is fine 

don't worry about the sitting judge because for every wrong doing their is a solution but you can take action on that also 

498_final stage (Professional)     07 April 2014

Hi Mahesh,

She had some strange behavior. She can not hear no to anything. If you say no then she used to behave as a DOG (I mean it) I am bitten by her. SHe scratched my face number of times. Her language would change suddenly. She used to behave as if she is some pros

She never had problem with me (ACCEPTED IN MAHILA THANA) but she had problem with my elder sister who never lived with us, with my mother and my father who is no more now.

She wanted to come back but I refused.

If you personally ask me.. SHE had some personality disorder problem which we tried to told to her mother and she said that you are making my daughter a mad for dowry.

I WAITED BECAUSE MY LAWYER'S SAID SO. YOU KNOW LAWYERS MOSTLY ARE DALLALS OF LAW, THATS THE REASON PEOPLE HAVE TO WRITE THEIR QUERIES HERE.

They also said unless 498a is dismissed there is no point of filing counter cases, they may go against us. (I dont know what does that mean)

Perjury depends on the status of the case, which now we are going to do.

Any other question you may have Mahesh???


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register