Upgrad
LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Ranjeev (Partner)     02 September 2014

Banks indifference to sarfaesi act-2

Further to my earlier post under the same title in oct 2013 aggrieved by the banks harsh actions I filed a securitization application u/s 17 in the DRT requesting for acceptance of our revised OTS proposal by the bank and nullifying the wrong actions taken by the bank under sarfaesi act .DRT directed me to take the prospective buyer to the recovery officials of the bank to settle the matter amicably ,under the revised OTS proposal . The bank officials refused to meet the prospective buyer who was accompanying me for the meeting as directed by the DRT. The bank officials told us verbally that the valuation for Rs 5.50 crore has been done by their approved valuer and threatened to put up the property for auction. We returnedback agonized    and empty handed .After few days a friend informed me of the auction notice of my property in the newspaper for a reserve price of Rs. 4 crores to be held on 30/11/13 .It is important to note that we were not sent any information mandatory under the Sarfaesi Act.The said auction failed. The bank again put up my property for auction on revised reserve price of Rs.3.55 crore to be held on 28/2/13 again without informing us. We strongly objected this auction also informed the bank about the statutory liabilities / encumbrance for Rs.1 crore u/r 9(7)&9(9) enforcement rules 2002 vide our letter dated 5/2/14 requesting the bank to issue corrigendum to this effect. The bank neither replied back nor issued any corrigendum. We again sent a reminder for the same to the bank on 22/2/2014 . But no response by the bank. The second auction failed on 28/2/14 . Immediately on 1/3/14 they again put up my property for auction with revised reserve price of Rs 3 crore to be held on 31/3/2014 . It is important to mention here that the inspection date of my property was 24/3/2014 for the said auction . No potential buyer turned to inspect the said property on 24/3/2014 . Sensing no buyer the bank The bank hastily sold my property on 29/3/14 to an ARC , prior to the auction date without informing us. It is important to note that our revised OTS proposal was also of Rs 3 cr fresh as also declared in our SA in DRT. In April,2014 on my follow up with the bank officials about the fate of third auction, I was informed that my property/account was slot to ARC. When I enquired about the sale value no response was given.I fail to understand the following;

1) Can the bank put my property on auction below the valuation done by their approved valuer?

2) Was it not mandatory for the bank to send me notice regarding the auction, 30 days prior to the date of auction?

3) Was it not mandatory for the bank to issue a corrigendum prior to the second auction  dated 28/02/2014 when it was informed to them on 05/02/2014 and reminded on 22/02/2104?

4) Can the bank sell my property to an ARC without informing us?

5) Is it not mandatory for the bank to tell me the value at which my property/account is sold? Why is the bank hiding so?

6) How could the bank sell my property to ARC when my OTS proposal of the similar amount of failed third auction was pending with them?

 



Learning

 6 Replies

RAJU O.F., (Advocate)     02 September 2014

Please note that SARFAESI Act was enacted for recovery of dues of Banks & FIs; but 90 % of the bankers do not know what is the law and rules, in this respect. So they act according to their whims and fancies. If you engage a proper lawyer, who is expert in DRT & SARFAESI Act & Rules, he can convince the Tribunal (DRT) the wrong measures taken by the bank.

In the instant case, if the bank did not inform you prior to 30 days by Sale Notice AND if publication of Sale not made prior to 30 days the said auction can be set aside. In your case, not the property, your account is sold to ARC along with all the rights vested with the said bank. They need not inform you the amount of such transaction, nor it is compulsory for them to inform you, prior to such assignment. Unfortunately, that is the provisions under Sections 5 & 6 of te Act. Such provisions are used for the benefit of the officials of bank & ARC, since practically no body is there to question their actions. Bank would have sold your loan asset for a meagre amount. In order to ascertain the sale value you may try to get certified copy of the assignment deed.

You may go through recent judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court, reported in 'Debt Recovery Tribunal Cases', {2014(2)DRTC 153 (S.C.)- Vasu P.Shetty Vs. Hotel Vandana Palace &ors.

Ranjeev (Partner)     02 September 2014

Thanks for your valuable response & suggestions. Kindly mail me your views on my earlier post.

Ranjeev (Partner)     02 September 2014

My earlier post was titled as Bank's Indifference to SARFAESI Act.

Ranjeev (Partner)     02 September 2014

My earlier post was titled as Bank's Indifference to SARFAESI Act.

Ranjeev (Partner)     02 September 2014

My earlier post was titled as Bank's Indifference to SARFAESI Act.

Ranjeev (Partner)     02 September 2014

My earlier post was titled as Bank's Indifference to SARFAESI Act.

Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register