Can a boy marry to his aunt's sister's daughter(father's brother's wife's niece)


Is it possible to a boy to marry his aunt's sister's daughter (father;s brother's wife's niece )as a hindu

 
Reply   
 
Bangalore

Law does not permit it.  You will be marrying your sister.  You both are sapindas as you have common ancestor.  Such marriages are unlawful according to Hindu Marriage Act. Your kids will be born with congenital defects, please save our nation from it.


Total likes : 1 times

 
Reply   
 


Proprietor

First type the title properly. Aunt or Aunt's daughter ? Title says aunt. But your post says Aunt's daughter.

Also, this depends on the caste system in Hinduism. So, the answers to your question can ony be given on a generic basis.

The castes that follow Gotra system of the Seven Rishis of the past, have much stricter rules and methods.

SAPINDA as per hinduism happens when it is brother's daughter or mother's sister's daughter. 

But MUSLIMS practise sapinda. Boy marries his father's brother's daughter. As per hinduism, this is equal to marrying one's own sister.

But Muslims do not marry aunt's daughter. So, their rules are the REVERSE of Hinduism Rules.

 

So, in general, answers may be provided.

 

But, By aunt's daughter, whom do you mean ?

1.Father's Sister's daughter ?

2.Mother's Sister's daughter ?

3.Mother's Sister's sister-in-law's daughter ?

4.Father's Sister's sister-in-law's daughter ?

5. Father's brother's wife's Sister's daughter ?

6. Mother's brother's wife's Sister's daughter ?

 

As per hindu tradition, here is the answer ( General set. Not to be treated as answer if you belong to a caste that follows Gotra system of the Seven Rishis of the past )

 

1.Father's Sister's daughter ?-------------------Yes, permitted ( since her father is different gene pool )

2.Mother's Sister's daughter  ?------------------ NO. she is your sister. ( Shared genes of your mother's sister who has genes from the same father of your mother )

3.Mother's Sister's sister-in-law's daughter ?------------------ Yes. permitted.( since her father is different gene pool )

4.Father's Sister's sister-in-law's daughter ?----------------- Yes.permitted.( since her father is different gene pool )

5. Father's brother's wife's sister's daughter ?---------------  NO. To be treated as sister ( since her aunt is like your mother as she has married your father's brother )

6. Mother's brother's wife's sister's daughter ?--------------- Yes. permitted.( since her father is different gene pool )

 

ALL MEDICAL GENETIC DISEASE etc are taken out of proportion and blown to huge size in recent times.

The chart above has been in existence in India, for thousands of years and except for five out of one thousand children from such marriages, the rest are all healthy.

Choice is Yours. The chart above is the one followed in India for thousands of  years.

 

 
Reply   
 

Earlier i typed the same title and message but updated some missing text

 

@hapling hand - Accroding to you how her and mine ancestors are in blood relation they are totally different 

 
Reply   
 
Proprietor

If she is your aunt's NIECE ( her brother's daughter ), then YES, it is permitted

If she is your aunt's NIECE ( her sister's daughter ), then NO, it is NOT permitted

 
Reply   
 

why is it permitted in aunt's brother's daughter case 

and why not is in aunt's sister daughter case

 
Reply   
 
FIN

If there is custom (proven custom) that has attained legal sanction (as in some states, in some communities) then one can.

 
Reply   
 

@Natrajan  - Accroding to this i agree this point but her father is related to different gene pool .Hence, why it is not possible then.

 
Reply   
 
Proprietor

 

why is it permitted in aunt's brother's daughter case  and why not is in aunt's sister daughter case
 

AS PER HINDUISM's SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE PRACTISED FOR GENERATIONS AND THOUSANDS OF YEARS, AUNT ( YOUR FATHER's BROTHER's WIFE ) IS EQUATED TO YOUR MOTHER AND UNCLE ( FATHER's BROTHER ) EQUATED TO YOUR FATHER.

SO, AUNT's BROTHER IS SIMILAR TO YOUR MOTHER's BROTHER --- SO YOUR MATERNAL UNCLE.

MARRYING DAUGHTER OF MATERNAL UNCLE IS PERMITTED SINCE YOUR FATHER's GENE POOL AND YOUR MATERNAL UNCLE's FATHER's GENE POOL ARE DIFFERENT. 

 

BUT AUNT's SISTER is equated to YOUR OWN MOTHER's SISTER.

SO, MARRYING THE DAUGHTER OF YOUR AUNT's SISTER IS LIKE MARRYING YOUR OWN SISTER.

 

Hope this clarifies.

 

 

@Natrajan  - Accroding to this i agree this point but her father is related to different gene pool .Hence, why it is not possible then.
 

ANSWERED ABOVE.

 
Reply   
 

ok thanks close this query 

 
Reply   
 

LEAVE A REPLY


    

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  



 

Search Forum:








×

  LAWyersclubindia Menu

web analytics