Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

B L (Deputy Manager- Training)     02 April 2013

Rights concerning resignation on medical grounds

Hello,

I resigned from my position yesterday on medical grounds with immediate effect/ prior to resigning, I had asked any oprions can be provide to me and teh HR informed the only option is to eitehr serve the full 1 month notice (as I am on probation) or  pay the shortfall. I read my appt. letter just now, and as per the policy, the org can also allow me to waiver or realx my notice period, but they arent doing so.

I had asked if I could work from home but was denied saying its not in the policy. I had also requested if I can come in late or take leave but I recieved a warning for my absentiem. due to this, I have been forced to resign

I have been advised to take rest for six weeks or else if my condition does not settle with medication, I may have to undergo surgery. This certificate has been provided to my employer, but they refuse to co-operate. I report to the General manager- HR hence I do not have a higher authority to go to except for the CEO.

Now the company has emailed me twice saying that I have to come and pay the short fall or else they will send a show-cause notice and a court order

My questions are:

Given the genuineness of my condition and a clause in my appointment letter which says that I can be allowed a relaxation or waiver, what  and how should be my next approach? Do I have any rights as per teh employment laws in India?

I have emailed time and agin that the company provide other options to me, but they have not provided any options. I dont want to pay the shortfall.What can be the repurcussions of this?

Thank you.

B.L



Learning

 14 Replies

Kumar Doab (FIN)     02 April 2013

What is your establishment: a Govt. company/PSU/Industrial Establishment/ commercial establishment……?

You are in which state?

In which state is redg. office /HO of the company?

The company must have displayed its registration certificate near entrance/on notice board.

 

You have posted that:

 

--“I read my appt. letter just now, and as per the policy, the org can also allow me to waiver or realx my notice period, but they arent doing so.”

 

“Do I have any rights as per teh employment laws in India?”

 

The waiver of notice period/pay is the right enjoyed by your employer. The employee can not claim it as a matter of right.

 

--“I dont want to pay the shortfall.What can be the repurcussions of this?’

 

Your liability is Maximum the payment of notice pay by you. Your company has also indicated it in its communications (verbal/written, as posted by you) to you.

 

--“I report to the General manager- HR hence I do not have a higher authority to go to except for the CEO.”

 

Before you escalate to CEO you may check all the communications exchanged so far, verbal or written, between you and the company, appointment letter, standing orders/HR policy/service rules/exit policy/severance policy/leave rules of the company and structure and draft your representation to CEO (under acknowledgment) in such a manner that your case display some merits and drills sense into the heads and you get some relief.

 

It shall be appropriate to show all documents to a competent and experienced labor consultant/service lawyer, give inputs in person, spend some quality time with your lawyer, understand the merits and proceed further once you are convinced on merits in your case. Let your lawyers opinion be final on all points discussed in this thread.

Let your lawyer remove and cover defects in your communications and exploit the defects and loopholes on the side of company.

 

--“I had also requested if I can come in late or take leave but I recieved a warning for my absentiem. due to this, I have been forced to resign”

 

Did you explain the reason in resignation submitted by you, concluding that you have been asked to resign or face (stigmatic) order of termination? Forced resignation may be termed deemed termination.

 

Has the company accepted your resignation with a copy/information to you (verbal/written)?

 

Did you apply for sick leave in writing (attaching copy of the medical certificate issued by the specialist doctor) and did the company decline to approve sick leave in writing?

 

Do you have the copy of leave policy of the company? Has the company described leave allowed to probationer in appointment letter?

 

Usually declinature to sanction sick leave supported by medical certificate is viewed as bad.

You could have requested to sanction sick leave as LWP. You could have requested that company may refer you to its specialist doctor.

 

Your company might have included in appointment letter that employment can be terminated due to prolonged absence including due to sickness.

 

 

---Designation alone does not decide employee is a workman or not. Your lawyer may ask you a set of structured questions and may opine that you fall within the category of workman. Labor laws applicable to workman limit the choice to employer.

In addition to the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, several states also provide for compliances under the Shops & Establishment Acts, Standing Orders Act, ……. If the employee falls within the definition which has been provided under these enactments, then the employee would be protected up to that extent.

Any policy in the larger interest and beneficial to both employer and the employee has the sanction of law as otherwise it will be easily termed as arbitrary.

 

 

If the IESO Act is applicable to your company and company has its certified standing orders extended to your designation, you may refer to these. If standing orders are not certified, model standing orders shall apply.

 

Model Standing Orders:

 

9. Leave.--………………………. shall issue orders on the application within a week of its submission or two days prior to the commencement of the leave applied for, whichever is earlier……………………….. If the leave is refused or postponed, the fact of such refusal or post postponement and the reasons there for shall be recorded in writing………… and if the worker so desires, a copy of the entry in the register shall be supplied to him.

 

13.          Termination of employment.:

 

(2)           No temporary workman whether monthly-rated, weekly-rated or piece-rated and no probationer or badli shall be entitled  to any notice or  pay in lieu thereof if his services are terminated

 

(This should imply no notice period/pay is applicable during probation)

 

 

14. Disciplinary action for misconduct:

(3) (e)      habitual absence without leave or absence without leave for more than 10 days,

 

{You have posted that “but I recieved a warning for my absentiem.”. If the company issued notice/warning for absenteeism (due to sickness) which is misconduct why it resorted to extract resignation? If at all there was absenteeism it was due to sickness, duly supported by medical certificate.}

 

15.          Complaints.--,  17.               Liability of 17[employer].,  18.            Exhibition of standing orders.--

 

 

--Refer to Shops and Establishments Act as applicable to your state.

e.g: The Delhi Shops and Establishments Act,

 

2.  DEFINITIONS.

(7)  “employee” means a person wholly or principally employed, whether directly or otherwise, and whether for wages (payable on permanent, periodical, contract, piece-rate or commission basis) or other consideration, about the business of an establishment and includes an apprentice…………

16. Leave means leave as provided for under this Act;

 

22. Leave.—(1) Every person employed in an establishment shall be entitled—

 (b)  in every year, to sickness or casual leave for a total period of not less than twelve days:

 

30. Notice of Dismissal:

 

(2) No employee who has put in three months’ continuous service shall terminate his employment unless he has given to his employer a notice of at least one month, in writing.

 

(This may imply that for service less than 3 months no notice period would apply.)

 

COMMENTS

(a) Applicability of section 30

The protection of the provisions of the section is available to all persons who fall within the definition of the term “employee” as given in section 2(7) of the Act and who have put in three months’ continuous services.  In the absence of any standing orders or any contract between the employer and the contesting respondent containing any particular terms or conditions, the conditions of service of the employee relating to his employment in an establishment at Delhi are covered by section 30(1) of Delhi Shops and Establishments Act, 1954

 

The SE Act does not indiscriminate between workman and non workman and is applicable to all employees.

 

Usually companies include the probationers also in the Group Mediclaim policy and deduct the premium from salary or include the premium in CTC of the employee.

 

If you are eligible for such policy you could have informed sickness to Insurance company/ Mediclaim helpdesk and submitted the bills within ………days ( as described in policy, say 7 days) after the treatment was over, for reimbursement of medical expenses, as allowed in the policy.

 

If you were included in any mediclaim policy your membership shall be terminated on the day your resignation is accepted. So hurry to submit the bills and buy a individual mediclaim policy and avoid break in insurance.

 

 

In case the CEO does not provide any relief you have no other option than to agitate in a forum where you are eligible to agitate.

The communications which company has sent to you on absenteeism demand to tender notice pay or face legal action must have been inserted in your personnel file, and shall become part of feedback on your tenure and reference check in future.

You should ensure that your personnel record is cleansed by the company.

 

Or

 

You may complete the negotiation with company and obtain concurrence that it shall withdraw its communications on absenteeism/misconduct and remove these and such notings from your personnel file, allow you to examine your personnel file, supply you the acceptance/declinature of leave application, resignation, service certificate, relieving letter (with good comments), attested copies of PF transfer forms, FNF statement showing recovery of notice pay, salary for days you have worked, PF number and that it shall not post adverse comments against you during reference check.

 

You may proceed as deemed fit at your end.

Valuable advice of learned experts/members is sought.

 


Attached File : 342367017 model%20standing%20orders.doc, 342367017 delhi shops & establishments act, 1954.pdf downloaded: 251 times

Sudhir Kumar, Advocate (Advocate)     02 April 2013

well elaborate by Mr Doab

Manish Kohale   01 April 2016

Hello There,

I am employee of one of the IT company, I am sufferring with Lumbor spondilities and going under treatment. But my doctor suggested to take complete rest and treatment to recover earliest. So on this ground i submitted the resignation on medical ground. As inform by HR and Senior Manager, I submitted the expert report as well. As per company rule normally have to serve 60 days notice period. But I requested for 30 days and also ready to pay 30 days shortfoll as well.But still company not allow me to release in 30 days. I request them for many times for the same with HR and Manager as well. Please suggest what shoud i do in this case where as i already submitted the resignation on 11th March 2016 also attaining the office regularly. Plesae advice in this issue.

Waiting for reply.

Regards,

Manish Kohale

Kumar Doab (FIN)     02 April 2016

Did you consult an able counsel specializing in labor/service matters before resigning or you nacted on your own.

 

Your counsel could have guided you well.

 

Has the expert doctor advised bed rest or declared you fit to resume duty?

 

Let your able counsel draft your reperesentations now than acting on your own.

 

 

 

Manish Kohale   04 April 2016

Hello Mr. Kumar,

I did not get what exactly you reply.

As per my Expert Doctor he suggested bed rest and medical treatment which is going on.

Also I have not consult to any  specializing in labor/service matters before resigning. 

I am not aware of this process.

Could you please suggest in this.

Regards,

Manish 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     04 April 2016

1. If the Specialist Dr has advised bed rest in writing, then why are you attending office? The managers or even employer can not ask to attend office if dr. has advised bed rest.

2. The resignation can be without approval, permission. Medical certificate is not a requirement to resign.

3. The notice period of 60 days may not be neccessarily applicable in your case even if it is inserted in appointment letter. The notice period is part of service conditions that are governed by various enactments and may not be more than 7/14/30 days  as per length of service and may be even NIL depending upon whether you are under probation period or confirmed and whether you/your designation are covered  by the applicable enactments.

 

4. An able labor Law consultant may ask you a set of structured questions and obtain information and  can opine finally in your matter.

 

You may hence consult.

IT/ITeS employee's union leaders, trade unions leaders can also guide you to an able counsel.

Srinivas   17 April 2016

Dear Sir, 

I work for a pvt ltd (hotel) in Tamilnadu, I had given my resignation on 06.04.2016 with 30days notice as per my appt letter . I stopped working from 12.04.2016  due to sick ( hemorrhoids ), I had to rest at home as per the doctor's advice. I might need to be operated if I don't rest for long. I have informed to my manager that I will not be able to continue at this situation over the phone as I might need to take extra time for rest. He is threatening me that he will file a case against me thinking that I prefer not to come back and work. I have been associated with this company for the past 11months and my designation with my sudden absence doesn't cause any damage to the organization and to its clients in terms of relationship nor any sort of revenue loss. Is there a way I can protect myself lawfully by producing valid medical certificates in case I cannot be fulfilling my notice period. Request your advice. 

Regards, 

Srinivas 

 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     18 April 2016

@ Srinivas,

 

Do you have copy of resignation and POD and acknowledgment/acceptance of resignation issued by company?

You have posted that; " I might need to be operated if I don't rest for long. I have informed to my manager"

 

Communicate in writing under proper acknowledgment that on dated...............you have informed Mr/Ms...............that....................your Dr...........................has advised bed rest......................and copy of Rx/Medical Certificate  is attached, and hence you have submitted for sick leave from dated.......................

 

Record all calls/meetings (audio/visual/witnessed/minuted).

 

Let the company reply to you as it wants; by phone/email/SMS/letter etc.

 

If you are unable to draft your communicatins properly, seek help from an able labor Law Consultant, elders of the family, employee's/trade union leader............

 

AS explained above "Designation alone does not decide employee is a workman or not. Your lawyer may ask you a set of structured questions and may opine that you fall within the category of workman. Labor laws applicable to workman limit the choice to employer.

In addition to the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, several states also provide for compliances under the Shops & Establishment Acts 9(Tamilnadu Shops & Establishment Act in your case and you may refer to clause on  'Notice of Dismissal'), Standing Orders Act, ……. If the employee falls within the definition which has been provided under these enactments, then the employee would be protected up to that extent."

 

If the compnay asks to join duty after getting fit and complete exit/handover formalities then you may do so.

Don't forget to supply under proepr acknowledgment the final resignation.

If you don't serve the full notice period write to adjsut notice pay in FnF statement/settlement, and supply correct FnF statement , payment of FnF dues as per correct FnF statement Form16 as per correct FnF statement, acknowledgment and acceptance of resignation, salary slip of each month,PF number with a/c slips,ESIC card, NOC/NDC, service certificate, relieving letter etc .

 

 

There are many threads on similar queries that you can search in search option on left hand side of this web page e.g;

 

https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/forum/How-and-where-to-lodge-a-complaint-against-a-employer-64348.asp#.VxSWutQrLIU

 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     18 April 2016

Become member of employee'/trade unions and be properly informed.Retain access to an able labor Law Consultant.

Srinivas   20 April 2016

Dear Kumar Daob, 

Thank you for the information, I shall follow as per the advice. 

Regards, 

Srinivas

 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     20 April 2016

You are welcome.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     20 April 2016

Post again if you still face difficulty

M Santhosh   05 July 2016

hi Team,

 

I am Santhosh working in Reputed organisation (BPO- Private Limited). During our joining we have signed on forms for 3 months notice period and in case of resigning early we were asked to buy out for each and every day.

Actually i am a diseased person with IGA Nephropathy(Kidney related) with no cure. Please do googl for more information on it. I need to serve my self and my family i had taken a risk to work in night shift. i am working from past 10 years and i had this attack 4 years back.

Now i got to know that the site is getting closed which is not yet anounced. so i had started searching for my jobs as a sage side. I got the job now and asking me to join in 1 month. I cant serve the 3 months notice period nor i can buy back. The other organisation is ready to buy back for 15 days i need to buy back for anothed 45 days which is equivalent to 45K.

Please share your expect suggestions on how to proceed further. I have all the medical certificates with me which proves that i am deseased but i am fit and fine as the disease wouldnt effect the person immediately.

Doctor suggested me to not to work in night shifts as it will not suit to my currect health conditions which i am still doing it. The new job is purely a day shift job. My Managers are not responding as they have to abide my companies policies.

How do i get waiver on my notice period. how do i quit.

 

Kumar Doab (FIN)     05 July 2016

@ M Santhosh,

 

You are in which state?

What is your designation and nature of duties?

You have worked for how many months?

Has the establishment communicated in writing about closure?

Has it offerred alternative employment?

Are you a member of Employee's/Trade Unions?

Is the notice period 90days for employer if employer initiates termination?

 

BPO are covered by Shops & Estbs Act of the state that was enacted to govern the service conditions of employees working in such establishments, and notice period is mentioned in the Act. Have you looked into it?

If exemption is not granted then standing orders (Model/Certified) may also apply.Do you know about exemption or application? Check at your end.

 

 

 

 


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register