Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

R.V.Seckar (Company Secretary)     23 February 2018

How daughter’s can get their share in the property of her fa

How Daughter’s can get their share in the property of her father?

X is grandfather and he had no children. He had lot of assets.  X brought up  A and B.   A had one son and four daughters.  B had two son and two daughters.  X was given advice that A’s son alone will safeguard the assets as per his horoscope. So , he adopted A’s son. But , the understanding was that both A and B will GET equal share of assets after the demise of X.  X expired . After some time , A expired.  There was row between B and A’s son and the High Court of Chennai held that A’s son is the adopted son of X. Hence , he is the legal owner of X’s assets. 

However , A’s son gave 40% of assets to B in order to avoid any further struggle.

While the case was in the High Court , A’s son obtained release deed from his four sisters on the promise that he will give due share to them. However , till date , he has not given any share of assets to his four sisters.

The main crux is even though X’s assets had to devolve on A and B equally  , for custom and religious belief sake , the same was given to A’s son. Hence , A’s son was just guardian of the assets of X instead of A or B. Further , A’s son  gave about 40% of assets to B . This implies if A is alive , he would have been the owner of 50% of  assets  of X and his daughter should have got their share of assets from A.  

Please advice whether the four daughters of A can revoke their release deed now as A’s son has failed to keep his promise to give their share of assets and a file a case against A’s son for their share of assets as he is only the guardian for the Xs assets as it was demonstrated from the fact that he have given 40% of Xs assets to B and circumstances of the case.

 



Learning

 4 Replies

Kumar Doab (FIN)     23 February 2018

Which personal law applies in this case e.g; Hindu?

A, B were adopted by X or not by valid adoption/deed?

Confirm!

Kumar Doab (FIN)     23 February 2018

You have posted that A’s son was adopted by X.

And the High Court has already decided the matter. The copy must be with you.

 

Generically Speaking; Apparently A’s son is not liable to give any share to anyone.

If A’s son has given any estate that devolved to him from his adoptive father by his sweet will then it is a personal matter of A’s son.

If other have released their estate/property by registered deed in favor of A’s son then it is a personal matter. They must have appeared before the registering authority in person and signed without any coercion, pressure…

The logic posted by you for cancellation of release deed is apparently without any legal force, logic.

Court alone can revoke deed on valid grounds, facts, merits.

You may approach a very able senior LOCAL counsel of unshakable repute and integrity specializing in civil matters and having successful track record………………and worth his/her salt, for a considered opinion on facts, merits, inputs in person.

 

Such counsels shall render good advise...

R.V.Seckar (Company Secretary)     23 February 2018

Dear Sir ,  

Thanks a lot .

Release deed is not registered . They got  it on stamp paper all the signatures of the daughers of A. 

Property given to B by A's son demonstrates that the adoption is only for safeguarding of assets of X and the real intention of hte adopter is to safeguard the assets. Actually , he intended to give it A and B but he was advised to adopt A's son as the assets will be safe in his hand.

We have to establish to the Court that adoption is only a scapegoat arrangement from the circumstances of the case.

Thanks a lot for your opinion

R.V.Seckar (Company Secretary)     23 February 2018

Dear Mr Kumar ,

Hindu law 

A & B were not adopted by an adoption deed. 

A's son was adopted by X by a legally valid registered document.

Thanks a lot 


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register