rti unsatisfactory reply
rob
(Querist) 23 August 2016
This query is : Resolved
I have filled rti application to naib tehsildar lehra, Sangrur, Punjab and asked for certified copies of the following
1. Copy of jamabandi 2004-2005, khewat no xxx, village xyz
2 state the land share owned by all land owners in this khewat in kanal -Marla , not in fractions as mentioned in jamabandi
3 state the reason why pati is changed in new jamabandi
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reply from naib tehsildar:-
As under rti act 2005, only record is provided which is available only in our office and no reply is given of questions under rti act. If you want copy of jamabandi then get it from fard kendar , on any working day.
---------------------------------------------------
I think naib tehsildar has not given any information and puzzled that how to get information. So what fill in appeal to FAA. Is he speaking true or my rti is wrong
kavksatyanarayana 
(Expert) 23 August 2016
if you feel any doubt that the reply is not proper, you can appeal to the next appellate authority under RTI. but there are several practical problems to the PIO to supply the required information and hence he gave opportunity to verify the record. after getting the required information, you can ask them to supply that particular information instead other information.
rob
(Querist) 24 August 2016
Kavksatyanayana , I am not satisfied with your advice
Rajendra K Goyal
(Expert) 24 August 2016
If not satisfied, send first appeal to appellate authority.
Sudhir Kumar, Advocate
(Expert) 25 August 2016
your query was that you asked under RTI
"state the reason why pati is changed in new jamabandi"
this question is not admissible in RTI.
Sudhir Kumar, Advocate
(Expert) 25 August 2016
you also asked under RTI
"1. Copy of jamabandi 2004-2005, khewat no xxx, village xyz
2 state the land share owned by all land owners in this khewat in kanal -Marla , not in fractions as mentioned in jamabandi
"
Such information is already available in public domain. One can get this copy from Patwari. This provision had been thee since last 250 years when there was no RTI.
