Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

D.Dakshina Moorthy (Sr.Office Superintendent)     23 February 2017

Conditional sale mortgage

Dear Sirs,

Kindly provide your valuable opinion regarding the following matter :

A Lady and her made an conditional sale mortage for their property to a person for Rs.80,000/-  As the sale was ostensible, the buyer made reconveyance deed - redemption mortage for the period of 5 years on the same day.  The sellers of the property stayed in the property.  The sellers paid Rs.41,000/-  and the buyer took the amount as Rent for the building. The time mentioned for the period of 5 years was completed. .The dispute case was processing  in .the court. meanwhile, the sellers dead and the legal heirs of the sellers taking the case in the court and the case was processing  between the buyer and the seller' legal heirs.  If the situation was being,  the buyer sold the property sold to another person. 

Kindly let me know that  :

While the reconveyance and redemption mortgate was pending in the court, the Second Sale was valid or not ? 

Eventhough, the time was barred debt for the redemption mortgage is over ( 5 years ) whether actual time of 30 years period to pay the debt for the redemption is allowed or not under Limitation Act.

As the first conditional mortgage was not considered, it was considered as Sale, based on that, the second sale was happened,  But the Release Deed was not produced at the time of registration of the second sale deed,  is there any possibility of previous sellers  legal heirs ( i.e. Grand Children ) will make property dispute against the second buyer for the recovery of the property ?  If so, what way they have to do ? 

Thanking you,

Yours truly,

 

( D.Dakshina Murthy )

 

 

 



Learning

 3 Replies

Pradeep Naik   24 February 2017

(1) Pending the suit the second sale is not valid.

(2) Actually the period of said 30 years starts from the date when right to redeem accrues, i,e, in this case when the period of 5 years ends, so it is allowed under Limitation Act.

(3) If the fact of the sale being condititional was not mentioned in the conditional sale deed itself and the reconveyance by first buyer was not registered then the seller's legal heirs can not dispute the subsequent sale.                                   

                                     But if the Conditional sale was properly made according to law then seller's legal heirs can file recovery suit against second buyer in civil court within 12 years from the date when they come to know about the second sale.

 

D.Dakshina Moorthy (Sr.Office Superintendent)     24 February 2017

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dear Sir,

Thanks to your reply. I request you to kindly provide the following :

(1) Pending the suit the second sale is not valid.

In this point, will it possible to make invalid of the second sale, to approac Sub-Registrar of the jurisdiction for cancelling the second sale or through court ?

(2) Actually the period of said 30 years starts from the date when right to redeem accrues, i,e, in this case when the period of 5 years ends, so it is allowed under Limitation Act.
 

In this question, if there is any case Law/order for the same, please mention/provide the same. 

(3) If the fact of the sale being condititional was not mentioned in the conditional sale deed itself and the reconveyance by first buyer was not registered then the seller's legal heirs can not dispute the subsequent sale.                                                                         But if the Conditional sale was properly made according to law then seller's legal heirs can file recovery suit against second buyer in civil court within 12 years from the date when they come to know about the second sale.

In this question, both conditional sale deed mortgage and reconveyance deed were done in the same day. Before making these two days, there is registered WILL in the name of the legal heirs of the first Seller.  Hence, in order to recovery of the property, apart from 12 years, is there any time limit to file the recovery of the property for the Grand Childrens ? 

With kind regards, 

 

( D.Dakshina Murthy )

 

 

 

dear 

sir

D.Dakshina Moorthy (Sr.Office Superintendent)     24 February 2017

Dear Sir, Thanks to your reply. I request you to kindly provide the following : (1) Pending the suit the second sale is not valid. In this point, will it possible to make invalid of the second sale, to approac Sub-Registrar of the jurisdiction for cancelling the second sale or through court ? (2) Actually the period of said 30 years starts from the date when right to redeem accrues, i,e, in this case when the period of 5 years ends, so it is allowed under Limitation Act.   In this question, if there is any case Law/order for the same, please mention/provide the same.  (3) If the fact of the sale being condititional was not mentioned in the conditional sale deed itself and the reconveyance by first buyer was not registered then the seller's legal heirs can not dispute the subsequent sale.                                                                         But if the Conditional sale was properly made according to law then seller's legal heirs can file recovery suit against second buyer in civil court within 12 years from the date when they come to know about the second sale. In this question, both conditional sale deed mortgage and reconveyance deed were done in the same day. Before making these two days, there is registered WILL in the name of the legal heirs of the first Seller.  Hence, in order to recovery of the property, apart from 12 years, is there any time limit to file the recovery of the property for the Grand Childrens ?  With kind regards,    ( D.Dakshina Murthy )      

 


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register