Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

rumi saikia (none)     04 November 2011

Does it comes under sapinda or prohibited relationship

I AM PRESENTING BELOW OUR RELATIONSHIP DRAWING.

A MAN WHO HAS TWO SONS, 

ELDER SON RAM AND YOUNGER SON JADU.

BOTH RAM AND JADU GOT MARRIED.

RAM HAS A DAUGHTER NAMED ANJU .AGAIN ANJU GOT MARRIED TO DIFFERENT CASTE BUT IN SAME RELIGION .

JADU HAS A SON NAMED MOHAN.

I AM DAUGHTER OF MOHAN AND MY BOY FRIEND IS SON OF ANJU.


NOW PLZ TELL ME IS IT POSSIBLE FOR US TO GET MARRIED. OR WE SHOULD
SACRIFICE OUR LOVE.DOES IT COMES UNDER SAPINDA RELATIONSHIP OR ANY OTHER PROHIBITED RELATIONSHIP



Learning

 15 Replies

kumar t v s (advocate)     04 November 2011

Under hindu law, especially in South India this marriage is perfectly valid.

 

Your father Mohan and your boy friends Mother are cousigns. The marriage is valid.

1 Like

sridhar pasumarthy (ADVOCATE)     05 November 2011

Dear Rumi,

You did not mention ur regligion.  If you belong to Hindu religion, you can marry him. There is no legal bar.

Happy married life in advance.

1 Like

Dr. MPS RAMANI Ph.D.[Tech.] (Scientist/Engineer)     05 November 2011

YOU ARE SECOND COUSINS AND CROSS COUSINS.  UNDER HINDU MARRIAGE ACT THE MARRIAGE IS PERMITTED, WHETHER YOU ARE NORTH OR SOUTH, EAST OR WEST.

1 Like

rumi saikia (none)     06 November 2011

My problem is that I am in a love with a boy who is relative of mine.

sir, so plz help me what should I do. Should I marry with him.Nobody
knows at my house.I am not getting courage to tell about our
relationship to my family.Even my boy friend is also worried regarding
our relationship.

I AM PRESENTING BELOW OUR RELATIONSHIP STATUS.

A MAN WHO HAD TWO SONS, ELDER SON RAM AND YOUNGER SON JADU.BOTH RAM
AND JADU GOT MARRIED.RAM HAD A DAUGHTER NAMED ANJU AND JADU HAD A SON
NAMED MOHAN
.ANJU GOT MARRIED TO OTHER CASTE i.e Non Assamese Man and she had a son named Raj Singh.I AM RUMI SAIKIA (ASSAMESE=HINDU) DAUGHTER OF MOHAN AND MY BOY FRIEND RAJ SINGH(NON ASSAMESE=HINDU) IS SON OF ANJU.

NOW PLZ TELL ME IS IT POSSIBLE FOR US TO GET MARRIED. OR WE SHOULD
SACRIFICE OUR LOVE.

N.B- PLZ NOTE THAT ANJU DAUGHTER OF  RAM MARRIED TO NON - ASSAMESE
BOY.SO MY BOY FRIEND IS ALSO NON-ASSAMESE.also plz let me know that does this type of marriage valid in ASSAM.Whether it is allowed ore it comes under any sapinda or prohibited relationship.

rumi saikia (none)     06 November 2011

My problem is that I am in a love with a boy who is relative of mine.

sir, so plz help me what should I do. Should I marry with him.Nobody
knows at my house.I am not getting courage to tell about our
relationship to my family.Even my boy friend is also worried regarding
our relationship.

I AM PRESENTING BELOW OUR RELATIONSHIP STATUS.

A MAN WHO HAD TWO SONS, ELDER SON RAM AND YOUNGER SON JADU.BOTH RAM
AND JADU GOT MARRIED.RAM HAD A DAUGHTER NAMED ANJU AND JADU HAD A SON
NAMED MOHAN
.ANJU GOT MARRIED TO OTHER CASTE i.e Non Assamese Man and she had a son named Raj Singh.I AM RUMI SAIKIA (ASSAMESE=HINDU) DAUGHTER OF MOHAN AND MY BOY FRIEND RAJ SINGH(NON ASSAMESE=HINDU) IS SON OF ANJU.

NOW PLZ TELL ME IS IT POSSIBLE FOR US TO GET MARRIED. OR WE SHOULD
SACRIFICE OUR LOVE.

N.B- PLZ NOTE THAT ANJU DAUGHTER OF  RAM MARRIED TO NON - ASSAMESE
BOY.SO MY BOY FRIEND IS ALSO NON-ASSAMESE.also plz let me know that does this type of marriage valid in ASSAM.Whether it is allowed ore it comes under any

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     06 November 2011

Dear Rumi Saikia, apart from what the experts has posted, we all know what is prohibited relationships, but they exist in name only which is only a creation of the society mental set up and so it exist in Hindu Laws. But why on earth are you scared if you truly Love each other. Even in Nagaland we do have that kind of prohibited relationship which are mostly ignored after the marriage. So get on the Board and start your life with your true Love. Lovers should live like the Gauls who are not scared of anything except the sky falling on their heads. All the best Rumi and your lovers.

Dr. MPS RAMANI Ph.D.[Tech.] (Scientist/Engineer)     06 November 2011

@ Advocate N. K. Assumi

Does what you say apply if a brother loves his sister and want to marry her?

Dr. MPS RAMANI Ph.D.[Tech.] (Scientist/Engineer)     06 November 2011

@ Rumi Saikia

Your Aunt was bold enough to marry a non-Assamese Hindu. Now why do you lack courage to marry her son? Go ahead. You can even get a registered marriage as a Hindu marriage.

N.K.Assumi (Advocate)     06 November 2011

Deqr Dr. Is brother and sister a cousin or a cross cousin? 

rumi saikia (none)     07 November 2011

My problem is that I am in a love with a boy who is relative of mine.

sir, so plz help me what should I do. Should I marry with him.Nobody
knows at my house.I am not getting courage to tell about our
relationship to my family.Even my boy friend is also worried regarding
our relationship.

I AM PRESENTING BELOW OUR RELATIONSHIP STATUS.

A MAN WHO HAD TWO SONS, ELDER SON RAM AND YOUNGER SON JADU.BOTH RAM
AND JADU GOT MARRIED.RAM HAD A DAUGHTER NAMED ANJU AND JADU HAD A SON
NAMED MOHAN
.ANJU GOT MARRIED TO OTHER CASTE i.e Non Assamese Man and she had a son named Raj Singh.I AM RUMI SAIKIA (ASSAMESE=HINDU) DAUGHTER OF MOHAN AND MY BOY FRIEND RAJ SINGH(NON ASSAMESE=HINDU) IS SON OF ANJU.

NOW PLZ TELL ME IS IT POSSIBLE FOR US TO GET MARRIED. OR WE SHOULD
SACRIFICE OUR LOVE.

N.B- PLZ NOTE THAT ANJU DAUGHTER OF  RAM MARRIED TO NON - ASSAMESE
BOY.SO MY BOY FRIEND IS ALSO NON-ASSAMESE.also plz let me know that does this type of marriage valid in ASSAM.Whether it is allowed ore it comes under any sapinda or prohibited relationship.

Dr. MPS RAMANI Ph.D.[Tech.] (Scientist/Engineer)     07 November 2011

You have to gather courage and if there is opposition from family both of you should stand firm. You talk to each other and decide how to proceed. You are not Sapindas. Sapindas are paralell cousins whose ascendancy is purely through father his father etc. You are related to him through your father. But he is related to you through his mother. Under Hindu marriage Act matriarchial descendents are also considered sapindas up to 3 generations. But cross cousins are never Sapindas. The term Sapinda comes from the word pinda meaning a rice ball. Rice balls are used in rituals performed to dead ancestors. Your father will offer pinda to his father. Your non-Assamese uncle will offer pinda to his non-Assamese ancestors.

You have to talk to each other and make up your mind. Then convey to your respective parents. If they agree be happy and go ahead. If they do not, you can go to the Office of Registrar of marriages and get married. In order to be really safe you can go out of Assam and get married.

There is no alternative to courage.

1 Like

rumi saikia (none)     13 November 2011

My problem is that I am in a love with a boy who is relative of mine.

sir, so plz help me what should I do. Should I marry with him.Nobody
knows at my house.I am not getting courage to tell about our
relationship to my family.Even my boy friend is also worried regarding
our relationship.

I AM PRESENTING BELOW OUR RELATIONSHIP STATUS.

A MAN WHO HAD TWO SONSELDER SON RAM AND YOUNGER SON JADU.BOTH RAM
AND JADU GOT MARRIED.RAM HAD A DAUGHTER NAMED ANJU AND JADU HAD A SON
NAMED MOHAN
.ANJU GOT MARRIED TO OTHER CASTE i.e Non Assamese Man and she had a son named Raj Singh.I AM RUMI SAIKIA (ASSAMESE=HINDU) DAUGHTER OF MOHAN AND MY BOY FRIEND RAJ SINGH(NON ASSAMESE=HINDU) IS SON OF ANJU.

NOW PLZ TELL ME IS IT POSSIBLE FOR US TO GET MARRIED. OR WE SHOULD
SACRIFICE OUR LOVE.

N.B- PLZ NOTE THAT ANJU DAUGHTER OF  RAM MARRIED TO NON - ASSAMESE
BOY.SO MY BOY FRIEND IS ALSO NON-ASSAMESE.also plz let me know that does this type of marriage valid in ASSAM.Whether it is allowed ore it comes under any sapinda or prohibited relationship.

rumi saikia (none)     13 November 2011

My problem is that I am in a love with a boy who is relative of mine.

sir, so plz help me what should I do. Should I marry with him.Nobody
knows at my house.I am not getting courage to tell about our
relationship to my family.Even my boy friend is also worried regarding
our relationship.

I AM PRESENTING BELOW OUR RELATIONSHIP STATUS.

A MAN WHO HAD TWO SONSELDER SON RAM AND YOUNGER SON JADU.BOTH RAM
AND JADU GOT MARRIED.RAM HAD A DAUGHTER NAMED ANJU AND JADU HAD A SON
NAMED MOHAN
.ANJU GOT MARRIED TO OTHER CASTE i.e Non Assamese Man and she had a son named Raj Singh.I AM RUMI SAIKIA (ASSAMESE=HINDU) DAUGHTER OF MOHAN AND MY BOY FRIEND RAJ SINGH(NON ASSAMESE=HINDU) IS SON OF ANJU.

NOW PLZ TELL ME IS IT POSSIBLE FOR US TO GET MARRIED. OR WE SHOULD
SACRIFICE OUR LOVE.

N.B- PLZ NOTE THAT ANJU DAUGHTER OF  RAM MARRIED TO NON - ASSAMESE
BOY.SO MY BOY FRIEND IS ALSO NON-ASSAMESE.also plz let me know that does this type of marriage valid in ASSAM.Whether it is allowed ore it comes under any sapinda or prohibited relationship.

Dr. MPS RAMANI Ph.D.[Tech.] (Scientist/Engineer)     14 November 2011

Originally posted by Advocate Assumi

“--------------------- we all know what is prohibited relationships, but they exist in name only which is only a creation of the society mental set up--------“.

 

The above statement doesn’t say “cousins or cross cousins”. It is a flat statement.  Hence my question.

@Rumi Saikia:

I thought you have got the answer. Why still this hesitation?

 


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register